do we live a shadow life in dreams?

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
ok that sounds a bit mystical, but it's not really

what i've noticed is that, in some dreams, what's going on refers back to an earlier part of your life - something you did before, somewhere you've been before. as it's a dream, this earlier thing is NOT REAL: in your waking life you never did it, never went there (the "there" doesn't exist)... but the sense in the dream of continuity, of it being "real" part, is overwhelming, in the sense, even when you wake, and realise yes it wz a dream, and none of it happened IN REAL LIFE, the link to the past DOESN'T fade with day, but feels right and true

my theory which is mine: the "past" you are locking into in the dream is in fact a previous dream (or sequence of dream-"types"); in the dream you are "remembering" the feelings, facts, events, places of the earlier dream - "remembering" of course in the strange context of dream-logic, where the "same place" can look totally different!!

the classic dream for me is the "travelling across london" dream: i am getting from east to west (reason variable and unspecified) and there is no easy direct route; i have to go WELL out of my way and change buses or trains somewhere, generally in some part of london i don't at all know --- i have this dream quite a lot, and on the whole the topography chances every time, but there are PARTS of my dream london, certain intersections, certain landmarks, which appear nearly every time (always in different phsical guise; but which i "know" and "recognise" from previous dream-visits... and similarrly feel are familiar when i awake, even though when awake i can safely say they are not parts of the actual real city i live in)

i guess what i am proposing: that the sense of familiarity relates to its being a certain TYPE of dream recurring - and given that at some level in the the real-life dreams we "know" we are dreaming, this manifests as an awareness of continuity (of dreamplace, of dream-event), even though such continuity makes little sense in terms of what we are seeing or experiencing in the dream

mark s (mark s), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 07:39 (twenty years ago)

(warning: i am not sure i have woken up yet properly)

mark s (mark s), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 07:44 (twenty years ago)

ever since i was young i can remember having the same type of dream over and over, but i was never sure whether it was just an illusion or not.

J.D. (Justyn Dillingham), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 07:48 (twenty years ago)

I often have the travel/map dream - usually I am trying to get from one bit of NYC to another, but it's no relation to the real NYC, just this sort of idealised dream version with scary and confusing transit systems built from all the bits of the subway/bridges/etc. that have ever scared me.

The maps seem to change as I read them, and bear no relation to any real place, yet they seem completely familiar as I look at them in my dream.

MIS Information (kate), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 07:50 (twenty years ago)

i am totally agreeing with this. i have a very recurring dream based in what appears to be an extremely detailed city, the same city with the same roads and themes. god its fucking cool.

Ste (Fuzzy), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 07:53 (twenty years ago)

i've had dreams like that! where one travels overground through london and the landmarks are there but not where you would have expected them to be, e.g. parliament always seems to be atop a rocky promontory and then you realise the train is travelling OVER the top of st paul's...and then all of a sudden i disembark in parsons green - but it's a kind of 1974-vintage parsons green, the kind of immediate postwar wreckage of a fulham you see in dennis p's lipstick on your collar.

quite often in these dreams if i'm visiting a record shop it's rough trade, but it's the old rough trade shop in kensington park road and it's always 1976 and they've got demis roussos playing on the speakers.

but the more peculiar and disturbing series of dreams i have are those involving laura. these happen extremely often, and in them we seem to be leading an entirely normal life as though nothing had happened. this life progresses in logical parallel, night after night, even though i know there are things which happen in them that L would never have done IRL and there are sometimes clear references that, somehow, we split up (in august 2001) and have come together again. in those variations of the dream she is usually a lot more cynical about me, and more than somewhat disappointed in me. and yet at other times there are references which clearly indicate that this is all happening in a parallel past - an alternative universe 1989 or 1994. but any familiarity (routines etc.) is purely in the context of the dream, as opposed to what went on IRL. i am sure that this is all simplistically freudian. but many is the time when i wake up into a hostile and lonely world and feel that the world i was dreaming was immeasurably preferable to the one in which i have to "live."

this is slightly wandering and doesn't really answer the question raised, but it's the closest thing i've experienced to this specific thing.

Marcello Carlin (nostudium), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 07:55 (twenty years ago)

yes the dream i had last night which spurred this suggested a much WORSE shadow life (viz that i had had some psychotic episode round the time i left the nme and the pieces i wz writing were all demented and had to be spiked and everyone wz worried about me: well this DIDN'T HAPPEN but when i woke up i had a strong feeling that i had dreamt a similar once-went-insane past for myself several times before, so that IN the dream i had no problem being comfortable with the feeling that this wz part of my past)

but yes, repeat-dreaming a BETTER shadow life totally fits into this as well

mark s (mark s), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 08:03 (twenty years ago)

The shadow world in these dreams is often worse. Transportation is confusing and threatening.

It's a bit like the Welsh Dream.

MIS Information (kate), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 08:06 (twenty years ago)

(clarification: in dream i had wz not about these psychotic episode directly, it wz about meeting w.ageing nme buddies and discussing them as it today, in retrospect: them telling me things now they didn't say back then etc, and describing the events from their POV)

(and the thing that feels like a continuity - ie common to other earlier dreams - is the "memory of strange mental episodes in my past", not the specifics of when these happened or how)

(ie i wd classif this as a TYPE of anxiety dream, recurring in different narrative garb, i guess)

mark s (mark s), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 08:07 (twenty years ago)

fortunately i have yet to experience a set of recurring, self-contained nightmares in which i am repeatedly terrorised by a HORRIBLE DOG ahem

Marcello Carlin (nostudium), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 08:08 (twenty years ago)

I sometimes have dreams where i'm trying to find people, probably my family but everytime I think i'm getting close they are taken further and further away. I usually wake up feeling unsettled and a bit down.

I also have one where i'm tied to helicopter blades.

Jarlr'mai (jarlrmai), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 08:11 (twenty years ago)

I have dreamt I was a schizophrenic, once. But it wasnt me, it was as if I was in someone else's dreams/mind. Very scary and vivid. "Here. have a holiday in this nutters head for a night".

Trayce (trayce), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 08:12 (twenty years ago)

I keep having this dream in this house- it appears to be a mix of all the houses I have lived in- with weird corridors, I see people I have seen before and go places, but it changes every time either the location or the peoples faces morph. I have never been there in real life or met any of these people.

battlingspacemonkey (battlingspacemonkey), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 08:16 (twenty years ago)

ohh and the weirdest bit is where i open cupboards that lead to other places - or other houses... narnia!

battlingspacemonkey (battlingspacemonkey), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 08:33 (twenty years ago)

Jung posited that as exploration of parts of the self, in Man and His Symbols. I have very similar dreams. Once I dreamt of a house I had come into the possesion of that had all these amazing rooms - one section was a cosy, homely modern place with low ceilings and clean lines... then up the hallway was a twisty multi-levelled part with a tucked away attic bedrooom that was my safe cosy haven.. .and then on out into this HUGE old cathedral like space full of stained glass windows, where my grandfather was holding a talk on the room's history. Had me puzzling over what it meant about my self for ages.

I dont re-dream a life inside that house though, sadly - its only appeared the once ;(

Trayce (trayce), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 09:37 (twenty years ago)

I need to re-reread Jung because I seem to have house dreams as well. Not as often as transport dreams, but often enough to wonder what it means.

MIS Information (kate), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 09:40 (twenty years ago)

i wonder what it means when you dream of h4ving s3x with your partner and then their face morphs into demons or people youve never seen before.

battlingspacemonkey (battlingspacemonkey), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 10:10 (twenty years ago)

I don't know, mark, but I do know I've sometimes found myself remembering previous dreams or fragments of dreams, ones I hadn't thought about for a long time, while falling asleep. Maybe that is some sort of re-orientation process?

RS LaRue (RSLaRue), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 10:39 (twenty years ago)

I have two un-named towns, one coastal and one county town, that appear frequently. These are both fairly nightmarish, or, at the least distressing. But I also have a Dream London and, on two occassions, a dream New York. The latter is particularly weird as I've never been to NYC.

Anna (Anna), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 10:46 (twenty years ago)

I tend to dream — in vivid detail — about my actual real life, with none of the surrealness most people have. Normal things, like getting up and going to the shops, which is:

a) very confusing when it's about my current life and I wake up and realise that the past six hours didn't actually happen

and

b) very disturbing when it's about my earlier life and things I'd rather not experience again.

Hello Sunshine (Hello Sunshine), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 10:49 (twenty years ago)

What I really hate is when I start the journey in Dream London and end up in Dream NYC. Or vice versa. That's just too confusing. Plus, you would think the trains would crash through being on the wrong tracks.

MIS Information (kate), Tuesday, 5 July 2005 10:52 (twenty years ago)

wow awesome! i have often wondered about this too... i have a very vivid place i go to a lot in my dreams, it's a city by the sea. it's no city i've ever been to irl (i think it's a different world - superficially v similar to our own but small details and a strong sense of otherness tells me it's somewhere else), but a lot of my dreams happen there and the dreams themselves are never duplicated, though some of them do have points in common.

the first time i went there was with my parents and brother and a friend, we travelled there by boat and the harbour was this huge yellow cave with all other boats in it queueing up for the people to get off on the beach. since then i haven't been there by boat, usually by train, occasionally road, once or twice by foot - it's always the same train station, one where the underground and overground systems coincide, though you sometimes have to run to make the connection to the overground part that swoops up through and around the buildings (this part reminds me slightly of a town called sha tin in the new territories in hk, but it definitely isn't sha tin). sometimes i have missed the train, but there's always another one eventually. there is a green line and a red line but they aren't the district and central lines. the trains themselves have green and red on too.

once me and the russian and the belgian were looking for a place to live there, we found a flat that only had one room but it was a massive room with 2 of the walls replaced by floor-to-ceiling windows and it was right on the water, out the front was wooden decking and a ladder to get in the sea so we decided to take the flat. i went in the water while the other two were inside discussing rent and there were sharks. i was frightened but stayed calm and tried not to splash, but the sharks just circled me and escorted me back to the ladder like a sheepdog does with a stray sheep, then disappeared once i was out. usually none of my irl friends/family are there but occasionally some show up.

often i have done awful, wrong things in these dreams or awful, wrong things have happened to me and i am escaping/hiding - i've frequently kidnapped my own child (i have no child irl) and once had to run along the rocks in a storm below the train tracks on the way to the city to escape, once i was hiding in a toilet clutching this child to me and "they" were in the next cubicle. once i had killed someone but i knew "they" wouldn't catch me if i just jumped from bed to bed along this endless wide corridor in a hotel without touching the ground. my mum was in that one and i could not make her understand that i had killed a person, she wouldn't believe me and just tried to reassure me that it would be ok, but i knew nothing would ever be ok again.

the terror and the guilt in the dreams are immense and very very real, i always wake up very dislocated from these dreams and they stay with me for days. the land in my dreams seems more lawless than this one and there is more riding on things somehow, it is more desperate.

i like the idea that if i could remember dreaming in the dream if it would be this life i dreamed of and i would be thinking about this shadow life i lived in this city with a river and all these grotty indie dives i went to.

oh! the breakfast factory i dreamed of once is in the same dream-land too. in that one i could fly, i went too far out over the sea without realising it though and got scared when i turned round and could hardly see land, but i headed back and approached the city from the air this time and got breakfast from the breakfst factory.

maybe it means i want to break free and want a more lawless existence, dropped out from routine.

or maybe all these dreams reveal is that i have a secret desire to be keanu reeves.

emsk, Tuesday, 5 July 2005 16:03 (twenty years ago)

bump

bump, Tuesday, 5 July 2005 20:08 (twenty years ago)

I wonder if the "city of dreams" has replaced the "house of dreams" as the Jungian symbol of the self. Though no, probably not - the House still probably represents the self, while the City represents the often confused and confusing External World.

I need more coffee. I've been so tired I've not been remembering my dreams.

MIS Information (kate), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 06:34 (twenty years ago)

weird dream thing last night, which was kind of shadow-worldy. In the midst of a thrilling dream where I was being chased by an fbi man, who I shot w/a tranquiliser dart (!!!!) I found myself down in the valley by the river derwent, which is down the hill from where I live. I remembered that there was this shale bank next to a steep bend in the river, where a little cargo ship had run aground, I'd come across it last year when I was out on a walk. I remembered that I'd meant to take the little feller to see it, so I started walking back up to the house, but I woke up, and remembered that I hadn't actually seen the grounded ship, I'd dreamed about it a year ago, and I'd been reminded of it when I'd seen the same location in my dream-landscape. Weird, eh?

Pashmina (Pashmina), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 07:39 (twenty years ago)

pash that's exactly what i'm talking about yes!!@

like there is not simply a landscape that we revisit in certain dreams - not that that isn't interesting in itself - but a narrative thread also

mark s (mark s), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 07:51 (twenty years ago)

and what's weird is that you "remember" your dream in a dream a year later, but it had been totally forgotten in all the waking team between!

mark s (mark s), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 07:53 (twenty years ago)

I dream a lot about failure. A lot of the time - when I feel really insecure about myself - I dream that I failed my exams. Sometimes this dream (or rather nightmare) is so vivid I wake up thinking I have indeed failed my exams. I really don't believe that we have a shadow life, I always feel our dreams are there to battle our emotions.

nathalie's body's designed for two (stevie nixed), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 08:01 (twenty years ago)

"Welsh Dream"?

mei (mei), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 08:17 (twenty years ago)

I'd love to know what the girl was dreaming of in this story...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/4654579.stm

NickB (NickB), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 08:38 (twenty years ago)

cranes?

Ste (Fuzzy), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 08:42 (twenty years ago)

Oh, it's so obvious now you mention it! ;0)

NickB (NickB), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 08:45 (twenty years ago)

mark s:

Do I need to call an exorcist for my girlfriend?

Vichitravirya XI (Vichitravirya XI), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 10:50 (twenty years ago)

((mysticism intentional, o'course.))

Vichitravirya XI (Vichitravirya XI), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 10:51 (twenty years ago)

I've had the transport dream too, but cos I'm not in London, I'm dreaming I have to catch a train to London. I stop at all the usual stations on my way up, Stevenage, Welwyn, Hatfield, but they are in the wrong order and don't look the same, and I have to change train about a million times. Some of the trains are old-fashioned steam trains and once or twice I dreamt I didn't manage to get through the door but managed to stand on a step and hold on very tight as the train whizzed through tunnels and other obstacles. Very scarey.

Another recurring dream is being at the top of either a stairwell or a cliff or the mast of a ship (the latter being the scariest because not only is it very high up but it moves around as well).

One strange but common dream is being at a festival and getting lost and because it's a festival there are all sorts of weird and wonderful things going on. This ties in with another regular dream I have of crawling through a series of tunnels to get from room to room. I'll find a hidden passage in a building I'm familiar with, crawl through it and find myself in a really nice special room that only I know about. Once I dreamt I was at a festival and instead of tents, people lived in large cardboard houses made of these crawl tunnels.

dog latin (dog latin), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 12:36 (twenty years ago)

Taking trains has an emotional meaning. I think it has to do with (not) being able to keep up with others, if I remember correctly.

nathalie's body's designed for two (stevie nixed), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 12:39 (twenty years ago)

Hah! I hadn't read the whole thread -funny that everyone has the same kinda dreams innit?

dog latin (dog latin), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 12:40 (twenty years ago)

I have dreamt I was a schizophrenic, once. But it wasnt me, it was as if I was in someone else's dreams/mind. Very scary and vivid. "Here. have a holiday in this nutters head for a night".

Similarly, I've dreamt that I've been on coke or acid (drugs which I've never taken).

dog latin (dog latin), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 12:42 (twenty years ago)

Anna, your NYC thing reminds me I've dreamt the same on several occasions! I have had a few dreams I'm there, which I also have never really been too. I'm usually wandering in dank alleyways with loads of graffiti and mess, I suppose its the result of too much L&O or somesuch ;) One time I was looking for some hipster club entrance down a side street and I was having loads of fun exploring; another time I was walking around streets looking at apartments and thinking it was odd they all were small standalone blocks with balconies like we have in Aus suburbs, and not at all like I suppose flats actually are in NYC. I liked one flat, I wanted to rent it. But there was loads of shitty vacant lot garbagey areas nearby I didnt like the look of.

Trayce (trayce), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 12:46 (twenty years ago)

i have this too, except i always wonder if i am actually remembering old dreams in my dream-fugue-state, or if i am "remembering" them. last night i had a strange dream involving romance and loss and then i "realized" that some of the people in the dream were ghosts PRETENDING to be people that had died in an earlier dream I had, so i spent the second half of the dream trying to send them back from whence they came, which involved drawing many repetitive square runes over and over again. i had another dream-memory too, but i can't remember how exactly it fit in, or what it was.

Sterling Clover (s_clover), Wednesday, 6 July 2005 17:10 (twenty years ago)

eighteen years pass...

ok so i woke out of a dream about being a tired and harassed magazine editor -- something that of course also happened to me in real life for a while -- and realised as i thought about it that i had been dreaming about a run of magazines i had been editing that were bad and failing, and (now awake) that i staightaway associated them with an earlier run of magazines i had been editing that were bad and failing.

in other words that both runs existed only in dreams, and i think there have been more. that this aspect of me has been regular but a mostly forgotten shadow life: the magazines i actually edited (which were ok -- doubtless many thought otherwise but the mag is after all still going 30 years later) plus repeated anxiety-ridden dreamruns of mags with were a comically flailing and humilating disaster, which nag at me subconsciously

(this is probably a thread where you have to go back to the OP for context) (or you can just ignore it lol)

mark s, Wednesday, 17 April 2024 10:06 (two years ago)

eighteen years jesus

mark s, Wednesday, 17 April 2024 10:06 (two years ago)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vPQgfaB3S1c

mookieproof, Wednesday, 17 April 2024 10:39 (two years ago)

I have a dream oxford very much like in the original post, a particular part of the city that bears a vague resemblance to the original but is fairly consistent across dreams (including a large covered tunnel going across a major road from a shopping centre, which echoes a long gone much smaller one irl. I haven't been to this dreamscape in quite some time though.

I don't have such a specific london, but I do have a nightmare london underground which is horrible and mazelike and full of insane escalator routes and passages that shrink down to an impossibly small size through which I must travel.

ledge, Wednesday, 17 April 2024 11:08 (two years ago)

I have the same London Underground swirling around my unconscious mind! Many of these pedestrian tunnels have piles of rubble in them. Often there will be people who glare at me as I pass.

Cormac knows what's up:
https://nautil.us/the-kekul-problem-236574/

the scouse that roared (Matt #2), Wednesday, 17 April 2024 11:32 (two years ago)

My theory is that your older memories are an interconnected long term database with tags - short, loose categories that group and connect these memories.

Dreaming is your brain taking recent memories out of the temporary storage where they start out and filing them away with the older memories in the long term database. More importantly, dreams are your brain tagging the more recent memories so that they can be connected and anchored to the older memories in the database.

The dreams don't track with the real memory (places look different, etc.) because the dream isn't just the new memory, it's the tagging and amalgamation with older memories.

I find familiarity in dreams comes from a "double dream" (my term) - a dream that immediately repeats a second time, often with a slightly different conclusion. This is the brain running the new memory through the database again to make sure the connections are secure. It feels familiar because your brain just processed the same memory.

il lavoro mi rovina la giornata (PBKR), Wednesday, 17 April 2024 11:56 (two years ago)

i don't remember my dreams well, but i have a lot of them

i take prazosin every night to deal with the ptsd nightmares. actually, idk if "ptsd" is the right word, since it implies the trauma is past. like, is there a word for mid-trauma stress disorder? there should be.

anyway. i still have nightmares sometimes. for me dreams are kind of a way of subconsciously processing the stuff going on in my daily life. the nightmares kind of make sense. sometimes i wake up from a nightmare in the middle of the night and i gotta use my dbt skills to kind of process whatever was going on in the nightmare, to recognize that i'm ok and that whatever it is i'm having a nightmare about is something i can radically accept.

when i'm not having nightmares, most of my dreams are quite ordinary. my life in dreams is often more ordinary than my waking life. it has a lot more in common with the life i used to live in the Before Time, but without the crushing gender dysphoria that was my constant companion during those times. it's kind of pleasant, nostalgia for the kind of life i never quite had. and then i wake up and everything seems quite strange and horrific. ever since 2016 i've had a hard time convincing myself that my waking life is real, that this isn't just some sort of wildly implausible prolonged dystopian fantasy. i can't quite make _sense_ of a lot of things. plus, traumas recur in my everyday life the way people have recurring nightmares about certain things. that doesn't help.

complicating it further is that sometimes i will have a dream inside a dream, i'll wake up and be relieved that whatever i was dreaming was only a dream. and then i'll wake up again and be sad that _that_ dream was only a dream. like there's a sort of layer cake:

reality
dream state (pleasant)
dream state (nightmare)

i'd like it a lot if dream state (pleasant) turned out to be actually real and my life right now was a nightmare that would just go away. no offense to anybody else in this benighted shared reality.

Kate (rushomancy), Wednesday, 17 April 2024 12:47 (two years ago)


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.