Israel/Palestine post 10/7 - follow-on events/thoughts as relate to other countries

esp in the UK there are much pettier party-political and gatekeeping and in-group sigalling elements at play* which is what I assume the tweet is about but even then there are geopolitical and economic reasons why they behave this way ultimately those things should still be seen as primary (but the mystification over these motivations is on the extreme side even compared to US discourse)

*(along with a general lack of emphathy and a specific, pointed contempt for people we've fucked over)

empathy has one h

he's talking about UK politicians and media rather than elsewhere

Oh, like the Labour Friends of Israel type thing? I find that difficult to follow, that almost feels like an example of the kind of self-ensorcellment that the UK specialises in

I stupidly subjected myself to radio 4's today programme this morning and the presenter was interviewing someone from an aid organisation in gaza, and the presenter was pompously "correcting" him about the situation on the ground there - because the alternative would have been questioning for a moment his own worldview. that's the sort of thing.

xp it is and your example is a very minor one it's the whole party and and the other parties and the media and people who engage with any of those things for too long (even in hatred)

Yes that absolutely happens, especially amongst the footsoldiers of client journalism, but it's misleading to view it as the whole story imo.

xpost

[100-post lawyerly digression on whether there is an agreed-upon definition of ensorcel]

I make people uncomfortable if I'm watching/listening to current events with them bc I always feel the need to "correct" and point out the framing and I hate what it turns me into xps

I had to look it up google says it's archaic xp

I'm archaic so I'll be using it.

Ok, I see what you mean now. I don't think this is anything to do with Israel per se, attitudes to Israel are just a manifestation of it. I think this is more of a kind of 1950s institutionalism that sees Israel as kind of like Canada or New Zealand. I don't know if its' any deeper than that. The kind of thing that exists in institutions but not necessarily the public. Technically I think this isn't ensorcellment but self-ensorcellment from which the source no longer exists and may only be continuing in placebo form

Man you guys really run something into the fucking ground huh

New board description!

As another example (albeit one entirely off topic here, I'm aware), almost no-one talking about Rwanda in the UK has any interest in the state of Rwanda (in either sense) - it's just a black box labelled 'awayness'

I don’t follow.

I would say it's more than "awayness" - most people associate it with the atrocities there in the 90s, so it's also "send them away to the bad place"

Very good piece on Gessen, but mostly on Arendt and her changes in thinking on Israel.

https://www.unpopularfront.news/p/arendt-and-jerusalem

Many of the discussions going on now have been going on for decades, partly because the FBI and its counterintelligence programs have muddied the waters by falsely equating anti-Zionism with antisemitism while ignoring many actual incidents of antisemitic terror. Good thread.

In 1970, the NY Times published a piece purporting to expose Jewish fears that anti-zionism was the new antisemitism within Black Power and New Left groups. The FBI took notice and turned the article into a pamphlet as part of its Counterintelligence Program or COINTELPRO. 1/13 pic.twitter.com/MxZxkTTBHY

— Stuart Schrader (@stschrader1) December 18, 2023

BREAKING: Colorado Supreme Court disqualifies Donald Trump from the state's presidential primary ballot under Section 3 of the 14th Amendment. The move sets up a battle before the U.S. Supreme Court. https://t.co/dfnRnBU3wS

— ABC News Politics (@ABCPolitics) December 19, 2023

Lol, sorry

Occupied. Right now. Berlin Central Station. Top work comrades. Time to close down the genocide monsters of western colonialism. Time to destroy Israeli fascism. This is what solidarity looks like. #GazaMassacre #FreePalestinepic.twitter.com/a0ynLBQAtQ

— GhostofDurruti (@DurrutiRiot) December 19, 2023

From one of the quote tweets he lives in an illegal settlement in the West Bank.

On #C4News last night Israeli politician Yuli Edelstein, (chair of the Israeli parliaments Foreign Affairs & Security Committee) said that accusing IDF snipers of targeting civilians in a church compound is antisemitic. pic.twitter.com/7WLf7wNO4y

— Saul Staniforth (@SaulStaniforth) December 19, 2023

Yes. Spoke about that guy earlier in the thread. Or the other thread.

... in fact that's the interview I saw.

normie dems breaking alert🚨 https://t.co/lfqh6Esa43

— ettingermentum (@ettingermentum) December 20, 2023

When you’ve lost moulton and spanberger

Talking of interviews, that belligerent cunt Naftali Bennett is back on British TV to turn everyone watching against the Israeli cause. He's just come up with a new phrase to describe B'Tselem: "self-hating Israelis".

Polling wise Americans are giving up on Israel being armed to the teeth.

Not that it matters with Biden.

Support more military aid to Israel?

Oct 17
Voters: 64-28 (+36)
Dems: 59-29 (+30)

Nov 2
Voters: 51/41 (+10)
Dems 49-43 (+6)

Nov 17
Voters: 54-39 (+15)
Dems: 45-48 (-3)

Dec 20
Voters: 45-46 (-1)
Dems: 36-58 (-22) 👀 https://t.co/yP1Gx3dtiU

— austerity is theft (@wideofthepost) December 21, 2023

"The thing is, though, “God, I wish the Israelis would just kill these people” is something you can sigh into a scotch and soda with your co-workers at the hotel bar after a day of frustrated “diplomacy.” Nobody would bat an eye. It’s just blowing off steam. But if you’re recorded saying it to a halal cart vendor in Manhattan, you have violated the social contract. If you stay within the system, almost everything is allowable: structural violence demands a certain politeness."

https://thebaffler.com/latest/impolite-society-burton

An 8yr old British Palestinian boy has been out of school because staff wont let him wear a Palestine flag patch on his coat. His dad explains what happened.

The school says its apolitical, but when Russia invaded Ukraine they flew the Ukrainian flag & held fund raisers pic.twitter.com/8GUgHIx49t

— Saul Staniforth (@SaulStaniforth) December 21, 2023

I found this commentary to be rather moving and specific in how it thinks through language and the notion of a shibboleth. Pertinent to our discussion of Zionism, River/sea, etc. An excellent read: here.

Zionism is not a Jewish sect, nor a Jewish tenet, nor a Jewish ritual, nor will you find it in the Torah, the Talmud, the Midrash, etc. It is a political movement and ideology based on religious fundamentalism, like, say, Hamas. Often, we call religious fundamentalists “terrorists,” but that’s only if they’re Islamic. This too is a shibboleth.

Zionism has two main tenets: Jews have a sacred claim to the land of Palestine, and Jews cannot survive as a people in a world that is deeply hostile to them, unless they have their own state.

These are two very different things. The first tenet is religious in nature – and as with most things sacred and numinous, it ought to be seen as fixed and immutable – but it is, interestingly, not necessary to Zionism. Or, that is, it is literally nominal insofar as “Zion” referred in the Hebrew Bible to Jerusalem, and often referred metonymically to the larger surrounding area that we would call Palestine. Therefore, Zion and its -ism. But in keeping with the metaphorical usage of “Zion” in the Torah, the founding Zionists were not necessarily committed to a Jewish State existing in “Zion,” or Jerusalem and its surrounds. Theodor Herzl himself, the founder of modern Zionism, presented at the 6th World Zionist Congress the Uganda Scheme – developed by the British – an idea for a Jewish State in British East Africa.

Herzl did, like many Zionists, prefer to found the state in Palestine, but he was looking for expediency; considering the historical plight of the persecuted Jew, he believed Jews needed a homeland in the form of a state, and that that homeland didn’t have to be religiously sanctioned as home; it just had to be established. Therefore, he and other Zionists worked with the British, who they hoped would establish for them a Jewish state. This is because of the second tenet, which as I have said trumps the first: the Jews need their own state in order to survive in a world that is existentially hostile to them.

This second tenet is deeply cynical; it resigns itself to antisemitism as fatalism. Zionists moreover relied on Britain, a colonialist empire that is as Arabophobic as it is antisemitic – and that promised Palestine both to Arabs and to Jews, simultaneously, for the sole sake of geopolitical strategy against the Turks during World War I – to establish that state for them. The Zionists had no illusions about this: “The antisemites WILL BECOME our most loyal friends, the antisemitic nations will become our allies,” wrote Herzl in his diary. In establishing the world then into 2 camps – Jews and antisemites – Zionism re-maps not only the entire world, but Jewry itself. Even Jews like me, who don’t support Zionism, would be considered antisemitic. And in pitting themselves against an “antisemitic world,” the Zionists authorize themselves to commit horrors. Herzl wrote in his diary as early as 1895 the Zionist plan for occupying Palestine: “We must expropriate gently the private property on the state assigned to us. We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit countries, while denying it employment in our country. The property owners will come over to our side. Both the process of expropriation and the removal of the poor must be carried out discretely and circumspectly. Let the owners of the immoveable property believe that they are cheating us, selling us things for more than they are worth. But we are not going to sell them anything back.”

This plan for naked ethnic cleansing follows its throughline uninterrupted to today. In April 2021, in an address to Palestinian Knesset Member Ahmad Tibi, Israeli finance minister Bezalel Smotrich tweeted “a true Muslim must know that the Land of Israel belongs to the People of Israel, and over time Arabs like you who do not recognize this will not stay here.” Later that fall, he elaborated that the Palestinians were “here by mistake—because Ben-Gurion didn’t finish the job and throw you out in 1948.” And this year, looking to finish the job, Israeli security minister Avi Dichter said on November 12th, “We are now rolling out the Gaza Nakba…Gaza Nakba 2023.” Like it’s a Black Friday event. Like it will be done in the middle of the market.

The resemblance in the speech of the Zionists to their antisemitic oppressors – the fascism, the racism, the colonialism, the vitriolic ambition for land and power – is illuminating. It is like the Gileadites and the Ephraimites, who resemble one another exactly, and only differ in their accents, and in who holds power. For this reason, this is to me the most interesting shibboleth of the three: it inverts itself. Its expression contains its absolute antithesis. The border crossed is not geopolitical, it is a border within the self, it self-trespasses, it self-annihilates. “Anti-zionism is Antisemitic” is the wrong pronunciation: the correct one is “Zionism is Antisemitic.”

yep

IF I thought Zionism meant Smotrichism I too would be anti-Zionist.

Zionism is a land of contrasts

I loved that article, tabes, and thanks; wish that there was more attention paid toward how debates of semantics effectively form a method of filibustering, that afford (the current Zionists-in-charge like) Smotrich et al. their greatest asset— time to kill. As we debate what versions of Zionism we would or would not support, the shitheads who have the funding and electorate power are, effectively, destroying any future concept that “good Zionism” can exist; templates that would propose a contrary future are welcome at this point, until I’m convinced, I remain broadly and vociferously anti-Zionist

Lol @ this attack on Alareer's work.

If you’re going to try to write a hit piece about a poet who was martyred and whose work will be remembered, you gotta come with a CV a little stronger than this one. https://t.co/GH9vuFuFgS pic.twitter.com/j4jsKJDTZ5

— 🇵🇸 timothy 🍉 faust (@crulge) December 21, 2023

Reading this substack on Israeli arms exports and how it facilitates democratic repression.

https://www.foreignexchanges.news/p/a-future-of-walls-or-liberation

xyzzz, I am currently reading Antony Loewenstein’s The Palestine Laboratory, which covers some of what that substack covers plus a lot more— lots of information in it.

https://www.versobooks.com/products/2684-the-palestine-laboratory

There are also some talks and podcasts with Loewenstein floating around. Highly recommended.

Great. Thanks table, will look for a podcast

This second tenet is deeply cynical; it resigns itself to antisemitism as fatalism.

Absurd claim. Not cynical at all and very much based on hundreds of years of Jewish history, not to mention prescient of the holocaust.

"Don't be so cynical. Wait around to get killed."

Don’t buy genocide for Christmas.

🌲Puma distributes its products in illegal Israeli settlements.

❌We BOYCOTT to end the international support that legitimises Israel’s war machine. NO PROFIT FROM GENOCIDE, NO PROFIT FROM OCCUPATION. pic.twitter.com/9VApjSfOzL

— Sisters Uncut (@SistersUncut) December 23, 2023

A Jordanian student in Germany, Mohammad Barakat, 21, was shot dead in Hamburg. The shooting was ideologically motivated in response to Mohammad's social media posts about the ongoing genocide in Gaza. This is the direct outcome of state-sponsored racism. pic.twitter.com/a5CP1zfG5N

— Dr. Shahd Hammouri د.شهد الحموري (@shahdhm) December 23, 2023

CONFIRMED: Operation Prosperity Guardian falls apart as France, Spain and Italy withdraw, refusing to put their warships under U.S. command pic.twitter.com/yVY6cj1X1j

— DD Geopolitics (@DD_Geopolitics) December 23, 2023

Smart move by France, Spain and Italy.

https://www.timesnownews.com/world/mohamed-barakat-shooting-jordanian-student-killed-in-hamburg-germany-after-posting-about-gaza-article-106239759

motive as yet unconfirmed on the barakat shooting (I don't know how good this news site is but there's very little reporting on the shooting so far and this is the most recent thing I could find)

https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F7606796d-e837-4e03-864e-3e8130042e4a_730x688.png

This has been an extraordinarily dangerous year for press around the world. Many killed, many more wounded, hundreds detained, attacked, threatened, injured – simply for doing their jobs. I am profoundly grateful to the press for getting accurate, timely information to people.

— Secretary Antony Blinken (@SecBlinken) December 28, 2023

the passive voice

http://cdn.bsky.app/img/feed_thumbnail/plain/did%3Aplc%3At46sqvutibvsmjgwn6r6izve/bafkreidjexmcjzp7sz3vjrrrxf7vpc2oa4jv3p2h5mvdktk2m26d3drjki@jpeg

apparently they've deleted this bit of insanity

Blinken belongs on a fuckin gallows

Watching news at home and they had an item about the conflict which had commentary from the UN, Israeli officials…and refugees in the Rafah camp. IT was a completely unremarkable clip, just a family cooking some rice on a portable cooker, but the fact that they were given a voice at all struck me as notable.

ICC PRESS RELEASE: The Republic of South Africa institutes proceedings against the State of Israel and requests the Court to indicate provisional measures https://t.co/MMpqoheUtk pic.twitter.com/oeWLtKx4fL

— Presidency | South Africa 🇿🇦 (@PresidencyZA) December 29, 2023