IT'S BETTER THAN DRINKIN' ALONE: The Official ILM Track-by-Track BILLY JOEL Listening Thread

Catching up:

omg I had totally forgotten about this song until now. it must have had a lot of radio play in Australia bcz i know all the words & i am sure i haven’t heard it since then.

anyway i like it - more for the sound & movement of the music, and the cadence of the lyrics than the lyrical content itself. the keyboard is like a sped-up “On Broadway” somehow & i dig it

Baby Grand: how can you not love a Ray & Billy duet. Lovely stuff <3
but also pplains otm, i admit my inner alarm bell went off when i first heard Billy “doing” Ray in the opening lines like DUDE WTF ARE U DOING


Big Man on Mulberry St: omg this album is flashback city for me holy crap. i remember that Moonlightimg episode!!! As soons as i heard the song i remrmbered Bruce dancing. so obv i love it because young dancing Bruce is <3 <3.

*Modern Woman should be at the top there oops

The verses on this remind me of Joe Jackson a bit

yeah i can see that

well, Joe Jackson was doing this shit himself around the same time.

yes that's why I posted that

"Modern Woman" - not as bad as I expected, based on the comments here. Bit dated, but the melody is catchy

"Big Man on Mulberry Street" - "whatever he's doing with his voice here has got to stop." yeah exactly, he stays in the weakest part of his voice for the whole song. music is ok if a bit aimless

mulberry street - title good, song kinda terrible

"i'll leave a big tip with every receipt" may be the worst attempt at a rhyme in billy's oeuvre

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=34s9gkkMzZg

Temptation is, according to Billy, a ballad about fatherly life, and all the things that take you away from watching your child sleep, etc.

uh i am very surprised at how much i love "mulberry street"

i'd like to hear "temptation" recorded by southside johnny and the asbury jukes in 1977 with steven van zandt producing. and then maybe covered 10 years later by eddie money and ronnie spector. there's a decent song hidden under here but billy seems to have no idea what do with it.

it's just so fun! the melody he sings during the shift into jazz is one of my favorite things he's ever composed xp

whoa i love "temptation" too! i mean the chorus feels a little overextended but i'm cool with it! keep having good songs, billy joel's the bridge!

These last couple kinda go past me... I like the arrangement of "Mulberry Street" but there's not enough of a song/hook there. The slightly raspy falsetto keeps making me think of some TMBG song, maybe the live throwaway "Escape From The Planet Of The Apes"?

"Temptation" kind of the same deal, it's pretty and stately and all but also feels ponderous and long because there's just not as much melody or craft as something like "Honesty." Sounds like he's going for a Bryan Adams mega-ballad maybe?

Can't wait to read what you think of today's!

"Temptation" just goes on and on. Between this, "Mulberry Street", and "Modern Woman", he really expanded his range of pastiches to styles that don't suit him, on this album

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=niIWtw-70Lo

Code of Silence, the second-to-last track, is another duet with a "We Are the World" veteran: the legendary Cyndi Lauper, who also assisted with writing the song. You must watch the corresponding segment to the "Building the Bridge" featurette, online here at 12:34, in which Billy's writer's block is depicted in animated cartoon form. Inexplicably, there is no cartoon Cyndi - was she in rights negotiations for an animated series or something??

In return, Joel showed up doing backing vocals on Lauper's "Maybe He'll Know," which taps back into that An Innocent Man vibe a little bit. It was released as a single in the Netherlands only, and did not chart.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQY-ISwmqpU

Inexplicably, there is no cartoon Cyndi

I would totes dig an MC Skat Cat-style duet with cartoon Cyndi.

Anyway it's not a hook-filled song and I can see why it isn't a perennial fave. Me, I like the dated drum sound (almost "Eminence Front"-ish). Harmonica not unwelcome. But overall, meh.

This is in the tradition of a huge 1986 hit called "Live to Tell," in which Madonna also refuses to explain the nature of the secret.

I listened to this track a lot in July when I created a BJ best-of list.

last two don't do a lot for me

I like the song but the harmonica seems quite out of place

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLsXrgtalbA

Getting Closer: album closer, with Steve Winwood guesting as organ player. I'm under a deadline so can't look up anything else on this one, but as we leave The Bridge, let us also bid farewell to Phil Ramone, Russell Javors, Doug Stegmeyer, and Mark Rivera (the hitherto unmentioend saxophonist who replaced Richie Cannata a while back). Next studio album is a whole new ballgame, with Liberty Devitto the only holdover.

Maybe it's Stevie on the organ, but this could've been on one of those mid-80s Eric Clapton records. Would've fit right in inside the background of one of those pool hall scenes from The Color of Money.

The ascending melody of the chorus is just about the only touch of magic in this song, and it's a very Winwoody magic. Sounds a bit like Traffic's Empty Pages ("found someone who can comfort me...").

So it's either Joel trying in his labored way to write like Stevie. Or maybe Stevie just saying, "well, mate, how about we do something like (burbly burble burbly burble)?"

We're used to all the catchiest top-40 fodder being on side 1 by now, but these last several songs seem particularly hookless and workmanlike.

I couldn't find anything to say about the last two, and that continues with this one. Fair to say that if The Bridge isn't his worst album, it is certainly his dullest?

Dullest, maybe, but not worst, not when a couple of the early albums offer competition.

devitto's drums in "code of silence" carry that song for me

cyndi's harmonies are also wonderful. the verses are soooooo dull and perfunctory though

anyway i think this is weirdly prob my fav billy joel album after innocent man but i very much get finding it his dullest. there's a kind of perfect marriage between sound and composition for me here; even the boring songs aren't very boring to me bc the arrangements are generally doing something cool or extremely uncool!

devitto's snare lands in the strangest places in "code of silence," i love it

"getting closer" is def the most bored i've been on this album so far but the chorus is pretty solid

this is terrible, rock star bitching about royalties/accountants/managers is the worst rock genre

anyway yeah it's vaguely "bluesy" in the worst, most anonymous 1980s way

code of silence - i've listened to this about a dozen times over the past two days trying to come up with something to say about it and i'm at a complete loss. sounds like the cold war to me. (and have we talked about the album cover painting? that *looks* like the cold war to me, and it's just about screaming: "within lies a billy joel album you are not going to like.") thank god for cyndi.

getting closer - "i'm getting closer/getting closer" may be the worst chorus hook in the billy joel oeuvre, and no amount of billy pounding on the piano can hide that.

yeah I would like to like these last couple but am really struggling to. dad rock is fine but not if dad's feeling the well run dry. it's nine tracks long and four of them are five minutes long on three minutes (maybe) worth of material. hook shortage. the anonymous cover does set the tone for me but i'd probably feel differently if this thing closed with "baby grand" rather than the three weakest tracks right in a row.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/6/68/Billy_Joel_-_KOHUEPT.jpg

Концерт, aka Kohuept, Kontsert, and Concert, was Billy's second live album, released to mark the six Moscow and Leningrad dates of the the Bridge tour. Running seventy-two minutes over two discs, it may be of interest to fans interested to see how earlier hits were presented by this point in Billy's arena development. His attempts to verbalize the big ideas of "Allentown" and "Goodnight Saigon" for Soviet teenagers may also be worth a listen. We won't linger on it here, but I figured we should at least mark the two covers of 1960s classics that conclude the program: The Times They Are A-Changin' and Back in the USSR. The latter was released as a single, failing to chart in the US but scraping the top 40 in Australia. Its video suggests Billy was eager to give the Iron Curtain kids a real rock 'n' roll show.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jYGmXPbJRq4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=42Tah0DCubg

https://img.discogs.com/AkyUSXQ2wJdIvo9GfGbfMfVtDGU=/fit-in/600x579/filters:strip_icc():format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-6634543-1427762014-5226.jpeg.jpg

I love how Russia covers 11 time zones and there's still exactly one building that communicates "Russia."

Indeed, at that time, it meant the entire Soviet Union, which was even huger.

Phew! After those last few, I'm all

https://i.imgur.com/AqSOsn2.gif

so weird to see Billy doing the solo acoustic folk singer thing!

Back in the USSR def plays to his strengths and style

I like the slow, wait-for-the-translation messages to the audience on this album. They're hokey but feel sincere, like Billy's really hoping he can help the Russian youth realize that the corresponding American youth have been through similar struggles and have similar worries etc. I get, like, Christmas Day cease-fire vibes off of Goodnight Saigon in this context. Naive in a certain pop star way but it's a nice step beyond just saying "rock and roll is universal!" or whatever.

"Baby Grand" without Ray is a disaster though! Should have roped in some famed Soviet singing star to mix it up or not even tried.

In Soviet Russia, piano plays YOU.

"A Matter of Trust" sounding a lot beefier, closer my Addicted To Love concept. I later found a clip where Billy talks about going for a Robert Palmer sound on that but I wonder if that became clearer later after ATL actually came out. His clenched Palmer-style singing isn't as obvious as his other impressions since it's so close to the "gritty" voice he often uses but I do think it's there.

some famed Soviet singing star

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_3JckQQgTbxE/TTCd768YMTI/AAAAAAAACB0/guZnvHv4yWA/s1600/trololo-m-20100312.jpg

Looking at that hideous drop-shadow CD artwork reminds me that the vinyl album had no print on the cover, just that type design blind embossed into the solid red cover. Fitting for a double album with "Back in the USSR" and his most Beatles moment.

Billy u gotta bring yr A-game to rock the Kremlin

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrSKG3TS0uER

deep state tried to shut me down won't happen #billileaks

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFVZCsUYwd0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jb7kJ-j_dKA

Why Should I Worry? is Billy's big number as Dodger, a mongrel with "streetwise savoir faire" and a major character in Disney's Oliver and Company. It's his sole film credit as an actor (not playing himself). The song was written by the frequent team of Dan Hartman and Charlie Midnight, whose most recent big score was "Living In America." Hartman, a name I probably should have known already, went all the way back to writing "Free Ride" while in the Edgar Winter Group, so I like to imagine he and Billy understood each other a bit.

Released November 18, 1988, the film performed decently but not spectacularly, being beaten in a head-to-head opening-weekend match with The Land Before Time though ultimately outgrossing it. See further discussion in this thread.

https://img.discogs.com/oZREjV0-2Ie4i4OPiQBi-yV2cQk=/fit-in/600x598/filters:strip_icc():format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-2860634-1304400544.jpeg.jpg
https://img.discogs.com/Ys2_qC1ePB9DOzm5IhHK1CtFy9c=/fit-in/600x599/filters:strip_icc():format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-2860634-1304400558.jpeg.jpg

Sing us a song, you're the piano mutt...

he song was written by the frequent team of Dan Hartman and Charlie Midnight, whose most recent big score was "Living In America." Hartman, a name I probably should have known already, went all the way back to writing "Free Ride" while in the Edgar Winter Group, so I like to imagine he and Billy understood each other a bit.

and "I Can Dream About You"!