Military cremation would alter tradition
WASHINGTON (CNN) -- The Pentagon is considering cremating remains of troops who may die in a chemical or biological attack in a possible war with Iraq, officials said Thursday.
Use of field cremation would alter a longtime U.S. military tradition of making every effort to return each person's body home in a flag-draped coffin.
It is not yet clear if the military would operate a crematorium in the Middle East or how the ashes would be sorted and returned to families.
The Pentagon also would have to address cultural and religious objections by some service members.
The reason for the high-level policy review is the prospect of mass casualties, especially from smallpox or anthrax, that would require the quick disposal of bodies to protect the living.
If adopted, the policy would be used by commanders only as a last resort if regular decontamination procedures are overwhelmed, Pentagon officials said.
Cremation has never been an authorized means of dealing with remains on the battlefield. A final decision on the policy review is expected within weeks.
My questions:
1. When was the first war/military conflict when the U.S. returned bodies to the U.S. for internment? I thought we buried in Europe during WWII, though I'm not sure about the war in the Pacific. I think that bodies were shipped back during the Korean and Vietnamese conflicts/wars/however you want to characterize them. But didn't we bury all overseas in WWI? (Maybe based on lack of transportation?)
2. Was there not cremation on the Civil War battlefields, or were all of the bodies buried where they fell or ...I assume that they were not shipped home?
3. Would you object to your body being cremated overseas and then your ashes returned to your family? If your body was a contamination threat/danger to others? If your body wasn't?
4. What are the religious/cultural objections that might be raised in opposition to this proposal? (I know that some faiths say that the body must be buried intact - but is there more?)
― I'm Passing Open Windows (Ms Laura), Friday, 7 February 2003 03:37 (twenty-two years ago)