HBO adaptation of Game of Thrones - will this be just for nerds? (NO SPOILERS PLEASE)

naw whats his faces speech abt ambition was tite

also some good zings this ep

'chaos is not a pit. it is a ladder!'

littlefinger is becoming one of the only interesting people on this show. i mean, it's awesome, but everytone is always so 'honor!' 'family!' 'oath!' 'boobs!'

some good power convos, nice bit of spectacle with the wall, couple of plot clues, piece shuffling otherwise. interesting that hbo balked at corpse nudity w/ ros. more interesting than surprising maybe. or maybe not even interesting, i dunno *shrug*

i thought it was v good for a set up ep which are usually a snooze

poor Ros

No more Theon torture porn, pls. Ick.

Do the non-book readers have any idea who the guy torturing Theon is or are you all totally in the dark?

Don't know who it is but someone cleverly put a screenshot with a clue up there.

Feel like we're never going o learn Podrick's secrets.

re: that clue. who is that guy to theon?

They've given us enough hints over the past two seasons to put WHO together imo - or at least I'll be very very surprised if its not who I think it is. WHY I have no idea though I'm starting to think it's "just because he can."

In which Max writes the greatest article on the series yet.

http://gawker.com/what-is-going-on-with-the-accents-in-game-of-thrones-485816507

i thought that guy was Bolton's bastard?!

*spoilers*he is*spoilers*

My husband hasn't read the books so he keeps asking about this character, and I'm still not sure if it is a big deal to spoil it or not.

wow ygritte is super posh; immaculately clipped non-scots accent irl

who pulls off an incredibly convincing northern accent

hmm.

i love that sean bean barely even bothers to do his posh yorkshire boromir thing in this. it's full on sheffield.

Did the same outcome befall roz in the books?

I don't think she was in the books.

Huh

Incredibly convincing [to americans]

The guy who isn't Vargo Hoat seemed like he was kinda shooting for Brummie

i think actually it's not that bad, but it's not a modern accent. it's 100 years old, which is why it sounds weird, but i suppose it makes sense for the character.

a good article!

my favourite accents to listen to on this show are: sean bean (obviously), Nikolaj Coster-Waldau (not necessarily "good", but nice to listen to) and liam cunningham, who does a beautiful durham/northumbria thing.

(xp)

god, ygritte's real accent is amazing

ygritte show accent is p much straight manc, or more specifically lancashire manc suburbs. i know ppl who sound a lot like that

roz was a whoo-er in the north that was chummy with theon iirc but didn't get any further along than that

I would like to point out that people generally adopt accents from their peers not their parents according to studies

i think she's going for lancashire yeah, but it's not quite right to me.

southern lancashire in partic.

i mean not that it matters. this is a terrible show about wizards that i don't even like and i only watch because everyone else does and i never post on this thread although the episode last week was good and i liked it when they blew up the boats.

but i like the febrile energy of max's article

As an American all I get is a southern gentleman out of littlefinger in a few random words and am nodding along blankly to all the other accent stuff you're all going on about.

It's a bit Welsh, I thought? Or am I not hearing it right? It is a very strange accent.

Well it'll be like one emphasized word per every three lines that give me that impression.

i think part of the problem is he's clearly reaching for a deeper voice than he naturally has, plus he seems like like he's not naturally an accent guy

welsh would be "correct" in some sense, since he's from the vale and theoretically vale accents = welsh

i think in a weird way his accent is worse or more distracting than dinklage's, because he seems to have something specific in mind that he's trying to do, where as dinklage hardly bothers these days

I had no idea Dinklage's was so weak. USA! USA!

from what i can tell dinklage's "accent" is basically just dropping his Rs and opening up his As a little bit

it's Victor Meldrew I think

Americans will get that reference

did littlefinger do all that growling stuff in earlier seasons? i've definitely noticed it more this season.

"and opening up his As a little bit"

Had to double take

Ronan called him Irish Dracula and now that's all I can think of any time he speaks.

I think Dinklage is just doing Stewie from the Family Guy.

hah!

did littlefinger do all that growling stuff in earlier seasons? i've definitely noticed it more this season.

Yeah I think it's been getting more pronounced the further in we've gone. Don't recall thinking anything in particular about Gillen's accent in the first series.

i think in a weird way his accent is worse or more distracting than dinklage's, because he seems to have something specific in mind that he's trying to do, where as dinklage hardly bothers these days

― caek, Monday, May 6, 2013 7:37 PM (1 hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

shifty character = shifty accent maybe?

for all we know this could be a middle earth type deal where in the reality of the story the common tongue sounds nothing like english but for our convenience it does

/nerd