Talking Heads- Classic or Dud?

if you say so

They're no GENESIS...

so wrong Turrican, most of the time you are OTM. not even close on this one.

I deeply love Remain in Light but not too jazzed about anything else.

i like todd edwards' remix of "burning down the house"!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9M_BpfEOd9U

incredibly overrated but not dud. i love so many of his songs but i find david byrne to be really insufferable

ha, let me just say - i love the talking heads. but for so many people i know, they're foundational. Remain in Light is the only record I like front to back.

oh yeah, I went to a screening of Stop Making Sense last month and the movie was missing most of the soundtrack. bass, vocals, drums, guitar. nothing else. they'd cut to the backup singers, keyboard players - nothing. we left once tina weymouth started singing genius of love, it was like watching a st. sanders shreds video. i was pissed at the time but now it's just funny. p sure i posted this already on ilx

later talking heads is good too, fools.

wtf flappy explain...

when we left I asked the employees what happened (obviously wasn't their fault) - apparently it was an issue with the copy they got from the distributor. I'm not exactly sure how DCP works, but it wasn't just the movie, the theater's "Don't talk" ad that played when the lights went down had the same sound issues - muffled & missing layers. It was bizarre & disappointing but what are you gonna do. they gave us passes for a free movie & I used them to see It last night.

Super classic c'mon

flappy bird - might have been a stereo issue? think they'd got their plugs in the wrong way round and the two channels were phase-cancelling

Yep almost definitely. I have a pair of earphones that do the same thing as flappy described, if I plug them in the wrong way

I just heard the live LP The Name of This Band is Talking Heads for the first time ever. Very different feel to my ears than their records, sloppy and immediate.

I would have thought phase cancellation would occur more from faulty wiring than having any plugs the wrong way around, but it does seem like that's what's happened.

In stereo, if left is plugged into right and vice versa, all this does is reverse the stereo field, for phase cancellation to occur both stereo channels need to be played through the same channel (in mono) with one of the channels inverted.

flappy bird - might have been a stereo issue? think they'd got their plugs in the wrong way round and the two channels were phase-cancelling

― Shat Parp (dog latin), Tuesday, September 12, 2017 10:55 AM (one hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Yep almost definitely. I have a pair of earphones that do the same thing as flappy described, if I plug them in the wrong way

― Vinnie, Tuesday, September 12, 2017 11:25 AM (one hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

hahaha awesome, i love that an 800 capacity theater had this problem

I'd say either a plug wasn't inserted fully (sometimes if a headphone jack plug isn't inserted properly it has this exact effect) or it's some other wiring problem. But yeah, incredible that a cinema - particularly one showing a concert film - had this problem.

I just heard the live LP The Name of This Band is Talking Heads for the first time ever. Very different feel to my ears than their records, sloppy and immediate.

This, along with "Stop Making Sense", is my go-to Talking Heads. I rarely play the studio albums, in fact. Not too many bands work improves that dramatically on their live albums.

Likewise, with the exception of Remain In Light, which is impossible to improve upon

Fear of Music is their best album

I'm not the biggest fan of "Remain In Light" either tbh.

"Fear Of Music" is godlike.

FOM is v good but yall are high as fuck if you think it's better than RIL

otm

i've been called worse things, i'll accept that

hey, opinions formed while high as fuck are opinions too, you know

especially opinions about fear of music and remain in light

Would not be good listening if you're paranoid-when-high.

Eazy OTM, "Drugs" is a bad trip

Lost my shape!
Trying to act casual!

they only have one genuinely bad album and that album is True Stories.

and it's puzzlin' evidence either way

so wrong Turrican, most of the time you are OTM. not even close on this one.

― Bee OK, Saturday, 9 September 2017 01:11 (three days ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I am profoundly disturbed by this post.

Good!

But yeah, I have tried a lot with this band - particularly since their so-called "peak" years (1977-1980) fall within one of my favourite periods of time for music ever. There is the occasional song I like here and there, but I find a lot of their material a little on the tedious side. I'm often left with the impression that they're a white funk band for people who perhaps consider themselves a little too artsy and deep to listen to the real deal, with some superficial "African" elements sprinkled on top and a thoroughly annoying vocalist bulldozing his way through it all, and I can tolerate seal-bark Andy Partridge just fine. Perhaps this description is a little harsh, but that's the impression that I get. The post-Remain in Light particularly comes across to me as quite bland.

It is, of course, undetstandable why there are fans of Remain in Light that haven't taken to their other albums - it sticks out like a sore thumb in their discography.

*understandable

their entire discography is sore thumbs

I'm often left with the impression that they're a white funk band for people who perhaps consider themselves a little too artsy and deep to listen to the real deal

Yeah, there's so many of these types around isn't there?

I think you can chart a pretty clear progression - you can see what ideas they're playing with and where they're going with them - from the beginning to the end, but none of their albums really sound like each other. Each one is in many ways a departure from the one before it.

a white funk band for people who perhaps consider themselves a little too artsy and deep to listen to the real deal

ad hominem bullshit

What century is it again?

Remove Bookmark from this Thread

Do I wish I got more out of this stuff than I do? You bet I do. Particularly since folks like Shakey and McBoing-Boing like 'em.

truly insane argument by Turrican, especially considering Tina Weymouth is in the band - one of the funkiest bass players ever.

I don't think of TH in terms of funk tbh. I don't think they are ever really "funky" in the conventional 70s-funk-by-black-artists sense. They borrow (liberally) elements from funk but I don't think they ever really get there, or even intended to get there. I think of them more like CAN - interested in building a musical vocabulary that deliberately excises certain things (some of which they were explicit about cf. Byrne's comments about "the blues", major key melodies, etc.) in favor of trying to incorporate genres and instrumentation and approaches that were not normally the province of white America (tropicalia, afrobeat, Brian Eno lol). Somewhere around the end of Speaking in Tongues-era Byrne very clearly *does* turn back towards America and then there's brief period of warped Americana/True Stories/Little Creatures which pulls in these other things like country and zydeco while mashing them together with their previous interests. And from then on Byrne is just in full polyglot cut-up pastiche mode through Naked and into his solo career.

these goddam byrnebros

superficial "African" elements

feel like this is a deliberate misreading as well, since it's not like their tactic was to just threw a ngoni solo on top of standard American pop song. Esp w/Remain in Light they are clearly borrowing compositional/structural ideas - building songs around circular multi-part vocal melodies, or long droning vamps that just alternate around a single tonal center or two-note riff.

I don't think of TH in terms of funk tbh. I don't think they are ever really "funky" in the conventional 70s-funk-by-black-artists sense. They borrow (liberally) elements from funk but I don't think they ever really get there, or even intended to get there. I think of them more like CAN

Kind of agree with this, they were definitely funky, but on their own terms - like Can - and not in some lame 'white funk band' way that Turrican seems to imagine they were.

yeah there is an immense gulf in approach between, say, the Average White Band and Talking Heads

there's this great japanese record called "fine time, a tribute to new wave" where a guy named yasuyuki okamura does "burning down the house". what's great about is not just the performance itself, but the fact that okamura is clearly singing it phonetically. the lyrics sound even better when they're sung by someone to whom they're literally, not just figuratively, meaningless. better than byrne!

i searched to see if it was on youtube, but i only found a version of talking heads' version apparently transcoded from a 32k realaudio file. it has 306 views.

xxpost:

Yes, I didn't expect that description to go down well, but unfortunately - because, like I say, I wish I got more out of their music than I do - it's exactly what I hear.

I don't see Can as a funk band at all.