no way NYT

Has anyone read Jeff Gerth's piece in the Columbia Journalism Review on the NYT's coverage of "Russiagate"? I heard an interview with the author, and have been meaning to read it, but tl;dr. To hear him tell it, Gerth (a former Times reporter himself) has some serious criticisms of the paper's reporting on the whole sordid mess.

xp
I feel like you keep misunderstanding me, which means I'm doing a bad job of communicating with you, YMP. I'll drop it after this, but ftr I didn't mean you were obliged to have a theory about how you yourself can individually change society. I meant: how do you account for broad changes in social attitudes if people inherit their views from their parents? What are (some of) the "larger forces at work" you alluded to?

I certainly don't expect you to have a fully developed sociological explanation of your own devising! But if you're skeptical of the media's role in changing people's minds on issues, what do you see as the forces behind changing viewpoints?

Anyway, we're not in class lol, you don't have to answer, it's obviously a massive question, but that is what I meant and what I was getting confounded by.

I'm *very* suspicious of the motives of anyone who wants to deny or downplay the influence of media, especially right now. furthermore the NYT must be destroyed, no more of this constructive criticism nonsense

as you wish Master Shredder

Rob, it's cool, sorry to present myself as a delicate wisp instead of someone who knows anything about anything. It's one of my flaws, which are numerous.

Anyway, as an actual attempted answerto the question upthread, I think people respond to real stuff that affects them, way more than words on a screen or a page.

My politics - from the cradle - is a politics of empathy. Standard cis het white liberal stuff. Dismiss me as an NPR/Whole Foods progressive if you like.

Tolerance *in theory* tends to evolve and enlarge when it is put into actual practice.

Purely theoretical LGBTQ+ acceptance (for example) expands when you actually have actual trans people right in front of you and actually living in your actual house. (Which I actually do, by the way.)

So yeah, that has been an education. And I am happy to report that engaging with IRL 3D real trans individuals has affected my thinking, shifting it from a vague acceptance to actual allyship.

So yeah that is my theory of social change. And it has almost nothing to do with what the New York Times does or doesn't publish.

At the same time (to Neanderthal's point) it is totally understandable to hold NYT to account and critique it for its lapses. No quarrel with that.

I just don't think it's _creating_ the toxic attitudes. To me, media is a mirror as much as it is a painting.

Has anyone read Jeff Gerth's piece in the Columbia Journalism Review on the NYT's coverage of "Russiagate"?

I'd been meaning to and this prompted me to go give it a scan. I'm not too impressed tbh. I think Gerth has his own axes to grind and he repeatedly seems to take Trump at his word on things and downplays things like the Helsinki press conference (pretending that people's reactions to it were all about one Trump answer that he thinks the media somewhat misinterpreted rather than his bizarrely deferential demeanor throughout, etc.). He also has a very credulous account of how Bill Barr came to write the summary letter of the Mueller report — to read Gerth's account, you'd think it was a fair-minded summary, which is hardly the case.

Sure, the NYT and WaPo and others overplayed some aspects of the Russia-Trump story because the connections were never as clear or as quid-quo as some of the reporting made them seem. On the other hand, it remains true that there was a huge amount of sketchy stuff going on between Trump people and Russians of various agency, as the Mueller report bears out. Gerth's takeaway ultimately is that the Times and WaPo were blinded by hating Trump and abandoned their holy journalistic objectivity, which is why people now don't trust the media. I don't buy it.

He also has a very credulous account of how Bill Barr came to write the summary letter of the Mueller report — to read Gerth's account, you'd think it was a fair-minded summary, which is hardly the case.

This part galled me.

Gerth like the dude who shows up at parties with a douchey smirk and constantly says things like "not to be that guy" when beginning every convo

I just don't think it's _creating_ the toxic attitudes

no but it legitimises them and weakens liberal opposition to the right's attacks.

Yep. For the sake of my blood pressure I should renounce my habit of visiting comment sites, but, boy, every time Ross Asshat and Pamela Priss publish more anti-modernist bilge another Karen gets her zings. The usual "I'm a Democrat, I voted for Joe Biden, BUT."

I think Gerth has his own axes to grind and he repeatedly seems to take Trump at his word on things

Yeah, this came through in the interview. He talked about interviewing Trump and seemed to find him believable, which . . . wow.

Barr's "summary" of the Mueller Report was a true hatchet job--which is exactly why he was appointed in the first place.

Wasn’t Gerth one of the most credulous Iraq War cheerleaders? Why the fuck should his musings on Trump and Russia carry any weight at all?

Ross Asshat and Pamela Priss

morbs would approve

Whatever y'all do, don't read Bret Stephens' anti-mask column today.

My blood pressure went up just reading that sentence.

Oh god ugggh thanks for the heads-up!

I finally had enough with the transphobia and other ridiculousness and canceled my subscription. Shoulda done it a while ago. I stopped listening to NPR news back in the trump years. Holding onto my Washington post subscription - plenty to disagree with but I have lower expectations. Getting less tolerant of bs in my old age.

I love how he gets sad-eyes when the government does public health measures and happy eyes when the government funds war and apartheid in Israel.

Bret Stephens should be forced to eat maggots for three years for just about everything he's ever wrote.

I love after the 2018 election when he was in such a hurry to shit on libs that he wrote how it was a disappointing performance and how they needed to reach across the aisle and then they wound up winning 40 seats and Nate Silver called him a moron basically

Elizabeth Koch is a part of the vilified Koch dynasty. Worrying about what people think pushed her to the brink of insanity.

Now, she wants to help people understand their debilitating "Perception Boxes." She spoke to me for her first big profile:https://t.co/DVKxmifHm8

— Brooks Barnes (@brooksbarnesNYT) February 23, 2023

I would not read that for less than $500 up front.

the end of that article's first arc is a new frontier in cringe -- it's two acts:

I.

Or you may have the opposite reaction: It must be really, really hard — eye roll — to be an heiress to one of the biggest fortunes ever accumulated, who graduated from an Ivy League university (Princeton) and is now married to a successful biotech entrepreneur. They recently vacationed in Bali.

When Ms. Koch first came on my radar, I was firmly in the second camp.

A publicist named Scott Rowe had called to propose an article on Ms. Koch and her nonprofit organization, Unlikely Collaborators, which is all about self-investigation. According to its website, the organization is dedicated to the creation of “provocative experiences that help you face who you think you are.” The site adds, “Our experiences use a process of self-investigation that encompasses principles and practices from eastern and western thought, meditation, psychology, and neuroscience — designed to expand your understanding of self, others, and the whole damned world.”

Oh, brother.

II.

“I know this is a lot to throw at people,” Ms. Koch said, apparently reading my mind. “Let’s go back to Perception Box. That’s where it begins and ends.”

She jumped to her feet and started writing on a white board, calling out each word with a flourish in a demonstration of one of her workshops.

“I don’t matter.”

“I’m not good enough.”

“I’m bad.”

She asked me to envision a person — a writer, perhaps. This person misses deadlines because they are “constantly worrying about making it perfect,” she said. “It has to be better. It has to be better. No, no, no. Not there yet.” That thinking can be painful and ultimately even professionally paralyzing.
Story continues below advertisement
Continue reading the main story

“That person is running a Perception Box story in their head,” she said, “and it’s an obvious one: I’m not good enough.”

I grimaced and told her that I could be that writer.

“Who are you still trying to please, and who are you still rebelling against?” she asked me, now firmly in teacher-student mode.

I squirmed and thought about how it was really stupid of me to say no to that blanket.

“Probably Daddy,” I said, almost in a whisper.

wow person who should be guillotined discovers CBT and mixes it with pop zen bs, so glad to be alive

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/26/opinion/san-francisco-democrats-board-of-supervisors.html

“Even Democrats Like Me (Billionaires) Are Fed Up With San Francisco”

Another variation of the old “I am repulsed by poor people and poor people drug use, save our city”

What It Means to Be Woke
—Ross Douthat

best Madonna single

Trump allies are pressuring Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida to weigh in on the expected indictment.

Never Mind About Ron DeSantis

Ron DeSantis Has a Secret Theory of Trump

jesus christ

Are we all excited by the chance to once more be irritated by NYT Iraq war articles, now that they are running anniversary pieces? We’ve already had one today that had several paragraphs on the CIA without one mention of torture.

it's funny, I was paying for my subscription through Paypal and I removed authorization to charge it like, over a month ago, but never got around to formally cancelling the subscription.

every other day I get emails like "Second to final warning - your subscription will be cancelled", "final warning - we will cancel your subscription if we don't receive payment!", "final warning again, we mean it this time!"....been happening for like a month, daily threats, and still they haven't cancelled it.

It's like cable or the Mafia, you don't get out except feet first.

Check out the kicker in this despicable profile:

Ms. Statler agreed about Judge Kacsmaryk. “I just know he just has a real tender spot for caring for women,” she told The Times, “and particularly women who are pregnant.”

Any article about that judge that doesn't lead with "That piece of shit" is a bad article

What Happened to America? We Asked 12 People in Their 70s and 80s.

that “article” was so typical that it made me laugh— there might as well have been a quote about kicking a ball in the street.

all of them seem to believe that people should just take the jobs that are offered and work them until they die. idiots.

the headline alone feels like a lazy parody of what everyone already hates about their vox populi attempts

cheating b/c I did actually read this one, but was there really no one in editorial who saw this and had a dim recollection that the UK is—infamously I would have thought—not in the EU?

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/27/opinion/microsoft-activision-ftc-antitrust-grail-eu.html

(and yeah their bios should have been enough of a red flag)

this person is utterly useless

https://i.imgur.com/f9FYV5j.jpg

lol I saw that and was so dispirited I couldn't even post it here

Chris Christie Is Doing Something Very, Very Important

Christopher F. Rufo
D.E.I. Programs are Getting in the Way of Liberal Education

good lord

I'm embarrassed to admit I am still capable of being mildly shocked at them platforming such an unambiguous and outspoken racist

I know everyone needs a rufover their heads but do we really have to let this guy write op-eds

at least put a pic of him under the byline with the caveat - "Warning, this piece was written by a likely Klansman" or something

WaPo not to be outdone:

What happened in the decade before crime rose? ‘Broken windows’ policing stopped.
Opinion by Charles Murray

Here are five key findings from a Times examination of Ron DeSantis’s educational backstory.

I loved this for the big town small town angle(?): https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/19/business/media/kansas-newspaper-marion-county-record.html

Ross Douthat

James Bond Is Now ‘Woke’

james bomb trans now