Paxton vs. Pullman

pullman's a quality bro, but ive been a die-hard paxton partisan for years and will vote for him with relish

Bill Pullman was Lonestar, therefore he wins everything.

paxton.

though pullman's fake sax playing in lost highway will always have a place in my heart.

man, these two are fuckin a
shit, i cant even choose

Voting Pullman because I think Paxton's gonna walk this but really they're both winners as far I'm concerned.

Greil Marcus has written about Pullman like he's Marlon Brando or somebody, but I don't have any sense of him at all, beyond that he starred in an insane David Lynch film. I liked Paxton in A Simple Plan and Twister (I don't remember much about One False Move, and should look at that again).

Only one of these men is motherfucking King of New York

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWli7LeYQuU&feature=related

go ahead, vote pullman

http://media.dvdtown.com/images/displayimage.php?id=13820

i dare you

http://content6.flixster.com/photo/11/38/30/11383028_gal.jpg

omg Abbott OTM x1000

so glad I voted Pullman

Paxton 4 Lyfe

I've liked Pullman in some stuff, but he was the worst SNL host I've ever seen. Paxton by a fucking mile.

I can't decide if Pullman should be docked for that "oh my fiancee is leaving me to meet a guy she's never spoken to on the empire state building well swell i'll pick up the tab" scene in sleepless in seattle or given points for somehow surviving it

i forget he was also in spaceballs and ruthless people, too. I think the SNL nightmare makes me forget he's been decent, but Paxton can fucking own the screen, and I can't say that about Pullman (sax solos aside)

also if Bill Pullman has ever been part of a new wave duo who credited judge reinhold for whistling on their album, someone should let us know

For Spaceballs and Lost Highway, I have to pick Pullman. Don't think I can name a single Bill Paxton movie.

you can't name aliens? or titanic? or weird science?

you can't name aliens? or titanic? or weird science?

lol forgot about chet!

http://cinemade.startlogic.com/weirdsci-paxton.gif

geezus he's been in some awesome flicks, don't make Paxton sound like he's fucking Richard Grieco!

he was even in that shitty Twister movie

http://blueprintreview.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/near-dark-bill-paxton.jpg

From wikipedia:
Paxton has the distinction of being one of only two actors, the other being Lance Henriksen, who has starred alongside an Alien, a Predator, and a Terminator. He further holds a distinct honor of being the only actor to have been "killed" by all three, as each of his characters in these films meets his end during conflict with the lead antagonists.

game over

god near dark is so fucking great

Paxton, despite being in Titanic, should win this.

part of me wants bigelow to squander all her post-oscar middlebrow good will by showing these vampire pretenders how it's done

she already did!

oh well good.

Bigelow is doing the Osama Bin Laden movie next actually..

Despite Frailty, Near Dark and a few others, it's gotta be Pullman.

paxton 4 eva

oh man i forgot about coconut pete

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mtrjUyoGzN4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEclreHys-Q

"fuck that guy...son of a son of a bitch!"

TS: Bill Paxton / Will Patton v. Bill Pullman / Jeff Daniels

― David R. (popshots75`), Tuesday, June 21, 2005 9:24 AM (5 years ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

Pullman for managing to deliver that speech in Independence Day without laughing.

fish heads

okay, i had no idea paxton had anything to do with fish heads. this just isn't fair to pullman anymore.

so far the argument for pullman, afaic
the sax shit in Lost highway
he was funny in ruthless people
he stood next to some funny people in spaceballs
young boys twirled around him in newsies
he got through a bad speech in ID4
he got through a bad scene in Sleepless in Seattle
i also believe he's done some theater

this against the director of both Fish Heads and Frailty, who has been murdered by a terminator, alien and predator, and played the most bad-ass vampire in the most bad-ass vampire movie. plus he's played the lead in a bunch of solid b movies, supreme goofballs in weird science and the dark backward, "coconut pete" in a broken lizard movie, managed to hold his own against three wives for a handful of seasons on HBO, yeah c'mon people.

also, martini ranch.

this poll has inspired me to watch Near Dark, which I've been meaning to get around to for a while now tbh

Near Dark by itself makes Paxton the winner, not to mention Alien, but ever since that Greil Marcus shit I've been a pretty big Pullman defender, like he seemed really hurt and confused about his American berserk face.

Not only did young boys twirl around him in Newsies, you boys also twirled him around in Newsies!

you boys, you!

Poor Pullman.

http://inthenameofmovies.files.wordpress.com/2009/08/while-you-were-sleeping.jpg

i haven't seen this movie but i find it weird that he's holding her in the air above the subway tracks. that's just not safe.

Bill Paxton = motherfucker who looks like he has some secrets

i think bill will happily tell you all of that shit

Bill Paxton motherfucker who looks like he has some crazy stories about getting drunk with jim cameron in 1983

I had no idea Nathan Patrelli had an acting career prior to "Heroes"!

As an eight-year-old, Bill Paxton was in the crowd waving when President John F. Kennedy emerged from the Hotel Texas in Ft. Worth, Texas, on the morning of Nov. 22, 1963. There are pictures at the Sixth Floor Museum in Dallas where the young Paxton can clearly be seen astride the shoulders of an unidentified man.

oh man, you should check out his TV series Profit, so ridiculous

paxton in a walk. pullman is a dork

RONG, Bill Pullman all the way. Who cares if Paxton was killed by Alien/Predator/Terminator? Pullman would've kicked all their asses, that's why he wasn't cast in the first place!

Nah, Pullman in Lost Highway is fab though

Alien/Predator/Terminator? Pullman would've kicked all their asses
Alien/Predator/Terminator? Pullman would've kicked all their asses
Alien/Predator/Terminator? Pullman would've kicked all their asses
Alien/Predator/Terminator? Pullman would've kicked all their asses
Alien/Predator/Terminator? Pullman would've kicked all their asses
Alien/Predator/Terminator? Pullman would've kicked all their asses

Pullman would just play a dude that got mistaken for Michael Douglas in those movies...

YOU ARE A DORK COZEN.

I have seen While You were Sleeping. It's . . . not good.

no but compared to pretty much every other romcom since it pretty much rules.

oh man, you should check out his TV series Profit, so ridiculous

I really wish HBO would serialize Stephen King's "The Stand"...so I could forget the crappy watered down cable miniseries

I didn't realize you hadn't seen Near Dark, Traveller, Frailty, Trespass, A Simple Plan...also I got a soft spot for middle-american secret-weirdo actors like Paxton, Dennis Quaid, Jeff Daniels, etc

― da croupier, Sunday, June 19, 2011 8:50 AM (10 hours ago) Bookmark

^^ was said to me in response to my Paxton diss in the HBO thread that helped inspire this thread and uh...it's more or less right since the only one of those i've seen is A Simple Plan, which i liked but don't necessarily think rested on Paxton's shoulders.

Spaceballs is probably doing a lot of the heavy lifting in my preference for Pullman, and i love Zero Effect if not so much for his performance

fun fact of no relevance whatsoever: Bill Paxton played Wyatt Earp's brother in Tombstone the year before Bill Pullman played Bat Masterson's brother in Wyatt Earp

Pullman's such a dullard, I don't know what he's really good for, aside from maybe being like the poor man's Michael Douglas, in the same way that Charlie Sheen used to be the poor man's Tom Cruise. (Except that Sheen was always BETTER than Cruise, even back in the days when Tom was the crazy one.)

Paxton, though - classic alone for the bits in Aliens when he goes all sissy. And for being dosed with angel dust while filming Titanic.

feel like this is the reason ilx polls exist tbh

you are correct sir

abbott just likes pullman because he lost his sense of smell in college after an injury left him in a coma for two days.

christ people, pullman for the serpent and the rainbow.

inexplicably, pullman is going to be in the new season of "torchwood" they're doing on starz. he's the villain, so that lowers the likelihood of him making out with john barrowman to say 30% or so.

I have seen While You were Sleeping. It's . . . not good.

aw i loved this movie back in the day, me and mom would watch it all the time. bill pullman's grandma was the suffragette mom from mary poppins!

in the movie, i mean. if it was in real life that might change my vote

From wikipedia:
Paxton has the distinction of being one of only two actors, the other being Lance Henriksen, who has starred alongside an Alien, a Predator, and a Terminator. He further holds a distinct honor of being the only actor to have been "killed" by all three, as each of his characters in these films meets his end during conflict with the lead antagonists.

― da croupier, Sunday, June 19, 2011 6:17 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

game over

― aero w. smith (Neanderthal), Sunday, June 19, 2011 6:24 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark

I like Pullman but c'mon

"What do you mean, *They* cut the power? How could they cut the power, man? They're animals!"

abbott just likes pullman because he lost his sense of smell in college after an injury left him in a coma for two days.

― mookieproof, Monday, June 20, 2011 2:26 AM (5 hours ago) Bookmark

wow...that makes him starring in While You Were Sleeping kind of fucked up

Pullman was in Zero Effect, and Paxton wasn't. But I still got to give it to Paxton despite the high number of flaming turds in his cv.

blurring the distinction between "despite" and "because of"

Oh shit i just remembered: Paxton was even in The Groove Tube way back in the '70s! No fucking contest (plus I already voted anyways.)

anosmic friend to newsies
this man is living my ideal life

paxton no contest

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Bill Paxton why because he look intresting (as a vampire)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zk_ZfUI4oPg

MARTINI RANCH

OK, someone here *has* to have seen this...

http://www.critcononline.com/images/brain%20dead%201990.jpg

Which Bill survives?

remember, a vote for Pullman = a vote for hen fap

this may be the most important poll in ilx history.

18 more hours to run a smear campaign

bah... picture didn't load

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51PC0KY68DL._SL500_AA300_.jpg

If Pullman wins this, I'm quitting ILX. Ok probably not, but I'll be unhappy.

I really don't think you need to worry about that happening.

Add The Last Seduction to that Pullman list.

He's been doing a lot of plays--would like to see how he does there.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

pullman should have morphed into paxton in lost highway, not that balthazard guy

results too close, imo release the names of Pullman voters and let a tribunal decide their fate...

the good guys won

doesn't matter, it's the principle

http://www.gonemovies.com/WWW/TopFilms/Godfather/MichaelEinde.jpg

damn this was close...too close.

every bill pullman movie has an ilxor who loves it enough to ignore the unfuckwithable glory of bill paxton's career

watched "dead alive," which might be the only movie with pullman and paxton, with some chilx pals on saturday. pullman is definitely the star, but paxton has some substantial scenes, and it's kind of archetypical roles for both - pullman is nerdy and nervous, paxton is brash and swarmy. great movie if you haven't seen it, also has a creepy bud cort in a big role.

you mean Brain Dead

oh shit yeah

looks like i'm the one who's "brain dead"

http://www.13wmaz.com/images/640/360/2/assetpool/photogallery/197835/BillPaxton.jpg

damn excited to find out what is up with his emmys stache

http://hollywoodleek.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/bill-pullman-bill-paxton2.jpg

disturbing

AHHHHHHHHH! I HATE IT!

looks like gabriel byrne

can't believe paxton won this. paxton! over pullman! crazy world.

http://content6.flixster.com/photo/11/38/30/11383028_gal.jpg

the best

http://d2oz5j6ef5tbf6.cloudfront.net/movie/large/Mr_wrong.jpg

http://blogs.dallasobserver.com/unfairpark/2007/03/the_day_bill_paxton_saw_john_f.php

http://www.cbc.ca/natureofthings/ftp_episodes/thefruithunters/gallery/images/08.jpg

lol.

Thought Pullman was excellent in Brokedown Palace.

paxton pwns in true lies

Pullman is aloof, arch, it almost always comes across to me like "I can't really act" acting which is fine, of course, but it doesn't work for me in his case. Paxton does the opposite really, or tries to, and it works for me. But maybe that's just cos I find him hot.

Well, bummer news indeed about Paxton. What a sad way to pass as well, after complications from surgery. He made a mark for sure.

Oh no! I just listened to Dean Delray's* interview with him last week and was starting to work my way through his roles. Damn, what a bummer.

*It was amazing because it felt like Delray had finally found a guest who actually complimented his (often distracting) voice.

https://soundcloud.com/deandelray/324-bill-paxton