Book vs. Film: EMMA vs. CLUELESS

Message Bookmarked

Bookmark Removed

ILX has numerous Jane Austen threads. Clueless placed at #49 on the comedy films poll. Which do you prefer?

Poll Results

Option	Votes
Film	10
Book	5

― a fifth of misty beethoven (cryptosicko), Monday, 2 December 2013 05:01 (eleven years ago)

Previously on Book vs. Film:

Book vs. Film: DO ANDROIDS DREAM OF ELECTRIC SHEEP vs. BLADE RUNNER
Book vs. Film: HEART OF DARKNESS vs. APOCALYPSE NOW

― a fifth of misty beethoven (cryptosicko), Monday, 2 December 2013 05:06 (eleven years ago)

er, rather...

Book vs. Film: HEART OF DARKNESS vs. APOCALYPSE NOW

― a fifth of misty beethoven (cryptosicko), Monday, 2 December 2013 05:09 (eleven years ago)

easiest one yet

FILM

― zanarkand bozo (abanana), Monday, 2 December 2013 05:15 (eleven years ago)

book

― balls, Monday, 2 December 2013 05:33 (eleven years ago)

Read Emma. Watched Clueless. Enjoyed both. They never really seemed to me to have anything in common, but then neither did Homer's Odyssey and Joyce's Ulysses, in spite of all claims to the contrary.

― Aimless, Monday, 2 December 2013 05:40 (eleven years ago)

The fresher that Emma is in your mind when you watch Clueless (or vice versa, I suppose), the more striking some of the similarities are.

― a fifth of misty beethoven (cryptosicko), Monday, 2 December 2013 05:58 (eleven years ago)

Bump. No one wants to debate Austen vs. Silverstone?!

― a fifth of misty beethoven (cryptosicko), Wednesday, 4 December 2013 16:40 (eleven years ago)

That would boil down to "writing fiction" compared to "acting a role". A film is almost never reducable to the work of a single person and a novel almost invariably is. The debate would be more Austen vs. Silverstone & the writer(s), director, editor(s), actors, set designers, costume designers, makeup artists, music director, etc.

― Aimless, Wednesday, 4 December 2013 18:20 (eleven years ago)

yes, Austen vs. Silverstone is glib, and misrepresentative (it's really Austen vs. Heckerling), but I was just trying to generate interest (unsuccessfully, it appears).

― a fifth of misty beethoven (cryptosicko), Wednesday, 4 December 2013 18:57 (eleven years ago)

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

― System, Saturday, 7 December 2013 00:01 (eleven years ago)

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

― System, Sunday, 8 December 2013 00:01 (eleven years ago)

You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.