Do you like Wilco?

All of their albums seem too long to me, but I consider them the cream of the crop.

Aside from that: I suspect that a little editing on their last two albums wouldn't hurt, but then I just never get around to listening to disc 2 of their second album, so maybe I just don't know how good it really is.

I kinda liked AM when it came out but moreso now. BEING THERE is a bit too long and unfocused but there are some bright lights in there. I was a little weary when SUMMERTEETH came out with all the praise that it was getting. I figured it was just runoff from the MERMAID AVENUE hype, but then when I finally got the record (months after it came out and the hype had died some) I thought it was OK, then it started growning on me song by song. Now I think its great. Really fantastic. They're a really good band and depending on what their next album is, they could become a *classic* band.

Loved Uncle Tupelo, and Wilco just doesn't have the urgency they did live.

So critically overrated in the US that I might *almost* not get mad if Tom were to describe them as irrelevant rockist crap.

I'm glad that none of these people going on about 'rockism' mean it seriously.

But, hey, it's all in good spirit.

(and I say that as someone who's indifferent to Bragg musically, and left the Tolpuddle rally early last year because his performance was resembling a self-parody and I couldn't take it so close up, but I'm glad he's around.)

While I agree, remember that the whole thing was in the can before 9/11, and untouched thereafter. Which makes it all kinda spooky, methinks.

wl: That's why it works so well- it's a 9/11 album untainted by post 9/11 sentiments!

"Yankee Hotel Foxtrot" = r0x0r (tries to be Flaming Lips)

"Summer Teeth" = sux0r (tries to be Beach Boys)

Word.

"Yankee Hotel Foxtrot" = r0x0r

True dat.

(tries to be Flaming Lips)

Errr... don't hear it.

"Summer Teeth" = sux0r

Nah.

(tries to be Beach Boys)

Word.

Daniel your aesthetics are in severe need of regime change.

I know! I should paint my room pink...

performance of "Hate It Here" (with added horn section) on SNL tonite fucking RULED

looking forward to the second cut ("Impossible Germany" maybe?)

Agreed. I never liked that song before just now.

ok for 2nd song "Walken" was AWESOME choice although I wasn't as blown away by the performance. uh, performance-wise.

the "Hate it Here" was totally inspiring , best-band-in-the-uni type stuff. The "Walken" was sort of "eh". which is kinda doubly weird becuz "walken" is the Little Feat-aping track that lends itself to such band solidarity. kinda seemed like the boys did not really grab that one like they could've. oh well. they sounded great.

What's the provenance of that Nudie suit Tweedy wore?

Leave it to a Wilco thread to feature the word "provenance".

Out of curiosity, has anyone looked into whether or not their role in Volkswagen commercials resulted in the 'Nick Drake effect?' Sales-wise, not mortality-wise, mind.

like, after wilco's adds woksvagen accidentally overdosed on anti-freeze?
i'm 'pparently mis'standing something there, amn't i?

no

I thought it was odd that VW uses non-lp trax in the ads.

haven't paid attention since YHF which is a pleasant-bordering-on-interesting listen. I always had a soft spot for Being There cause when it came out my Faces and Big Star Third/Sister Lovers love was at its peak. I think I eventually came around to Summerteeth, too.

Summerteeth is the only Wilco cd I have, actually. I'm sorta lukewarmin' to it, mildly.

Up until the last year or so, the answer would have been "Meh" but last two albums are pretty great 90s indie rock.

Im not sure what to make of the new one yet. I like "normal american kids" a lot tho

I think they're probably splintering their fanbase a bit, so it's hard to know what to recommend, but I get taken in about halfway through the album during the run from happiness to locator especially.

not really caring any more, they have too many records. I'll always love Summerteeth

I think they have their own beer

Actually dug out my old Fuck (sorry, really wish they'd chosen a different name) albums, and yeah, there is a little bit of the same thing going on, though I like the recent Wilco stuff better.

Not a fan of early Wilco (anything earlier than Summerteeth) and a pick-and-choose relationship with the band for any album after Sky Blue Sky. Usually a couple of standout tracks on all of the latter-day albums. The new one and Star Wars were kind of dull to me, though.

(sorry, really wish they'd chosen a different name)

it's ok buddy

Expanded Reissues of AM & Being There Coming: http://www.rollingstone.com/music/premieres/wilco-details-reissues-of-first-two-lps-am-being-there-w508163

I was surprised by how much I loved the Alpha Mike odds and sods box. I'm in on these reissues, I adored "Being There" when it came out.

I loved AM and BT back in the day but fell off the bus after YHF. That comp of rarities looks good though, have to check that out.

Vouch for a ghost, summer teeth, yhf and especially sky blue sky, with the total classic "impossible Germany"

I guess up until YHF he had an effective foil in Bennett

I really dug "Germany" when I first heard it but it does zero for me now

I still don't know what the hell happened on Wilco (The Album), it's just so uninspired. It sounds to me how I imagine people who actively hate Wilco hear them all the time
Star Wars was pretty excellent though, which was something of a relief

i haven't loved anything since YHF (though I've liked some albums), but yeah Wilco (The Album) strikes me as by far their worst.
wonder if Farrar is on that last Uncle Tupelo track, or if it was just recorded pre-breakup?

Wilco (The Album) is like Beethoven compared to Wilco Schmilco. That is a bad record.

Schmilco sounds like what it is - the uninteresting outtakes from those sessions

W(TA) sounds like Tweedy actively persuing sub-Fleet Foxes/Feist blandness

I guess up until YHF he had an effective foilcollaborator/multi-instrumentalist/co-writer/producer in Bennett

W(TA) is easily their worst. The bookends on The Whole Love are worth the try.

Best record post-YHF to me is Star Wars, and I actually enjoy Schmilco.

I am curious if the extra stuff on these re-issues have already seen the light of day on the box set, which is, for the most part, pretty great. And I happen to love Schmilco. It's like Star Wars awkward little brother.

I couldn't get through 3 songs of that b sides comp

And Bull Black Nova is the only redeeming thing about W(TA).

"Alpha Mike Foxtrot" (a code for Adios M-F) is a bounty of riches. I love the band through YHF and it's got lots of live cuts from that period as well as fun alt takes and b-sides. The stuff from their later period was eye-opening for me. There's a track that sounds like a Fall outtake! And I've often found bands detritus is fascinating where they're being experimental or the song doesn't fit the album's vibe.

I saw them twice on the current tour and they were fantastic.

And Bull Black Nova is the only redeeming thing about W(TA)

"Deeper Down" is lovely

http://www.weepaperpeople.co.uk/2017/10/08/wilco/

https://wilco.kungfustore.com/new-items/jeff-tweedy-bobblehead-wil920.html

My fandom in their salad days just baffles me, When I hear the songs now they sound rote and forced and dumb

To the point that I assumed one of their songs as my handle here..
Shame

Never like them before Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, didn't like them after. Still one excellent record though.

Yes, Mermaid Ave. is excellent

You're too hard on yourself, "California Stars" is great.

They were one of my favorites for a while. I like everything until Sky Blue Sky, which was meh and everything after has been decent to meh. I gave up after Schmilco, which was decent.

I can drive around when I visit my hometown and "Misunderstood" still does something. Between Being There and A Ghost Is Born they really gelled into a great band and then they stiffened up. I'm glad Tweedy is healthy and out there doing his thing.

I seem to remember liking his first solo album well enough.

I made time and space to listen to “impossible deutschland” when it came out and man was that a waste of time

calstars no disrespect but you are usually the one bumping these threads to question your past fandom

they're america's Pearl Jam.

calstars no disrespect but you are usually the one bumping these threads to question your past fandom

I don’t think you can call what Jeff does “singing,” he’s more of a loud talker who uses inflection

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSo5ByudFAsD7zbr-pGRY96glfFB1miQ5UOfOmBnmYSf5XVHsvzPLABzXbqJnkst-gScNM&usqp=CAU

"And that's a problem because ... ?"

Yeah him too
Never bought into louis

I haven't been to a show in possibly a decade, and I haven't gone back to anything off their recent albums (2015's Star Wars is probably the last one I'd revisit), but I'm still a fan. I was glad to have been around them in Illinois and to follow them from Being There through Sky Blue Sky during that time. I thought they got a lot better for a while and then cooled off bit, but even the ones I had reservations about (Being There, A Ghost Is Born, Sky Blue Sky) grew on me - what I didn't about them seemed more insignificant as time went on. Mermaid Avenue is a whole other thing for me - I love Guthrie and they're definitely interpretative albums - but along with YHF they're my favorite Wilco albums and I love how their music seemed to evolve after doing each one.

I usually don’t care much about lyrics. But “I must be high” is especially cringe:

“You
Always wanted more time
To do
What you
Always wanted to do”

It’s simple — nothing wrong w that. Early Wilco reminds me of my college friends so I’ll always have a soft spot for them. I’m still able to enjoy Summerteeth and Being There quite a bit.

Same. <3 I was a big Uncle Tupelo/ Wilco/ Sun Volt fan at one point. Around 2000/2001 my bff and I dragged a friend to see them in RI. Said friend has very eclectic taste but favors punk/hardcore. etc. He's still furious about it and says it was the worst musical experience he ever had.

I listened to California Stars recently for the first time in maybe 15 years? Still a fantastic song.

just noticed they put out a new live album on streaming a month ago. it's just a compilation of soundboard recordings from the last decade or so, so it doesn't really live up to the idea of what a proper sequel to kicking television could be, but there's a bunch of songs recorded at the show i was at last year which are cool to hear again

the last two albums (& last year's ep) were their strongest work in a while, "bird without a tail / base of my skull" is already deservedly a live staple

How is that 2014 Capitol Theatre box set?

i didn't even know they put out a box set of those shows, it seems to just be the soundboard recordings they previously released as part of their roadcase series but they've put out so many of those (over 100 shows now) i have no idea which are the particularly worthwhile ones

The last time they really wowed me was Star Wars.