Hotels in NYC?

When I went three of us shared a flat we found in Loot, UK free ads paper, weird basement flat with insane heating, owned by a profeshional prankster who wanted part payment in cuban cigars. $60 a night which split three ways was very economical. OK it was 96th two blocks west of broadway so not in the thick of things, but next to the red line express subway stop. Had bonkers heating, the bathroom was on the other side of the hall and a doorman called Eddie. You get the feeling that all newyork doormen should be called Eddie.

(your link didn't work)

(neither did yours)

I will point out that you probably don't want to bother unless you've got cash burning in your pocket though. It's not Ritz level but it's not cheap.

I'm liking Kate's suggestion, though. I'd do my own research, but you guys are doing such a bang-up job. I'd thank y'all profusely, but I don't want to sound obsequious. (Though using "obsequious" makes me sound prententious.) (Ah, I should've saved this material for another post.)

My God, I feel like Mahir - "I Kiss You!"

Otherwise, I stayed at the Iroquois. Every R&R biog book I have read has the band staying there. James Dean, The Clash, Andrew Loog Oldham, etc.... but the most memorable quote was Mick Jones "What is this shithole" and Tony Wilson from the Factory Records book "the shithole next to the Algonquin".

It aint as bad as that.. (Apart from the Last Room available which has the boiler in it, which in return for using we got a concessionary rate on a decent room in the hotel).

What's your Yah name?

friend of mine strongly recommends the Brooklyn Bridge Marriott - anyone second that or have other suggestions? how cheap does it get? budget's getting tighter i think...

theyre both like 125 a night.

There was no hot water at all, the room was boiling hot, the bed was hard as a rock.

AVOID.

whoa... that's some splurge. but yeah, the soho and tribeca grands aren't really all that nice or worth the pricetags. the rooms at the tribeca are tiny, but they come with DFA cds....

User rating:
New York City: Hotel Riverview: "The place is a dump - AVOID!"
September 23, 2004: A TripAdvisor Member, Washington, DC

The place is a dump. The rooms are tiny (about the size of a closet), don't have AC, and the TVs rarely get proper reception. The shared showers / toilets are filthy, and the staff is rude. Aside from being a rundown hangout for transvestite prostitutes and drug users, it is also used as an S.R.O. hotel by the city to place homeless people. There is little security, no room service, and a rarely working elevator. Safety and health are questionable. AVOID THIS HOTEL! Just pay an extra 20 bucks a night for a real hotel, it will be worth it.

(I live here)

It's dirty but it's cheap.

http://nymag.com/travel/features/34731/

BTW if you don't want the luxury of the Hyatt, there's a cheaper hotel in Jersey City - I think the Marriott Courtyard, that's spitting distance from the Pavonia PATH train (the one right across the water from NYC)

Actually, it might not be cheaper.

the prices in that article are not accurate.

i can't remember the name of the place i stayed last time i stayed in manhattan, it was fairly cheap, had my own bathroom and was within walking distance of the bowery ballroom.

i still say priceline is best bet cause you choose stars in addition to price. i once got a nice room at hilton for like $100 during a holiday weekend.

i did that with hotwire once and was stuck down in the financial district!

from what i've heard anecdotally, priceline might get you a good deal in some pretty good hotels, but they usually stick you in their least attractive rooms

also, it's not uncommon to find cheap hotel rooms in big cities over summer or winter weekends when locals go out of town

through the hotel itself

yikes! priceline lets you pick neighborhood(s), which can be helpful but you have to pay attn to the boundaries of the neighborhoods you choose (my mom got a hotel by the u.n. once when she picked "midtown east" which i know isn't THAT far a walk from trains, but she does not know the city, gets nervous, etc.).

why would locals affect hotels? they're not staying in them!

they don't, necessarily, but they're indicators of how attractive the destination is at that particular time

comparatively-speaking

yeah my hotel was supposedly in "soho"!! it was down like on wall st! v strange :\

that's totally subjective, though... i think in general ppl want to get away for the weekend, whether that means a city person going to a nice b&b in the country or a suburbanite visiting the 'big city' for their long weekend. i don't think that says anything about how attractive the destination itself is, just who's going to be there. i.e., when the locals get out the tourists come in, but don't they usually call that a peak time and jack UP the price?

that was an xp i did not mean the definition of soho was subjective ;)

hahhahaha i was gonna say...next yr gonna be claiming jersey city as part of soho...

yes and i also live in the e. village lol

my mom got a hotel by the u.n. once when she picked "midtown east"

well that's technically correct unless they want to get down to the "tudor city" level of specificity

yes, it is correct. i didn't say it wasn't, but when someone from out of town thinks 'midtown' they forget the outer avenues because they're not really familiar with the area and are thinking of midtown east as grand central, etc. hence, checking the map first before selecting neighborhood so you realize/remind yourself that you may not be 1 block from 'everything' when you pick midtown.

Hotel 31! Bargain, and where I'm staying again later this summer.

Also, the Chelsea Star near MSG. When I stayed almost a couple of years ago they were undergoing fitting new apartment rooms. They let me stay in one of them at no extra cost, cheap as anything.

kevin, you were maybe at the off soho suites...?

ok ok so i need a double with like an extra sofabed kind of thing (3 grown women). 300 range. for oct 6. how do i make this happen?

Wow, I stayed at the Sohotel on Broome St. in 2003 for about $100/night in 2003, and now it's $200+ a night on average!? Anyway, I kinda liked it.

http://nymag.com/travel/features/34731/

^does someone know where this article went?

was it this one?

http://nymag.com/urban/guides/nyonthecheap/travel/hotels.htm

thanks

My in-laws are coming to NY for a week in late September and RS and I will be joining them for part of that time. Since there will be 5 of us total and for a whole week I was wondering if a week long apt rental might be the most economical option. Does anyone know anything about this type of thing and have any recs?

BUMP

Anyone? Anyone? Bueller?

second home on second avenue, maybe. it's a very small b&b kind of place in the east village. they have a couple of suite-type rooms that sleep 2-5 people, and prices are supposed to be very reasonable.

i don't have any specific recs for apartment-letting services, although there are a quite a few of them according to google.

People put apartments to sublet on craigslist all the time!

also, a lot of the agencies put their sublets on craigslist as well as their own sites.

with parents involved, i think i'd feel a bit better going through an agency and having an office to contact in case anything goes wrong. plus you don't have to worry about an illegal sublet.

yeah, or some weirdo dropping in on you

http://www.newyorkology.com/archives/2008/09/ill_take_new_yo.php
http://www.newyorkology.com/archives/2008/09/38anight_hostel.php

ymca in great neck: $57

HOTEL 17!!!!

That was the name of the place I was trying to remember.

my parents are coming and would like to stay in a bed and breakfast, in brooklyn. they don't want to spend mad $$$ but are also not totally poor. anyone know of any good ones? i found a few (one they are most interested in is down the street from dmr!), but i guess you can never tell with these things based on websites.

rip gabbneb

O_o

teh gab gave me some nice seattle tips

does anyone know about union square inn? my parents made a res there and they are not super fancy needy or anything but they also want me to go check it out to make sure it's ok. but i keep forgetting/running out of town. now i don't want to go to manhattan for the rest of the weekend.

i know nothing about new york, but if you want leonard cohen to write a song about the time you sucked him off, it'll have to be the chelsea
― Geoff, Monday, July 16, 2001 8:00 PM (7 years ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

lol

does anyone know anything sub-$100 near columbia and the 116th st subway? other than the L Hostel?

i stayed at a place around 107th there once that was cheap? i forget the name... it was a few years ago :(

Hotel 17 it is!

Hotel 17 is awesome. I love that place.

But watch out for the clanging radiators.

Ha.

We strolled back past the Iroquois hotel (where we first stayed, clanging rads and all), but it's now poshed up to Algonquin standards.

I take it the Gershwin hotel is still, um, the Gershwin?

ha, i'm in hotel 17 for new year yay!

Damn, everyone's gonna be at the Hotel 17 and I'm gonna be in Istanbul.

(my hotel is PAISLEY - I have come to believe that everything in Istanbul is paisley)

this will be my first time in hotel 17, the past two visits i've been at hotel 31.

and i shall remember to carry my passport around with me, as last time i got 'i deed' in every pub i went into.
cue look of surprises on big doormans faces with "you're 34?"

know of any good sublet apartments anybody? for a week around oct..

guys i am coming short-term for a wedding and suddenly it hit me that i don't want to sleep on people's couches i want to be Grown Up and stay in a..... Bnb? AirBnB? hotel?

what should i do?

Check out The Jane, a cool hotel (with tiny but mega-efficient rooms). It's near the new Whitney Museum on the west side. The staff wear bellhop uniforms! I stayed there last year around this time for $70 a night. Rates rise with the temps, of course, but if you're going to NYC during the winter this may be the best hotel deal in town.

Unless I’m bringing the kid I use the app hotel tonight and stay in a hotel in New York. Kid implies kitchen and second bedroom which makes the hassle and negative externalities of Airbnb worth it.

Jane looks good! having my own bathroom @ $100 more per night though hmmm

Will try Hotel Tonight - i'm assuming i can book in advance if I want to though?

They wythe hotel is expensive but dope

I go to the rooftop bar sometimes. It’s in my neighborhood.

lol i've been to that rooftop bar. no way in hell am i even looking up the prices of that place.

the ludlow beside katz's deli is really nice, expensive tho. i mean nyc is weird, the rates seem to fluctuate wildly and the times of year it's cheap/expensive are surprising. i've seen the holiday inn clocking in at more than fairly upmarket places on occasion.

afaik as a fairly regular visitor airbnb is p much dead in nyc. i stopped using it a few years ago after some property inspector came and hammered eviction notices on the door every day, the place wasn't particularly nice either, and i got older and my circumstances improved. it seems to me it had all become dodgy/shark types on airbnb after that.

it's a shame as the first time i visited nyc as an adult, about 6/7 years ago, i stayed in an ensuite room in williamsburg on grand st for about 60 pounds a night. it was shared with the host but he left the downstairs entirely to visitors and was away for most of my stay anyway. think those days are gone, though i've had good experiences with airbnb recently in remote european towns, somebody renting out their mom's apartment, picking you up at the station, recommending restaurants etc. but mostly whatever human spirit made airbnb quite fun and fresh is gone i think.

not from the world, just from airbnb.

I think the prices are jacked up now but there were a few decent rates at usually pricey hotels a while back with the "one night" app, probably a different one than caek is mentioning. I ended up at the east village location of The Standard for a decent price. The caveat being the ability to book a room goes live at 3pm or so for that night

looks like they've changed it so you can book at noon, but given the list of hotels on there, probably fewer deals unless you're heading to nyc in the winter season

it's next month so.. deals might be had

The Refinery is fun.

not in my price range i'm afraid :(

i've now been told by a source:

Brooklyn: the Nu hotel
New York: Assemblage Downtown, the Roger Smith, The Ace

oh, this is for the march thing in gpoint? ( I will be missing it). The last time I had to book hotels for family I ended up just doing Fairfield Inn in Astoria/near LGA. which is totally fine and normal priced. It's kind of in a dead spot but they have a free shuttle to LGA, the Astoria Blvd stop and free parking. Everything in ny got soooo pricey. From there you can still walk to steinway etc or use the saved money to carservice it.

oh and this worked for me since I had moved to astoria, maybe some of the other fairfield inns in the city will be normal priced too.

the ace rooms were ok-ish but the lobby is apparently an coworking space. if you're just passing through there, it's fine, but the ability to enjoy the lobby is a nice thing for me when the rooms are intentionally smaller and every damn seat was taken all day

fwiw a couple years ago when I was there I stayed at the midtown hilton, the east village standard, and the ace midtown if you end up wondering about anything in those areas

this is fucking crazy, all these places are like $200-300+ per night

the last-minute hotel app thing caek mentioned has rooms for like 90

yeah the ones you're listing are not cheap?

think I checked out this thread a couple years ago before I booked travel (and used email promos, etc) and a couple of the old favorites have been remodeled into boutiques now

yeah i did not realize!

i remember the good old days of comedy nights at the gershwin. it was like a cheap boutique hostel

I totally stayed at the Gershwin when it was a hostel in like the late 90s. That was such a good deal.

Ah there are a ton of references to the gershwin above, ha.

Ppl in my neighborhood seem to still Air bnb regularly but in their own homes which probably puts them safely within the requirements. Still, I see a TON of European tourists in Bed-Stuy all the time.

Hotel tonight started out only offering bookings in the next seven days and that’s all I ever used it for, but it offers further out now. It’s using the same data feed as kayak and Expedia and whatever. It’s just a nicer app and more “curated” list.

i sense your pain in using that word caek, and i sympathize with it

crud

I had an email with a hotel deal and was considering booking a few days in early April, with the idea that if my workplace comes through and pays for me to go to a conference I'd get my stay reimbursed. if not, I just use it for my own vacation

but the prices went up to the point where I'm not going to do that. crossing my fingers for the conference!

the *conference rate* for the recommended hotel is $329/night lol

In Orbit - yes i'm baffled/amazed at the number of Euro tourists too! It's like there was a really popular German TV show set in Bed Stuy and they're making a pilgrimage or something.
But I would recommend it Tracer!

heeey I'm going to that conference! going to probably get one of the day-of deals on fri/say after it (and will be back here looking for ideas), but will be staying at the conference hotel the rest of the week

now to seek out our most recent nyc area meetup thread...

In Orbit - yes i'm baffled/amazed at the number of Euro tourists too! It's like there was a really popular German TV show set in Bed Stuy and they're making a pilgrimage or something.
But I would recommend it Tracer!

― Priory, Tuesday, February 12, 2019 7:45 PM (one month ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I'm traveling to a few other cities soon and I've been agonizing over where to stay, what neighborhood, hotel v Air bnb, etc, and now when I walk through the streets of New York I'm like, you know, I don't blame people for wanting to stay in Bed-Stuy for the same reasons that I love living there--it's quiet, it's scenic, it's on a good train line. And these days there are plenty of coffee shops and restaurants and boutiques and local businesses to enjoy.

mh, give me your dates and I'll see what I can free up! I go out of town a lot now but let's see.

I'm in town April 1 - 7, with activities on the 2nd through 5th. I'm guessing I'll be free evenings on the 3rd/4th/5th and just bumming around town until my flight leaves the evening of the 7th

oh yeah, the relevant detail: I'll be staying in Chelsea. Probably the opposite side of the world for most people around the area, but.. when work's footing the bill..

in orbit, you are still in the same house that you have been in for like over 5-6 years? ground floor? I think I have been there once. It is very pleasant.

Second floor but otherwise yes! Eight and a half years now iirc. You could come over again, I'll be home this weekend and I think next weekend too.

Oh but when I used to throw myself birthday parties my downstairs neighbor would let me use her apartment because it has access to the patio. Maybe that's what you're thinking of?

ha, i won't be back in town until June. But maybe I can actually motivate to see a bunch of people when the weather is nice and shit.

xpost YES, I remember hanging out in a kitchen downstairs.

Love staying at the Jane, with one exception it’s the only place I’ve stayed when taking myself to New York. Thinking about hotels today for no evident reason. Maybe I’ll travel again someday! What a concept.

any good new options or suggestions? looking at coming up with the 13-year-old, so need two beds. going to be doing a bunch of tourist shit but staying right in downtown manhattan seems potentially overwhelming. should i be looking in the village? chelsea? brooklyn? i realize these are annoying questions but i am dumb about nyc, sorry

the jane looks really cool but the rooms are so small and it looks like all their public spaces are under renovation. also wonder if the teen could deal with communal bathrooms lol.

if you can find a generic business hotel in the financial district in your budget then that is what I usually recommend, good transit links and if you're coming at the weekend then it's relatively quiet and cheap. hotels further north in Manhattan tend to cost more, and midtown is a bit intense.

the Hampton inn downtown Brooklyn is reliable and fine with kids if you just need somewhere to sleep and eat breakfast and get on the subway. otherwise the downtown Brooklyn hotels are on the expensive side. bizarrely more expensive than the equivalent hotel in Manhattan.

I've stayed at the Evelyn (was the Gershwin) in nomad. not an especially pretty neighborhood, but fine and may be more conveniently located than the financial district. a bit more expensive than the jane.

also the app hotel tonight is good, although they don't make it easy to find double rooms.

We stayed at the Hampton Inn in Chelsea last year when we took our 12 year-old to NYC. Picked that one because it was halfway between Financial District (where my wife had to work a couple days) and all the touristy shit we wanted to do. Worked perfectly for a place to sleep and grab a quick breakfast in the morning before heading out for the day.

Hampton inn (as a chain) will also guarantee connecting rooms if you request those at booking, which is why we often end up there.

There are buckets of new hotels in bk from the ace at the high end to the Even (???) at the low end; close to the blue green red n orange lines so u can get to whatever side of manhattan u want.

There is something to staying in a midtown hotel if it’s ur kids’ first time in the city. Concrete bunghole and whatnot

thanks all! i was also looking at the hotel indigo in brooklyn as it's right next to the L line

If i may w-bug is not that great a visit these days in terms of… hipness? Idk williamsburg is a drag

Also ur marrying urself to the L train (or g to the e/m) which may not be operating in a reliable way

There's an Air B&B hotel (it's a hotel, but all bookings are handled by Air B&B) in the Lower East Side called "Untitled at 3 Freeman Alley" that's actually very reasonably priced. It's about a two block walk away from the 2nd Ave. station on the F.

everyone who lives here recommends staying in hotels in Brooklyn to save money, which makes sense, but I don't know if they realize that downtown brooklyn/williamsburg hotels are no cheaper and often more expensive than the Manhattan equivalents.

thanks all! i was also looking at the hotel indigo in brooklyn as it's right next to the L line

― na (NA), Wednesday, February 7, 2024 1:37 PM

some friends of friends stayed there recently and they did not like it iirc

eh, I haven't been since 2019 but unless you're doing something late night/early morning and don't want to limp back to a hotel, staying in Manhattan and bouncing over to Brooklyn for the day wasn't that inconvenient

Not cheap (but not uber-expensive either) is the Maritime Hotel. Good location (Meatpacking District, w. 16th St.), cozy lobby to lounge in plus neat round windows in each room.

The Andaz Bryant Park, across the street from the NY Public Library, may be pricier but would be a good home base and is a really cool hotel.

Archer and The Refinery are also both in the garment district (just south of Times Square), so you have the midtown home base for getting around but on streets that aren't hectic.

Doubletree Financial District was totally fine, reasonably priced.

Stayed here this past summer, thought it was good and very um contemporary Brooklyn. Same group owns other Brooklyn hotels
https://theboxhousehotel.com/"> https://theboxhousehotel.com/