Ruthless Reviews--C or D?

For those of you who have visited the review site: http://www.ruthlessreviews.com/.

I would have voted classic 3 years ago, and almost still want to for the amazing 80's Action Movie Guide.

but I'm leaning towards dud due to Matt Cale's descent into self-parody. The 'ruthless' reviewing style was entertaining for a while but it almost seems like he takes his schtick too seriously now and tends to grandstand and draw parallels to things that aren't there in all of his reviews now.

Plus he's always had this habit of making insensitive comments to the mentally disabled (re: RETARDED).