Israel/Palestine post 10/7 - follow-on events/thoughts as relate to other countries

Real WWIII vibes from all of this. You don't even need Trump at the White House!

Every university in Gaza destroyed. 94 academic colleagues (many more under rubble), thousands of students dead.

We are publishing papers posthumously. Our collective work destroyed. The plans for my guest lectures to students are ghosts in my diary https://t.co/qJWonITMhW

— Alison Phipps አሊሰን 🧡 (@alison_phipps) January 21, 2024

https://x.com/y_salahiddeen/status/1748790793072992479

xp I'm a little shocked I haven't been able to find much mainstream reporting on the demolition of Israa University. A line in a BBC report, NPR posted about it on Insta (?!), but not much else. From what I can gather, the Israeli military used the campus as a base for the last 70 days before destroying it, making it an act of cultural genocide (imo). Most reports mention the uni housed ~3,000 artifacts, but I've seen reports that Israel looted them before destroying the campus and reports that claim they were destroyed along with the buildings.

kudos to this AP reporter at the US State Dept though:

https://www.aljazeera.com/program/newsfeed/2024/1/19/journalist-questions-bombing-of-gaza-university

Yup, it's good questioning.

xp I'm a little shocked I haven't been able to find much mainstream reporting on the demolition of Israa University. A line in a BBC report, NPR posted about it on Insta (?!), but not much else. From what I can gather, the Israeli military used the campus as a base for the last 70 days before destroying it, making it an act of cultural genocide (imo). Most reports mention the uni housed ~3,000 artifacts, but I've seen reports that Israel looted them before destroying the campus and reports that claim they were destroyed along with the buildings.

kudos to this AP reporter at the US State Dept though:

https://www.aljazeera.com/program/newsfeed/2024/1/19/journalist-questions-bombing-of-gaza-university🕸

JERUSALEM, Jan 21 (Reuters) - Israel's cabinet approved a plan for frozen tax funds earmarked for the Hamas-run Gaza Strip to be held by Norway instead of transferred to the Palestinian Authority (PA), officials said on Sunday.
Under interim peace accords reached in the 1990s, Israel's finance ministry collects tax on behalf of the Palestinians and makes monthly transfers to the Western-backed PA, which exercises limited self-rule in the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
But there have been constant wrangles over the arrangement, including Israel's demand that the funds do not reach Hamas, which it and most of the West deem a terrorist group.
Hamas seized control of Gaza from the Western-backed PA in 2007 after a brief civil war, and two years after Israel withdrew settlers and military forces. Despite the Hamas takeover, many PA public sector employees in Gaza kept their jobs and continued to be paid with transferred tax revenues.
Israel is now at war in Gaza to wipe out Hamas after a cross-border attack by militants of the Palestinian Islamist movement on Oct. 7.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the cabinet decision on the tax funds was supported by Norway and the United States, which will be a guarantor that the framework holds.
Netanyahu's offices said the money, or any equivalent, will not be transferred "in any situation, except with the approval of the Israeli finance minister, and also not through a third party."
The Palestine Liberation Organisation said on Sunday it wanted the money in full and would not accept conditions that prevent it from paying its staff, including in Gaza.
"Any deductions from our financial rights or any conditions imposed by Israel that prevent the PA from paying our people in the Gaza Strip are rejected by us," Hussein Al-Sheikh, secretary general of the executive committee of the PLO, said on social media platform X.
A spokesman for Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, who heads a far-right, pro-settlement party, confirmed that Norway would hold the funds under the arrangement.
"Not one shekel will go to Gaza," said Smotrich, who has long been opposed to transferring funds to the PA.
Reporting by Steven Scheer, Ari Rabinovitch and Ali Sawafta; editing by Mark Heinrich.

taxation without representation

Palestinians in Gaza are eating loaves of bread made from rabbit feed. Some are not posting the photos themselves out of a sense of pride and dignity when really it is the rest of us who need to be ashamed at how this famine has been allowed to go on like this https://t.co/HurhcGRlZt

— Rawan‏𓂆☭ روان (@RiverToSea48) January 21, 2024

I think it's my fault, but we've been posting on the "other countries" thread fyi.

(also xpost to tabes: very true; I guess I meant "shocked" more in the sense of "disgusted" than "surprised"; this genocide has disintegrated any vestigial faith in the media I once had)

More on the Columbia U story that fgti post earlier: https://www.columbiaspectator.com/news/2024/01/22/protesters-allegedly-sprayed-with-hazardous-chemical-at-pro-palestinian-rally-nearly-two-dozen-report/

how weird the death toll is falling as they’re bombing the last remaining hospital, the hospitals being largely responsible for calculating the death toll https://t.co/ZE8oxGYM78

— hil (@plume__) January 22, 2024

there are also thousands of people still buried under rubble

that NY Times piece just leapt out at me as a particularly detached "hmm well let's take a look at the numbers shall we" type tone with the death rate, complete with a coldly analytical chart.

What a letter.

somalis don’t play when it comes to palestine. this traitor’s family just disowned him. https://t.co/7qZFpJqO46 pic.twitter.com/x5xQNK6A6i

— fatoom (@fatimasflavors) January 27, 2024

Defunding UNRWA at this critical time overtly defies @ICJ's order to allow effective humanitarian assistance "to address the adverse conditions of life faced by Palestinians in Gaza". This will entail legal responsibilities - or the demise of the int'l legal system. https://t.co/xEc80VaMEO

— Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur oPt (@FranceskAlbs) January 28, 2024

Honestly, the international legal apparatus is a tool for the West to punish non-Western countries and wash their own hands clean of wrongdoing while doing the most harm. The ICJ, the International Criminal Court, all of it is a fucking charade.

hope y'all are being well compensated by Putin to post here

Nancy Pelosi: Protesters calling for a ceasefire in Gaza "is Mr. Putin's message... Make no mistake, this is directly connected to what he would like to see...

"I think some of these protesters are spontaneous and organic and sincere. Some I think are connected to Russia." pic.twitter.com/hMwcM2WmKj

— Jacob N. Kornbluh (@jacobkornbluh) January 28, 2024

Vile racists gonna vile racist

What a letter.

Ahmed Hussen's our MP; my wife has met with him (on another issue) and he mainly impressed her with his doggedness at adhering to the Liberal party line.

Citations Needed has posted a couple shorter podcast episodes getting into legacy media whitewashing of both the destruction but also trying to reframe the ICJ:

https://citationsneeded.libsyn.com/news-brief-quantifying-the-medias-selective-humanity-in-gaza

https://citationsneeded.libsyn.com/news-brief-the-icj-ruling-and-the-essentialness-of-squishy-western-liberal-support-for-genocide

Like the artist's response to this

An artist with German Jewish heritage cancels her exhibition in Germany after being questioned about signing her IG posts “Free Palestine” without “from Hamas” pic.twitter.com/AuTWEwtkfm

— James Jackson (@derJamesJackson) January 30, 2024

Jesus Christ, how smug that letter is

I get the distinct impression the Germans are trying a wee bit too hard. I wonder why that would be?

Her response is worth reading too imo pic.twitter.com/3kQIWOCf3M

— boltcutters fetcher (@jasminegalx) January 30, 2024

Germany, always on the right side of history

how did we get to Germans accusing Jews of anti-semitism

DARVO

how did we get to Germans accusing Jews of anti-semitism

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Germans_(political_current)

might have something to do with it

they just represent a more extreme and idiosyncratic version of the mainstream German POV which is that support for Israel is the means by which the German nation has morally redeemed itself (which also justifies German economic imperialism) and thus any criticism of Israel is a threat to the German Staatsräson (and German domination in Europe) - and nothing is more threatening to this way of thinking than Jewish people who won't perform their assigned role in the German national redemption story

unlike the mainstream the Antideutsche express this through explicitly anti-German rhetoric but they are still so fucking German it's painful and they're just as antisemitic, islamophobic and colonialist as the mainstream if not more so

also worth remembering that denazification is a myth and that the west and the east both refused to deal with themselves in differently bad ways and modern Germany is like a synthesis of both approaches (very broadly speaking - denial/justification and displacement/projection)

^ ^ ^

denazification is a myth

true. it was never possible to expunge nazism. the war crime trials and executions in Nuremberg, the strict censorship of nazi symbolism/propaganda, ritual denunciations of the past, and other denazification tools have at best served as guard rails to limit the reach of nazi sentiments and open up space for other ideologies to enter. the results have been far from perfect but mostly acceptable. Among EU countries Germany's current level of fascist sentiment seems no worse than 'about average'.

I suppose one can see 20% for the AfD as "about average" in a European context but "mostly acceptable" it ain't

"Denazification is a myth" is less about whether a good job was done in banning swastikas and more about the amount of nazis who ended up in cushy positions of economic and political power in the postwar era I'd say, possibly not a topic for this thread tho

the AfD at 20% in the country that spawned nazism, while fascism is currently flourishing in a dozen countries that never even tried to 'de-nazi' themselves shows that the efforts to limit its reach in Germany did work about as well as it could have in the real world, considering the country emerged from WWII saturated in nazism.

I don't even know where to start with that post.

"Nazism is at acceptable levels, I declare this denazification process a realistic success".

I'd read previously that West Germany had largely 'denazified' by the mid 1960s. Not quite sure how to quantify that, but whats the consensus on that process, and to what extent it occurred?

East Germany seems more difficult to measure. Seems more prevalent, but how much of any resurgence is a resurgence, or something which was frozen in time under Soviet influence

it didn't - the vast majority of nazis stayed in positions of power and until at least the 60s (much later in many cases) the general approach seems to have been to just not talk about it (while letting the CIA recruit the best anticommunists). even I still grew up with the notion that it was rude to ask about what my grandparents' generation might have done and this was in the 90s/00s (semi-rural bavaria but still)

the GDR did a much better job of removing nazis from publicly facing positions (while recruiting some of them into the stasi as well as funding some neo-nazis in the west) but they portrayed the Germans in general as victims of fascism and took the Moscow line on refusing to acknowledge the specificity of the genocide, while pointing to the west as the only place where the legacy of fascism lived on

Fellas.

Larry David shares his favorite episode of #CurbYourEnthusiasm. pic.twitter.com/6IKIS9PApC

— Variety (@Variety) January 31, 2024

it didn't - the vast majority of nazis stayed in positions of power and until at least the 60s

Bad wording on my part, I meant to say that by 1965-1968 most of the nazis were gone (presumably mainly through ageing out of the system?), but were newer nazis gradually replacing them during that period, so that even if the original nazis had aged out, nazis were still running some stuff, thats what I'm less clear on

it didn't - the vast majority of nazis stayed in positions of power and until at least the 60s (much later in many cases) the general approach seems to have been to just not talk about it (while letting the CIA recruit the best anticommunists). even I still grew up with the notion that it was rude to ask about what my grandparents' generation might have done and this was in the 90s/00s (semi-rural bavaria but still)

The dude that Baader Meinhof kidnapped and murdered was a SS untersturmfuhrer who then became an industry big shot in the postwar era, quite representative in a way.

(I think I only asked my grampa about the third reich once, reply was a weak "well everyone was going along with it", but I must have been like 8 so prob he didn't think I could have handled a more elaborate take. My parents did talk to me about the holocaust and Germany's responsibilities a lot, but then they were dirty hippies).

anvil, I don't think German elites in the late 60's/early 70's were particularly interested in keeping the fire of nazism alive in an overt way, which is not to say they didn't harbour fascist or anti-semitic beliefs. it's kind of a question of what "newer nazis" means within that historical context.

Bad wording on my part, I meant to say that by 1965-1968 most of the nazis were gone (presumably mainly through ageing out of the system?),

If you were in your 30s by the end of the war you were only in your 50s by the mid-60s.

https://pitchfork.com/news/robyn-fever-ray-and-other-swedish-artists-call-for-israel-ban-at-eurovision-song-contest-2024/

Honestly, if Israel is let in but Russia and Belarus aren’t, it wouldn’t be surprising but it would evidence what many of us have been saying the whole time: Palestinian lives don’t matter to Western institutions.

Also, though: why is Israel in the Eurovision contest in the first place? It isn’t in Europe?

Australia has been in it a few times and they're in completely the wrong side of the planet.

Israel's been in Eurovision since the 70s and their football team(s) play in European competitions. They don't have any friends in their immediate vicinity.

Bizarre, imho— why not just make it “The Song Contest” ffs

For the same reason only Earth women compete in "Miss Universe."

Europe isn't a continent, it's a state of white