Posts you had second thought about and decided not to post - put them here

why do all indie bands now need to have singers that sing like little babies. little babies with speech impediments

Because the key to indie is being non-threatening.

was this board always full of tedious gasbags who make talking about music miserable

i'm not even talking about the two posters above

honestly fuck the person who said that in your thread. i have my issues with certain indie rock affectations but for the record appreciate you and your enthusiasm, also my quibbles are not about music being "dangerous" vs. "non-threatening" because i'm not a fucking turd, just for the record

i keep saying things "for the record" but because of this thread it's off the record okay

was this board always full of tedious gasbags who make talking about music miserable

― ivy., Tuesday, 29 August 2023 22:47 (fourteen minutes ago) bookmarkflaglink

yes!

this board is full of ppl that are miserable, is i think closer to the truth

this board is full of ppl that are miserable, is i think closer to the truth

Step 1: buy a mirror
Step 2: stare into it until enlightenment dawns

been there done that

the solution to being miserable is not to try your hardest to make other people miserable

well that’s what i already do! can’t really be responsible for people’s weird overreactions

maybe you should take a really fucking hard look at your privileged life and what leads you to punch down all the time, idk

jesus christ

“my privileged life”

says the guy whose family money means he doesn't pay rent

y'all please stop this

Mixing Negronis now. No punching down at this party.

i don’t think it’s punching down to say someone’s metaphors don’t make sense, it’s not like i hold the keys to ilx or determine anyone’s posting status

now I want a Negroni <3

y'all please stop this

― ivy., Tuesday, August 29, 2023 7:15 PM (fifty-two seconds ago)

got it, and sorry for carrying on in the actual thread

hey sleeve? you don’t know me, and you don’t know anything about my family. i work 60 hr weeks teaching high school so maybe you shouldn’t make assumptions like that

i don’t think it’s punching down to say someone’s metaphors don’t make sense, it’s not like i hold the keys to ilx or determine anyone’s posting status

― the late great, Tuesday, August 29, 2023 7:16 PM (five minutes ago) bookmarkflaglink

idk i would like to at least communicate this without making it personal, but to waltz into a thread about music and say "i haven't listened to this but i would like to criticize the way you wrote about this music i haven't listened to" is just kind of a dick move! unsolicited advice at best. honestly kind of off-topic. editors tell me my metaphors don't make sense all the time but i have a working relationship with them. you are a person on a message board

feedback is usually something you ask for unless you're publishing something very publicly and my ilx writing just kinda shouldn't be held to the standard of my published work because i am not working with an editor, please don't hold me to such a standard because i will fail to meet it, and it will upset me, do you get why i got upset?

he's got some previous for this, it's not long since he was telling me to get a thesaurus for not hating his fave director in a verbose enough fashion for his liking!

well that’s what i already do! can’t really be responsible for people’s weird overreactions

― the late great, Tuesday, August 29, 2023

Yes, you can. Especially when they're telling you so.

ooh a call back to one of your most infamous posts! i hope i'm not the only one who appreciated that.

the metaphors worked fine - you've got to work to be an asshole about the concept of pressure building (to an explosion) or seeing power lines swaying through a car window

ivy would've been told to die back in 2001 for that thread with no pushback, so at least this is an improvement (of sorts).

told to die for starting an enthusiastic thread about an indie rock band? you what

Indie is like the most hated genre of all time on ILX. Predictably enough.

Except that nobody can agree on what indie actually is.

Of course, there's that too. Actually the current glut of polls suggests maybe not as hated as I thought.

It's like goths who claim not to be goths

One thing I always found funny is that what was known in the US as 'College Rock' the UK equivalent got dismissed as 'Student Disco'.

Student discos were where it was played but I don't think the music itself was ever called student disco.

Shed Seven, Kingmaker etc certainly did but it was purely a derogatory term used by people. Dont know if it was ever used in the media.

Yeah, you might be right. That's exactly the sort of band I was thinking of too, I don't know if college rock was the same thing though.

That's why I said the UK equivalent.

Amerindie was always quite different to the UK kind. Have a look at my indie rock poll thread and you will see its quite different to the UK indie of its time.

What I mean is I'm not sure US college rock was about second string indie bands who were on major labels and who were perceived to lack substance or credibility. I thought college rock covered bands like REM, the Replacements, Husker Du as opposed to, er, Cud.

... but I could be mistaken there.

no you're broadly right

I thought college rock was basically indie bands who had jumped to majors so got the bigger push on radio?

told to die for starting an enthusiastic thread about an indie rock band? you what

― imago, Wednesday, 30 August 2023 bookmarkflaglink

You are not a real ilxor, hence the confusion.

That’s the way I remember it, although it’s been awhile.
(xp)

Xp charming

"Indie Dance" was a genre - in about 1992.

I thought college rock was basically indie bands who had jumped to majors so got the bigger push on radio?

― Toshirō Nofune (The Seventh ILXorai), Wednesday, August 30, 2023 8:20 AM (six minutes ago)

I thought it was called college rock because it was what was played on *college* radio (small, independent, freeform) not mainstream, at least initially /during the 80s

Was around in 89 iirc

xp

As a non-American I obviously know sfa about college rock which is why I brought it up and will defer to actual Americans on the matter.