FAVORITE PEPPERIDGE FARM COOKIE

o

yeah o will probably win sadly

i'm voting milano

GENEVA

YOU FORGOT THE OPTION FOR BLUEBERRY VERONAS.

* Lisbon*
o
+ Orange cookies dipped in chocolate

^^ WHERE DO I GET THESE?

i dont know. but i could go for a bag of pirouettes (these only seem to come in the samplers)

milano, sentimental vote. all these were good. except when they tried to go 'down home' e.g. the Chesapeake Choc Chip

$2.99 for 6 cookies means the last one I ate was ca. 1994

double chocolate milano are tite
also mint milano

but i could go for a bag of pirouettes (these only seem to come in the samplers)

OTM (sad about the sampler-only situation)

their large round 'soft batch' style cookies are rarely as good as the traditional three level stack of goodness. i do like the double chocolate whatever ones though.

Chocolate Chessmen

^^ again, where??

i love chessmen. the same way the only girlscout cookie i REALLY love is the basic shortbread cookie jammer.

Thick, heart-shaped peanut butter cookies in a a chocolate sandwich

^why do you illude me?

lol elude me
what ~ ever bring your chocalate peanutbutter sandwichness to me now

milano

Pirouettes come in tins mang, any grocery store worth grocing at will have them

I can't pick a favorite from the milano family, I wish they'd put out variety packs bc how oversexed do you have to be to really need an entire thing of orange milanos

otm. my milano vote is a general show of appreciation for the entire genus.

http://i13.tinypic.com/4ucyf85.jpg

Dont't * Pirouettes come in tins?

http://www.artofthecookie.com/images/products/softbakednantucket.jpghttp://www.artofthecookie.com/images/products/softbakednantucket.jpghttp://www.artofthecookie.com/images/products/softbakednantucket.jpg

...

chessmen highly underrated

BORDEAUX, regular

I will not have any other as winner

RIP ginger man?

Mint Milano.

And I hate those commercials that imply that Milanos are for frustrating moms seeking a break from their mothering activities. I'm a man, and I LIVE for Milanos.

Double Chocolate Milano kick ass, but strangely, milk chocolate Milanos miss the point.

I LIKE THE SOFT ONE W/THE MACADAMEA NUTS AND WHITE CHOCO

SO AWZOMLY 80S LIKE U COULD EAT A CEASAR SALAD AND DRINK A HEKIKEN THEN EAT ONE OF THOSE

PIROUETTE
Yes, they come in tins, two bags per tin. Three different flavors to choose from.

pirouettes

brussels for me, then milano.

dear pps frms,
please eliminate all all all of the flavor variations, please.

oh i do love the chessmen. very much. but something about the combination of tastes on the geneva YUM

Top 10 Least Popular Pepperidge Farm Cookies
10. Asbestos Snaps
9. Broccoloons
8. Tainted Oyster Dainties
7. Gravel Sandys
6. Cinnamon Sharptons
5. Cholestrol Chubbies
4. Spackle Swirlies
3. Mallomar Khaddafys
2. Monkey Clumps
1. Johnny Bench's Nut Cups

chessmen + banana pudding + fresh whipped cream

chessmen make the best layered banana pudding.

bishop budino

chessmen make the best layered banana pudding.

-- lauren, Wednesday, 30 January 2008 16:38 (1 hour ago) Link

i smell a brooklyn potluck.

Mint Milano

i'll bring bordeaux battered oysters. xp to self.

whoa why is that banana pudding thing such a good idea??

did they only make chocolate chessman so that you could actually play chess with them, and eat the pieces that you take?

ian, i am totally up for that.

i have to admit that i make a variation of a paula deen recipe - the horror, the horror. at least it's not a sandra lee creation, which would probably involve adding jello pudding cups to a bag of crushed shortbread cookies and piping the resulting glop into banana peels.

i never knew there were so many variations of the milano. i voted for original. mini milano's sound amazing.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Mmm, Milanos. I voted for the double chocolate variety. I haven't had these in ages, maybe I'll go to the store...

Orange! Orange! Orange Milano

classic mint milano gets my vote

this poll reminds me that when i was a kid i used to dig through the bag of chessmen and eat all the rooks for some reason

bordeaux best, followed closely by chessman and gingerman. I mean I wouldn't say no to a milano or anything but for straight up awesomeness bordeaux is the one to beat, for realz

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

things i am happy to discover in the kitchen at 2 a.m.: 3 double-chocolate milanos

rofl double entendres

wow not worth wading through the fake pr0n for an alyssa milano joke nvm

great now you ruined my cookies.