Ben & Jerry's Poll

half baked

why you gotta be difficult

chunky monkey is my stalwart, but i'm voting chubby hubby

Not Pictured: Cherry Garcia

Good job

OPO: Ben & Jerry's

^Poll

chubby hubby, with coffee heath bar crunch coming in second. i had no idea there was a pumpkin cheesecake flavor though... this throws down the gauntlet.

ok the search fucking blows

that thread's the first one you come up with if you search for 'ben jerry's'

i searched posts, i guess.

http://www.benjerry.com/assets/images/features/americone_dream/americone_dream_pint.jpg

^^ damn this looks tight

Where's Oh My Apple Pie?

http://images.ciao.com/iuk/images/products/normal/177/product-6482177.gif

What, no Caramel Chew-Chew?

Of those options, either Mint Chocolate Cookie or Coffee Heath Bar Crunch but I am all about the sugartastic train.

Out of the ones I've tried - which is only about 10 - Dublin Mudslide. Makes me realise how shit Tesco's selection is.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Imagine Whirled Peace

LOL times infinity! that is so corny but funny

CREME BRULEE, which i only discovered because of the other thread.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

I absolutely love the Phish Food, those little chocolate fish are fantastic. The Stephen Colbert Americone Dream is a very close second though.

This is some straight up bullshit. None of these delicious flavours are actually for sale anywhere.

scoop shops yo

Not in my local scoop shop. It only has about 8 flavours. I want to try pumpkin cheesecake!

Sounds like Jerry just quit Ben and Jerry's in protest of Unilever ending its contractually obligated social mission.

WTF did Ben and Jerry expect would happen?

To be fair, the partnership with Unilever lasted 25 years.

To be fair, it’s amazing ice cream and I will continue to absorb any pint that comes within a block of my home.

Yeah, ice cream rules. My daughter worked at a premium ice cream place this past summer, and we got so much free ice cream. Once she bought Ben and Jerry's, and I was like, why!? Your free ice cream rules!!

yeah, i mean idk what he thought was going to happen.

when my family lived in VT, you could get free commercial size tubs of B&J's that weren't sellable for whatever reason (oh no, too many chocolate chips!) if you said it was for a charity event.

yeah my cousin used to give factory tours and he'd get two pints a week of those factory seconds

I need to change jobs

smores is the best one thats actually around in stores. there's a couple i've had that are better but i haven't seen them since before covid

FWIW, Ben was arrested in the U.S. Senate back in May for protesting all the horrendous shit going down in Gaza.

My aunt said "classical hippie - yuppie - transformation" - is that fair??

Whenever I hear of Ben & Jerry's, I think back to my first job, working at a grocery store where I overheard two old PA Dutch ladies in front of the freezer case:

Old PA Dutch Lady #1: "What's your favorite flavor of Ben & Jerry's?"
Old PA Dutch Lady #2: "Cherry Garsh-a."

hate to say it but the Jimmy Fallon ice cream is amazing, only downside is you have to look at his face

I avoided Cherry Garcia for a long time because cherry ice cream sounded gross and I can never get those years back.

i should obviously just not post in this thread but - sure i like ice cream but it isn't even a top 5 dessert for me tbh. best with something hot and no chunky stuff please.

gelato >>> ice cream

agreed

Coconut Almond Fudge Chip was robbed in this poll, it is clearly the best

Bring back festivus

hate to say it but the Jimmy Fallon ice cream is amazing, only downside is you have to look at his face

― frogbs, Wednesday, September 17, 2025 5:14 PM (three hours ago) bookmarkflaglink

took my kids to the B&J place some 5 years back and seeing that flavor and it almost feels like harbinger for today.

What does Fossil Fuel taste like? Not a very appetizing name

Something like cookies and cream?

Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Cookie Pieces, Fudge Dinosaurs & a Fudge Swirl

Honey Graham Latte is the best new flavor in a long, long time.

hmm interesting i don't usually get intrigued by the coffee ones enough to try them since i'm not a coffee drinker, but then again i tried the mudslide one once and ended up getting it a few more times it was so good

that sounds amazing, I'll keep a lookout for that one

hate to say it but the Jimmy Fallon ice cream is amazing, only downside is you have to look at his face

hate to say it but frogbs was right. I think the non-dairy version of it is even better

Uh that was to be a quote, but kinda more fun as a spoiler

iirc i didn't like that one, too many competing elements. half baked is already the perfect cookie dough variant

I get it, I feel that way about half the B&J flavors but for some reason love The Tonight Dough (except the name)

I avoided cherry garcia for the longest time because cherries in ice cream sounded gross and the name is cheesy but holy moly that’s some good stuff.