Creepiest Other on L O S T rite?

Tough one. I ended up going with Ethan, he seems to have natural creepiness whereas Ben plays at it.

Ben, no doubt. He's just touched.

I like your last option, I shall start using it. :)

Also, I vote Alpert for the hottest Other. The eyeliner thing doesn't usually do it for me but the fact that he coule be an age-less pirate does.

yeah, i'd do Alpert

I <3 Alex 4eva. How could Ben not win this?

it's not clear cut! Ms Klugh was UBERCREEPY in S2 finale.
Ben gets the lazy votes imo.

onimo OTM re: Ben, I also voted for Ethan.

I love Ben, but he's not really creepy anymore at this point.

ie he's not creepy when he's tied to a tree after having the shit kicked outta him rite? but ms klugh even DIED in a creepy wai.

I have no idea who Mrs. Klugh is.

http://nl.lostpedia.com/nl_images/2/20/MsKlugh.jpg

Bea Klugh - creeped out Michael to turn bad and then demanded to be killed in Island Momus episode.

xpost yeah her^

clearly Jacob is the creepiest. Ben close 2nd.

Alpert's mascara manbag is creepy tho

Mikhail deserves some props for repeatedly not dying and for having missing eye and ruthless & sadistic streak. Also keeps a cat - classic creepy bad guy move.

Dude Ethan was way creepier than Ben. At least with Ben we have some idea as to motivation etc. Plus Ethan had no middle ground, he was either murdering Claire-napper or smiling friendly Juliet-recruiter.

Mikhail's not really creepy though, he's actually kind of pathetic. I love him though and hope he comes back next season, possibly minus one hand/arm.

Oh shit I should've voted for Jacob, I just looked right past him.

Cmon dude how can you say Mikhail's manky socket isn't creepy. Like you didn't cover yr face with a cushion.

I wasn't 100% sure whether to include our man Jakey. After all, can he be counted as an Other? Hence the question mark after his name.

Oh shit I should've voted for Jacob, I just looked right past him.

-- nickalicious, Friday, June 15, 2007 10:44 AM (Friday, June 15, 2007 10:44 AM) Bookmark Link

wah-wah-waaaaah.

nicka wins this thread

Mikhail is fun.

Who was that old lady who interrogated Jack and Juliet?

God Lost talk is confusing when you haven't watched it since episode four.

Her name was Isabelle I think? NOt very creepy, but I did like her.

she was pretty creepy with her Zsa Zsa Gabor like voice.

yeah she was kinda creepy but since she was in the Crap Jack Tat eppy, also completely forgotten.

http://www.lostpedia.com/images/thumb/3/31/Pickettglass.jpg/248px-Pickettglass.jpg

No "Other" val dude can touch me! lolz

Pickett wasn't all that creepy as a character but there was a lot of residual creeped-outedness on my part from his role in Kill Bill.

Ok, ppl who don't think Picket is creepy, imagine this scenario:

Tom: Ok, so we'll totally ambush Michael by distracting him with one guy and have a couple more come up behind him rite?
Picket: Yeah! We'll capture him up good!
Tom: Ok, positions everyone, here he comes!
Picket: Can I pretend to be taking a piss?
Tom: Jesus Picket, why always with the pissing?
Picket: Cmon man, please?
Tom: Christ, whatever. Alright.
Picket: YES!

Ethan! IRL Cruiser cousin = crepe au naturel.

Also you left out Goodwin, but he's not creepy at all.

oh he is

hot damn, i hate myself for missing out creepy neck-snapper goodwin ;_;

you linus

i don't think jakob should count as an udder

Voting for the chick who called herself 'The Sheriff'.

so creepy she disappeared from the show completely.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Which one was the female high sheriff type who passed judgment on Juliet and made her get branded?

Aldo was mad cute, yo

"IF. YOU. KEEP. FOLLOWING. ME. I. WILL. KILL. ONE. OF. THEM."

Ethan's kkkkkkkkkkkk-creepiness is that he actually talked like a Dalek.

Alpert obv. tho "eyeroller" WTF? It's Eyeliner baby.

Which one was the female high sheriff type who passed judgment on Juliet and made her get branded?

-- Rock Hardy, Saturday, June 16, 2007 11:56 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Link

Voting for the chick who called herself 'The Sheriff'.

-- Mikey Bidness, Saturday, June 16, 2007 4:49 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Link

http://www.lostpedia.com/images/thumb/8/8b/3X09_TomJackIsabel.jpg/180px-3X09_TomJackIsabel.jpg

isabel.

as sexy as any other other

gis isabel lost result # 2

http://utenti.lycos.it/andreacflm/blog/lost.jpg

i voted ethan.

Alpert obv. tho "eyeroller" WTF? It's Eyeliner baby.

It says eyeLOLler, not eyeroller.

Sayid's face in that 3rd panel is brilliant.

ethan ftw. the look on his face and the way he says "hello, there" when he's about to kidnap claire and charlie creep me the fuck out. that scene has continued to outcreep everything else on lost.

I voted Ethan--Tom was only creepy (and extremely so) in the Season 1 finale...afterwards, sans beard, plus boobs, not so much.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

I saw William Mapother hanging out at SXSW a couple years ago. I wanted to say hi but I was kinda creeped out. He apparently likes Rhett Miller.

I'm really pleased that Ethan won this. Even creepy IRL! Amazing.
Let's hope we see him with Charlie's head grafted onto his back or some shit in Zombie Season.