I reckon a site-wide ruling on this would be a good thing, really. Democratic vote, anyone? Opinions below, as taken from here.
ALDO: Firstly, can I just say something about spoilers? I don't think I've said anything actually spoilery on this thread - maybe the closest I came was when I suggested people might want to look out for Julian Bleach's appearance on Torchwood - because as far as I'm concerned once an actor (in this case John Barrowman) has appeared on a TV chat show and said "I'm in the last two episodes of the series" I can't see how that doesn't mean the news is out there for everyone. If there's as tight a control on information as is strongly implied then him saying that on the show was okayed by the production team for release. Ditto David Morrissey in an obviously posed photograph from APRIL upthread in the Daily Mail link - which is totally different from Sun 'exclusives' with 'leaked' photos - but see also how I'm not talking about which Big Finish audio his character is allegedly based on in case it gives anything away. Or which returning characters from 'Classic' Who are in S2 of the Sarah Jane Adventures until it's announced (I think it could well be the Series wind-down NEWS story). That's the stance I'd like to keep up tbh, giving little dribbles of hints without saying anything but talking freely about things that are approved by the production office to talk freely about.
JIMD: I don't like spoilers. They actually do spoil my enjoyment of tv shows. I just much prefer seeing things fresh, as far as possible. So I try to avoid them. You seem to think that, if something was mentioned in a 200 word article on page twelve of the Daily Mail four months ago, well then, EVERYBODY know that already, surely!? So it's fine to mention it to anyone else, who doesn't (for whatever reason), whether they want to or not.
Now sure, I could just avoid reading any threads about any telly ever. But another thing I really enjoy about tv is speculation! All that stuff we were doing here last week, where people were trying to guess how the regeneration would pan out, was LOADS of fun! I can't help thinking that, if you'd been around, you'd have sniffed at us all and said something like "pff, EVERYONE knows he's not going to regenerate because he's been seen dressed as the doctor filming the Christmas special in Cardiff" and then...well, you'd have killed that speculation, and stopped the fun.
Another way of looking at it: how to cause the least negative feeling in the world! If you tell me about something that's going to happen, that removes a bit of future enjoyment from my life. If you DON'T mention something which is going to happen, and which you know about, does that really remove much enjoyement from yours? Really? Surely it doesn't (unless you have some warped "haha, I get off on being more knowledgeable than other people about this, and letting them know that I am!" thing going on). So why is it such a big deal to ask you not to do it?
I just think "spoiler" means "anything which hasn't been screened yet".
Poll Results
| Option | Votes |
| JimD is right | 20 |
| Oh FFS! Shut UP! | 12 |
| aldo is right | 7 |
― JimD, Monday, 7 July 2008 19:30 (seventeen years ago)