NYT: The 25 Greatest Actors of the 21st Century

All boxes checked!

Kind of shocked that Philip Seymour Hoff wasn’t in the mix

No Gandolfini on the list! Well, he’s no Melissa McCarthy

you've probably avoided some bad news about them by not reading articles

Whether I agree with it or not, I like that McCarthy's on the list. Movie critics are usually incredibly shitty about judging comedic performances.

yeah, especially satisfying that they went so hard on Spy in the piece

Which, I mean, I love Deneuve, but why is she on a 21st century list?

if only there was any kind of answer to this in the mini-essay about her approach and performances

How the heck is Hoffman not on this list?! Ledger?

I could give you some bad news but you obviously don't read threads or articles (or display names, or tweets)

wait what happened to Heath? WHAT HAPPENED TO HEATH

his acting got worse so they left him off this list

Christ, you scared me for a minute!

Even if you like Daniel Day-Lewis more than I do--especially if you do--I'd count The Gangs of New York as a minus, not a plus.

My favorite thing about that film was Day-Lewis' acting in it, and his character. The rest of it around him seemed a bit much, but as a villain and a personality, he felt larger than life and I couldn't wait to see every second of his time on screen in it.

I don't recall ever watching a film just because of who was performing in it.

Not a judgement, just an observation: I'm guessing you'd have a hard time finding someone who shares that viewpoint.

I imagine one of the only times that was true for me was Dancer in the Dark.

I watched The Bishop's Wife last week cuz #CaryGrant. I should've stayed away because Loretta Young.

I'm in this camp, actors rarely if ever have anything to do w/ my seeing a given movie

"Actors doing the sort of thing they especially excel at" is a different factor to "actor is listed somewhere in credits"

I've watched so many movies just because it looked ordinary at worst (obviously I draw the line somewhere) and had Gene Hackman or Audrey Hepburn or somebody else I really like.

Instead of the director's cut of Superman II I watched, I would much rather have seen the Gene Hackman cut, with all the scenes of his that were discarded.

https://archive.org/details/supermanii-restoredinternationalalternativecut2005

times when i have watched a film specifically to see an actor in it tend toward the old (Mitchum, Chevalier, Welles) or action (Jaa, Chan) or because they ARE the show (Marx Bros)

Willem Dafoe? lol

― Lover of Nixon (or LON for short) (Neanderthal), Wednesday, November 25, 2020 11:53 PM (five days ago)

Seconded

― Robert Gotopieces (James Redd and the Blecchs), Wednesday, November 25, 2020 11:56 PM (five days ago)

several of these seem like "we liked them in the 90s, so they're grandfathered into this list"

― Lover of Nixon (or LON for short) (Neanderthal), Wednesday, November 25, 2020 11:56 PM (five days ago)

That was my first reaction to Dafoe, too, but when I looked up his filmography, he has done a few significant films since 2000. I can sort of see it.

― clemenza, Wednesday, November 25, 2020 11:59 PM (five days ago)

What's wrong with him? He's one of those few I'm always happy to see.

agree, and loved him in The Lighthouse

Apparently he's great in Abel Ferrara's latest.

Keanu is an interesting case because he is entirely himself on screen and is always a compelling presence, and his wick performances have added a lot of shading to his stock character. he obviously doesn’t have “range,” but there’s something to be said for doing one thing extremely well

this was an interesting argument about the virtues of reeves, and really did change my thinking about him: https://www.rogerebert.com/features/bright-walldark-room-february-2016-the-grace-of-keanu-reeves-by-angelica-jade-bastién

Keanu’s failed performances are those that push him toward a theatricality against his natural instincts. They also tend to be the kind of roles actors use to challenge or prove themselves—difficult accents, lush period pieces, reliance on verbal dexterity (...) Total Film writes dismissively that “you can visibly see Keanu attempting to not end every one of his lines with ‘dude.’"

ROFL

btw, need to copy paste the link, think the accent makes it screw on ilx

*screwy

"Meryl Streep Isn’t on Our List of Greatest Actors. Here’s Why."

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/04/insider/best-actors-list.html

An explainer!

Gary Crant!

I don't see Scoot McNairy on this list

voted song kang ho

I don't see Scoot McNairy on this list

Very disappointed his career hasn't taken the Sam Rockwell trajectory (in terms of visibility) I expected it to.

I am somewhat perplexed that Michelle Williams isn't on this list given that she has approximately 500 Oscars

Oscar nominations?

She has three fewer Oscars total than Green Book won last year.

Citizen Kane (10.0)
Mank (6.0)
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me (7.0)
Hillbilly Elegy (5.5)
Affairs of State (2.0)
Blume in Love (6.5)
Mario Puzo's The Godfather, Coda: The Death of Michael Corleone (5.0)
The Parallax View (7.0)
The Killing of a Sacred Deer (6.5)
The Net (6.5)

I have no excuse for last rating, other than to say it’s an example, for me, of some of what I was trying to say in this thread: NYT: The 25 Greatest Actors of the 21st Century. Early in her career, I really liked Sandra Bullock.

Oops, wrong thread.

Julianne Moore turned 60 this week.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Departed from my initial post and voted for Nicole Kidman, possibly edged in that direction by seeing The Killing of a Sacred Deer (I want to give her credit for Eyes Wide Shut, too, which came out in the summer of '99 and maybe was still playing somewhere in January of 2000).

clem's accidental post above had me genuinely trying to work out which of these actors could have possibly appeared in Citizen Kane for oh, at least 10 seconds

God this list sucks.

List this God sucks

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

04. Keanu Reeves 5
21. Catherine Deneuve 1

never change ilx

1 dude in the top 5? I'll take it.

voted for Zhao Tao, would have liked to see Kim Min-hee get a vote or two

04. Keanu Reeves 5
21. Catherine Deneuve 1

never change ilx

― early-Woolf semantic prosody (Hadrian VIII), Wednesday, 30 December 2020 00:24 (one hour ago) bookmarkflaglink

1 dude in the top 5? I'll take it.

― On average, this critic grades 8.3 points lower than other critics (Eric H.), Wednesday, 30 December 2020 00:49 (one hour ago) bookmarkflaglink

Never change ilx

Whatever, dudes suck and you know it.

🎶Some dudes will
Some dudes wont 🎶

1 dude in the top 5? I'll take it.

― On average, this critic grades 8.3 points lower than other critics (Eric H.), Wednesday, 30 December 2020 00:49 (one hour ago)

Never change ilx

― spruce springclean (darraghmac), Wednesday, December 30, 2020 1:21 PM (one hour ago)

two Irish actors in the top 5? never change, ILX

this is not a poll to take too seriously