David Lynch - Classic or Dud

Now I know why he called it The Straight Story!

lol

Article speaks of a tendency... you seldom find universals in a filmmaker with a 40-year-career.

the fact that there are significant countervailing tendencies would indicate that the conclusion being drawn is wrong

yes, that essay is dumb: the standard line you usually hear trotted out about david lynch (and especially wrt blue velvet and twin peaks) is that his work pries into the evil that is lurking behind the surface image of white picket fences and all-american small town life. and while that's a bit of a whatever,cliched take it's certainly more on the money than this.

yes, that the Rotary Club types are actually crossdressers and into BDSM...

I knew this wd provoke a firefight from the worshippers.

im not really a worshipper and i think if you wanted to critique lynch on how unwoke he is, how white his films are, or how often the portrayal of women in his films betrays a hairy-handed lechery then you can easily do that. i just don't think this is particularly illuminating

Like many directors his age he's subject to objections that the majority of his protagonists are straight, white men. I don't take this "sin of omission" as anything major, given the overall tenor and focus of his body of work, and the fact that his protagonists are often nuanced, flawed, etc. and not held up as paragons of racial virtue or some shit like that.

I do think it is worth noting that his lone lesbian protagonist (Naomi Watts in Mulholland Drive) is ultimately a tragic figure that is portrayed pretty sympathetically, and not as evil or as deserving of punishment for her "deviance".

xxpost No, it just provokes corrections from people who know how to read a text without imprinting bullshit on it that isn't there.

Now, if someone wanted to write an essay about Lynch's questionable handling of women in The Return, I'd be all ears.

I knew this wd provoke a firefight from the worshippers

This is key.

it does raise interesting questions, that's the value i see in it, and I honestly (in mostly staying away from the Return thread) haven't heard/read much other than awestruck praise for DL of late. I am an admirer.

Still, it's something worth wrestling with, the horror genre and human deviance. Signed, a gay horror fan.

'zackly!

xp
One thing that struck me as I skimmed that article (sorry, work) is the notion that more people haven't called out Lynch's version of "normal". I don't agree that it's in need of calling out really, because the white picket fence families in his stuff (Earth based stuff anyway) are kind of archetypes anyway. They don't seem real or normal to me, and it's not like I "relate" to the facade of the Palmer's family life, or Janey & Dougie or whoever. They're almost like blank canvases on which Lynch can paint surreal, nightmarish shadow versions of those peoples' lives.

What's "dated" about this is that hyper-stylized version of an American family really only exists on commercials, or via nostalgia for people who grew up in the 50s and 60s. Haha, or for the kind of suburban white Americans who would probably never watch Twin Peaks.

an upstanding upper-middle class pillar of a white community raping and murdering his daughter

...while possessed by what appears to be a longhaired grease monkey.

― ice cream social justice (Dr Morbius), Thursday, August 31, 2017 11:16 AM (seventeen minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

It's probably significant here that Fire Walk with Me, which was Lynch's last word on the Twin Peaks universe until very recently, implies that Leland was considerably more abusive and symbiotically linked to BOB than the series lets on.

Yes, obv the TP series' vision of 'normal' directly derives from '50s/early '60s pop culture, even in the casting of actors from the period like Beymer, Tamblyn, Piper Laurie, Chamberlain, Don Murray. (ditto Blue Velvet)

from Amy Taubin's Cannes report in the current Film Comment, where the first two eps of TP 2.0 were screened:

"I wish I could be interested in Lynch’s fiddling with CGI, his overworking of his actors’ glottal stops, and his evocation of Mystery Science Theater 3000, the symptomology of Alzheimer’s disease, and, more generally, castration anxiety. But I’m not."

She did like the new Top of the Lake.

― Supercreditor (Dr Morbius), Wednesday, 12 July 2017 17:19 (one month ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

That last sentence is a kicker and a half. New top of the lake is appalling

i think the essay's thesis (that lynch is working from a notion that middle class wasp life is normal and everything outside of it is deviant/horrifying) is easily countered with numerous examples from his films and also his own life. if anything, he often seems to conjure up that perception of normality only to subvert the living hell out of it.

but i also think it's silly to pretend that he doesn't have longstanding "issues" with how he presents people with physical and mental disabilities, and issues with not portraying people of color at all. lynch is really good at offering up visions of the "normal" life and then subverting them, because he often does so in deliberate, drawn out subtle ways (yes, i know it often ends in very unsubtle ways). but he frequently doesn't offer up that same subtlety to his "weird" characters. i think the essay is correct to point out that he often uses disability as a signifier of "otherness". but again...sometimes he does show immense compassion for these characters. as morbs said, he has a long career and there are plenty of counterexamples.

lmao i essentially said what shakey said on morbs' facebook post

New rule. Only allowed to post 'c' or 'd' in these threads.

Posting thinkpieces = ban, the wronger the longer

CDCCDCCD CCDCCCCC CDDCCDCC CDDCDDDD CDDCDDDC CCDCCDDD CDDDCDCC CCDCCCCC CDDDCDCC CDDCDCCC CDDCDCCD CDDCDDDC CDDCDCDD CCDCCCCC CDDDCDCC CDDCDCCC CDDCDCCD CDDDCCDD CCDCCCCC CDDCDCCD CDDDCCDD CCDCCCCC CDDCCCCD CCDCCCCC CDDCCDDD CDDCDDDD CDDCDDDD CDDCCDCC CCDCCCCC CDDCDCCD CDDCCDCC CDDCCDCD CDDCCCCD CCDCDDCC CCDCCCCC CDDCCDCC CDDCDDCD CDDCCCCD CDDCCCDD CCDCDDDC 

that's a real message but it's in binary so get your punch card supercomputers out of the closet

Oh I've no doubt there's already twenty posts in the TP thread about it hey

It's probably significant here that Fire Walk with Me, which was Lynch's last word on the Twin Peaks universe until very recently, implies that Leland was considerably more abusive and symbiotically linked to BOB than the series lets on.

This is true, but on the other hand, FWWM also presents Deer Meadow, which is like a nastier version of Twin Peaks and … at the same time a whole lot lower down the socio-economic scale. Maybe it has a light underbelly we never get to see.

Carl is positively angelic in TP:TR

And I love Lynch, but I'm not sure he's done a lot for the image of hobos.

Carl is positively angelic in TP:TR

But he's moved his trailer park from Deer Meadow to Twin Peaks ha ha.

Recently saw Ellen Page accused of being an imperialist colonialist.

I think David Wants To Fly is probably the worst we'll see of Lynch.

Didn't Lynch's interview with the Palmer family suggest Leland was not guilty of abuse?

Given these elements of Lynch’s work, it is baffling that more people have not critiqued the filmmaker’s normative sensibilities.

I stopped reading the essay here, because I feel like critiques of Lynch's normative sensibilities have been a staple of the Lynch discourse for as long as I can remember. "Is David Lynch sexist/racist/exploitative" is probably the most well-worn corner of Lynch criticism. The essay's argument is a surface argument and it's fine as far as it goes, but plenty of ppl love Lynch who also find him troubling and sometimes indefensible. I mean, if you don't find him troubling I'm not sure what you even get from his work. Of course it's troubling.

Didn't Lynch's interview with the Palmer family suggest Leland was not guilty of abuse?

According to... Leland

Who was created by lynch!

wait a sec, does this refer to Gordon Cole interviewing the Palmers? xp

It was Lynch as himself interviewing the Palmer family for a special feature.

Horror troubling and bigotry troubling are very different reasons?

Watched Fire Walk With Me recently and wondered whether Sarah is somehow sleeping through Laura's screaming or if she's been ignoring the abuse.

i already know about "I am the FBI" ... very funny to hear of it choking up left-wing friends who may be on watchlists. :)

Sarah is somehow sleeping through Laura's screaming

this is the case, leland is drugging her

i already know about "I am the FBI" ... very funny to hear of it choking up left-wing friends who may be on watchlists. :)

― ice cream social justice (Dr Morbius), Thursday, August 31, 2017 10:33 AM (twenty-six seconds ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

oh no the cognitive dissonance i'm experiencing in this fictional story!!!!!!!!!!!

it's familiar, but it's still funny.

Horror troubling and bigotry troubling are very different reasons?

Sure, but not unconnected. A lot of fear is about the unknown/unfamiliar.

the FBI in Twin Peaks bears virtually no relationship to the actual irl FBI

It's probably worth noting the posts in the cosmic horror thread where people cogently explain why they wouldn't conflate Lynch's worldview with e.g. Lovecraft's.

like, enjoying that line has nothing to do with the actual FBI and everything to do with the character's position in this fictional universe

xxp

Since when has the context of a line of dialogue ever mattered? Since never, that's when.

https://images.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=http%3A%2F%2Fmidwestcoastal.files.wordpress.com%2F2013%2F11%2Fdale-cooper-thumbs-up.png%3Fw%3D400%26h%3D550&f=1

the line in the article about Mike evoking otherness through his disability just seems wrong on many levels

Didn't he cut off his own arm to rid himself of BOB?

enjoying that line has nothing to do with the actual FBI and everything to do with the character's position in this fictional universe

YEAH THX I'M DUMB

christ i fucking hate this place sometimes

the FBI in Twin Peaks bears virtually no relationship to the actual irl FBI

wellllll, they have the same name...

sorta like the FBI in Mississippi Burning