Led Zeppelin: Classic Or Dud?

Lock thread.

Rumor has it they're releasing the 2007 reunion show.

BORING

I'm finally reading through that Uncut (or whatever) special that came out a couple of months back and has been floating around my bedroom ever since. Must get back to listening to some of the lps after reading overviews of them in there. I don't think I got around to getting the last couple and that makes at least Presence sound like it should be interesting.

Do love the first US tour live sets the most though I think.

Apart from 'Achilles Last Stand' and 'Nobody's Fault But Mine', Presence does very little for me. I've given that record so many chances over the years...

Kinda like "Hots On For Nowhere". "Tea for One" is good, but I liked it better the first time when they called it "Since I've Been Loving You"

(at least Zep plagiarized themselves for once instead of somebody else)

They really should have taken a rest after Physical Graffiti, but I'm guessing that this wasn't an option due to the band being such a massive cash cow at the time. It was clear that Plant's heart wasn't really in Presence (and of course it wouldn't have been at that time, with him being wheelchair-bound and wanting to recuperate everything), and of course In Through The Out Door suffered from Jimmy Page being smacked up... maybe if they'd been forced to take things easy after Physical Graffiti, we may have had a Led Zeppelin for several more years.

Apart from 'Achilles Last Stand' and 'Nobody's Fault But Mine'

Ha, that's like half the album.

I never listen to "Presence," but I've got no problem with "In Through the Out Door."

Indeed, but looking over the Zeppelin albums prior to Presence there's very little I would 'throw away' (Maybe 'D'Yer Maker' from Houses Of The Holy which I've never liked and always found a bit corny), and then all of a sudden here's a Zeppelin album which I could easily do without half of; it's quite a drop in form!

It would be weird if they had made a post-Bonham album with a straighter drummer a la the Who post-Moon, although In Through the Out Door is almost what I'd imagine a Bonham-free Zep record to sound like anyway, at least in terms of the songs.

And yet his playing on the album is killer ...

Was Keney Jones a straight drummer? I kind of thought he had some of Moon's idiosyncracy as a drummer.

some of the wildness in playing during the Small Faces days at least.

He was pretty tamed (sober?) by the time he was in the Who.

I've always thought of Jones as more of a Bonham-type player myself. particularly on stuff like Afterglow.

but yeah he got tamer as he got older.

Jones stopped drinking on the Who's '82 tour, leaving Entwistle as the lone drinker in the band (Townshend had dried out, and Daltrey never partied on tour). His playing at that point, unfortunately, was free of much of what made him so distinctive in the Faces.

I will be all over this

That's awesome, but I sort of really don't want to see that in theater next to Zep fans.

Amusing that this one-off performance from the band in post-middle age, decades after its dissolution and minus its iconic, irreplaceable drummer, will surely be better than "The Song Remains the Same."

I'll pass.

Profound disappointment when word started to leak out that it was this reunion gig and not some awesome set from the 70s (deluxe editions with injection-molded abs mudshark)

(Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene, not a shark with a rippling six pack)

Amusing that this one-off performance from the band in post-middle age, decades after its dissolution and minus its iconic, irreplaceable drummer, will surely be better than "The Song Remains the Same."

U MAD. Would muuuuuch rather see a theatrical re-release of TSRTS.

So, I'm going with a friend to see Celebration Day in the theater tomorrow night. I'm intrigued enough that I'd like to see it with a better soundsystem than I have at home. The bootlegs sounded pretty good, after all.

Nobody else is going on the one night it'll be in theaters? I'm a little surprised.

I'm probably going to go - I've got a ton of work that I really ought to devote my evening to, but it's only one night and it's Zep. Just why did they pick tonight?!

(ps the Stones are doing the same thing tomorrow, which I really can't do either. Grrr.)

It does seem like a random date. I get that it's not a weekend night, but still it's odd.

considered doing this for my birthday but had better options

happy birthday Shakey Mo!

thx

Woo! Front row all to myself! I never get why nobody ever sits here, especially for something like this. Only thing it's bad for imo is subtitles.

Have fun! I'm not seeing it till 9 tonight.

It's well worth it. It's a bit weird at first, there's no dicking around and it's straight into these old dudes hammering it out onstage. But you get used to it. The epics worked best - Time Of Dying is great, No Quarter even better. Kashmir is spectacular.

Mostly I was thinking just how good Jones is - major advantage of seeing this in the cinema and getting all that lovely bass. Jason is having such a great time. Page is such an old woman. Plant, well he's really figured out how to live. It's his band; it's always been his band.

Making the audience laugh: Jimmy gurning at the start of Since I've Been Loving You. His teeth are too white, I think is what it is.

Making me laugh: whoever was holding up a 'Carouselambra' sign. I'd've loved it if they'd dropped everything to spontaneously pump that out, but 'twas not to be.

Making me laugh: whoever was holding up a 'Carouselambra' sign. I'd've loved it if they'd dropped everything to spontaneously pump that out, but 'twas not to be.

so awesome

I'm going to look out for that sign.

should add 00s Jimmy Page to list of men/old lesbians

http://disasteronheels.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/quaker.gif

jpj looked pretty good

Just back from Chicago screening. So much fun, very good editing I thought. I liked that there were no frills -- just the concert. Really, at two hours there's not room for much else. "Nobody's Fault But Mine" and "For Your Life" were my faves.

I was trying to make out that sign, but missed that it was "Carouselambra". The only unrepresented album!

The bass sound was a little rough for me, but I blame that on the theater, not the production. The subwoofers were probably just cranked up for all those rilly cool explosions that normally screen.

also hard to make out what was said a couple times. I have no idea what the hell Jimmy said at the end there. and after one song near thend it sounded like Plant said "how did you like that, Dave?" (or wait, was it "Paul"? well either way, who would they be)

This was so much fun. Totally, utterly, worth seeing. Jimmy got all sloppy and slow as the show went on, John Paul Jones was stunningly good, Jason looked like he was going to cry over and over again, and Robert adapted to the change in his vocal range by selling the lyrics better instead of using the high notes as a form of emoting.

The early run of "In My Time Of Dying", "For Your Life" and "Trampled Under Foot" was definitely the highpoint for me. Though Jason killed on "Misty Mountain Hop".

Totally agree on all points re: individual performances. Bonham was kicking ass. super touching moment when Plant gives him the shout-out after I think "Nobodys Fault" and the crowd just goes nuts, Jason rises to acknowledge them, pulls up a sleeve revealing the tattoo of his dad's run and looks up to the rafters

There were two or three moments of mid-song applause in my theater, the most enthusiastic after Plant belts the "OOOOOH"s mid-Kashmir. He really did nail that. But I also think it kinda took something out of his voice for the remaining few songs.

Page seemed like he was having trouble getting the theremin to work. and the turnaround from guitar solo to main riff in "Dazed" was all kindsa messed up. (tho he did get applause in the theater after the bow section.)(but you knew that was coming)

I had no intention of buying this next month but I'm seriously reconsidering after the theater experience. Might not get the video but likely will get the cd. It's quite an end cap to their hallowed run.

I had assumed that this would be playing late nights at least for a few weeks. Is tonight really the only chance I have to see this on the big screen? And I have to go to ALBANY?

I thought it was only playing yesterday worldwide (it's "Celebration Day", not weeks, after all), so jump at the chance to see it today even if it's in Albany.

There appear to be a few showings in the UK on Sunday.

The Stones thing tonight, though, is a one-off simulject.

Ugh can't do it.

Saw this last night and all its wonder of digital satellite transmission - sound sucked and the show had to be restarted twice. I may have gotten a free movie ticket out of it, but dang the theater needs a faster internet pipe or something like this shouldn't be shown. Even had a Windows OS screen and a stopped video file control panel up for a while. Lotsa pissed off Zeppelin fans until sound was turned up correctly.

Went into this with low expectations after hearing a few of the boots from dimeadozen.org. But man I changed my mind after the 'Black Dog' 'In My Time of Dying' 'For Your Life' 'Trampled Under Foot' run of songs. Double yes to everyone above - JPJ performance was sublime, Pagey is great up until 'Dazed and Confused' onwards (damn his guitar tone just rules so hard), Plant is an old woman, and Jason is just as good as his dad. I'll have to get this in some format just for the 'For Your Life' performance - such a highlight.

I don't particularly care about Led Zeppelin but went last night to the Celebration Day screening because my boyfriend is a crazy diehard nerd fan. Saw this at the worst possible theater in Philadelphia (of course), but I thought it was OK. There were some glitches in the transmission (sounds like it was common at many screenings) and the sound originally was fairly low. But once they cranked it up, it felt more cohesive. I didn't mind much of the editing, but a lot of the effects and aesthetic choices were pretty corny.

Got this on Blu Ray tonite. Fantastic! Though the tinny synth on "Kashmir" made me wish they'd dug up the old Mellotron. Page is particulay awesome in this. Such a different energy when these guys play the songs as opposed to when Plant & Page did them with other musicians.