I had a dream last night I became a... Catholic!

I don't remember the context, but there I was, about the take the oath or whatnot. I don't remember any catechism or anything. At first I was excited but then a little voice called out "Andy, you're not catholic material! You're a protestant! The Reformation! Martin Luther! Simplicity, earthiness, not ritual, not grandeur!" And I felt great dread, then I awoke in relief.

I'm actually seeing an atheist right now, but it raised the question: would I switch for someone? I don't think I could.