Best Pixar Film (Updated Version)

Poll Closing Date: before WALL•E is released outside the USA. You DO know that other countries exist on earth, right?

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0910970/releaseinfo

sorry

should've counted to ten before I did that so I could keep myself from doing it in the first place

I probably should've waited for the UK release, at least. Oh well.

I totally went overboard in my reaction there, apologies :-(

It's just that I just read the following article's last two words and then I was reminded of that Malkin woman's existence by ILX again and then this thread and I was all, you know what, fuck america. (this seems to happen a lot, lately)

http://www.newsweek.com/id/143742/output/print

Stan OTM

WALL•E by just a hair.

havne't seen wall-e yet. ratatouille wins out of all the others though.

fuck america? FUCK AMERICA?!! But, but... we have mountains, and PRAIRIES and ALL KINDS OCEANSES... WHITE WITH FOAM!!!!

lol stanm u jealous of our awesome america what just had a birthday

http://www.ibewlocal934.org/EagleFlagFacesmall.jpg

WALL•E by just a hair.

-- Johnny Fever, Saturday, July 5, 2008 4:36 PM (1 hour ago) Bookmark Link

havne't seen wall-e yet. ratatouille wins out of all the others though.

-- akm, Saturday, July 5, 2008 4:39 PM (59 minutes ago) Bookmark Link

note: this is exactly why i made this poll.

ok, Aimless - I forgot about the foam! I take it all back. :-/

Ratatouille by a rat hair and I _have_ seen WALL-E.

Ratatouille by a rat hair and I _have_ seen WALL-E.

My vote as well.

torn btwn ratatouille and toy story 2 (which i haven't seen in years)

I've never seen any of these and I'm thinking of making WALL-E the first -- should I?

I would start with Toy Story, Finding Nemo and Monsters Inc and then follow up with Incredibles, Toy Story 2 and Ratatouille. THEN see WALL-E; it's close to the best of the lot and seeing a pixar on the big screen vastly improves the experience.

For worst, I'm torn between bugs life and cars and I think it's bugs life. It's been about five years since I saw it tho'.

Was just watching some Toy Story/Bugs Life clips and I was shocked at how remedial the animation/light sourcing/lip sync looks now. I remember having serious shock and awe at the time.

Guayaquil, I would see WALL-E first in theaters, and work backwards.

Toy Story 2 is the one for me, but the only one I don't want to win this poll is Finding Nemo.

I wouldn't have believe it til I saw it, but WALL-E wins. Truly amazing film.

I thought Ratatouille was seriously crap. Total Dud.

Having not seen Wally I vote for The Incredibles

nemo, but (possibly) only because i haven't seen ratatouille (and i have seen wall-e).

Incredibles, but only cos I've not seen WALL-E yet. Being English and all.

bumpity bump.

Loathe as I am to vote in this before seeing Wall E, it's Finding Nemo. Or The Incredibles.

Interesting how varied (and intense) the responses to this are.

i have not seen any of these movies.

Much as I love The Incredibles, the last two Pixar movies have made it merely the best of great Pixar, whereas Ratatoille and Wall-E are immortal.

Cars is the worst of the great Pixar, A Bug's Life is plain bad.

So between Ratatoille and Wall-E, I'd have to go with Wall-E, partly because I just saw it, but mostly because I was ready to bawl 5 minutes into Wall-E, and that feeling almost never left.

With you pretty much all the way there.

Bugs Life has the pillbugs = not bad.

Only one of these films has Edna Mode. Though who knows, in a few years' time perhaps Wall-E will have acquired as much of my lingering affection as the Incredibles has. For now, though…

Cars is the only one I couldn't even finish. Otherwise, Finding Nemo was the main disappointment. The rest are all varying shades of great with Wall-E, Monsters Inc, Rattatouille and Incredibles being my top 4.

What about a poll for Pixar shorts?

Why all the love for Ratatouille???

Cars is the worst of the great Pixar, A Bug's Life is plain bad.

This, I think, is backwards.

Otherwise, Finding Nemo was the main disappointment.

And this is simply madness!!

Not having seen Wall-E yet, I hesitated between The Incredibles and Monsters Inc. Ended up voting for Monsters Inc. even though I've watched The Incredibles a lot more.
Ratatouille love leaves me a bit baffled even though I enjoyed it. Really want to see both Toy Story again as it's been a long time (probably have not seen them since they were out in theatres). Only one I haven't seen is A Bug's Life. Worth watching or not? Worst is Cars out of all those I've seen.

this poll is too early, i haven't seen Wall-e yet and neither probly have a lot of other ilxors.

Finding Nemo it is then

Ratatoille is great because of the scene where Ego eats the ratatoille and wooshy-flashback to his childhood -- it was such an unexpected moment of emotional power that I got choked up, which may not amount to much but who cares, because the real reason is Janeane Garofalo as chic French chick.

Monsters Inc. I loved loved (it was the first Pixar that made me want to cry with love) but I watched it again ~6 months ago, and it was only very good.

Cars has its nice moments but basically paints Lassetter as a fuddy duddy.

NEMO

http://www.specialtylinens.com/nemotod.jpg

I haven't seen Wall-E, but I vote for the Incredibles. That was a great film and it should have been nominated for Best Picture.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

I would like to see Wall-E.

I've only seen the top 5 finishers, and like WALL-E the best. But I don't really love any of em.

You haven't seen Toy Story? : - o

I liked Finding Nemo but don't love anyone of them. They're well-written and visually incredibly creative, but there's something kinda soulless about them all.

but there's something kinda soulless about them all

I feel precisely the total opposite way.

This poll's results are very very wrong.

Monsters, Inc. 7

What the fucking fuck?????
SHIT film. Their very worst. Even worse than Bug's Life.

Has Wall-E been released yet? Has anyone even seen it?

WALL E was super, great etc but Toy Story (+2) owns this shit, come on.

ratatouille is 5th, not 2nd, best Pixar film. Which is still a good position to be in but ilxors have disappointed me.

i'm surprised monsters inc got so many votes. it's kind of the forgotten pixar movie to me.

what is with people who thought finding nemo was disappointing or even bad? I rewatched this yesterday for like the fourth time and it's almost perfect.