Don't Forget The AlcoPOLL (ooh baby! ooh baby!): ILM Artist Poll #109 - The Afghan Whigs - RESULTS

which one's the dud

"my time (has come)"

i love shawn smith and harold chichester and twilight is way too low

it's a pretty weird exploratory record, not quite like anything else he's done. there's parts of the sound dulli brought over to the later twilight singers records but a lot that's very distinctively on its own. i'm not huge on the other two singers either. there's a few great tracks and a lot of stuff that's just fine?

I couldn't get into Twilight at all, sorry.

"my time (has come)" is not good but not bad enough to actively bother me i guess

again, twilight is his sade record

it's possible i'm unduly influenced by the fact that it was my introduction to dulli. i listened to it on repeat while reading watchmen for the first time in hs. huge record for me

but like... every song is awesome and beautiful

twilight also interesting because it's technically the... follow-up to black love? not really of course, but it was recorded before 1965 iirc, fila brazillia percussion added later

yeah iirc dulli recorded a bunch of demos with smith & chichester while the whigs took a year off to deal with their legal issues with their label. the demos leaked out & after 1965 he revisited them and finished them off with fila brazillia?

i wish it was all like the best parts of it because the highs are so high to me, there's a lot there he could have explored further for sure

https://i.imgur.com/DXJd1JW.jpg
6. The Twilight Singers - Blackberry Belle
56 points, 7 voters, 1 #1 vote

TOO LOW

Had that at Number Four.

i think this record is at least a little bit better than congregation. incredible sustained atmosphere

yeah! way too low, that was my number 1 vote. The first 7 songs are just outstanding.

i'm listening to twilight and i really should've found room on my ballot for "clyde"

shot dead [time-delayed gun sound]
by you again

it's just really hot

yeah everyone who hasn't heard blackberry belle absolutely needs to check it out. there was definitely a bit of a divide between ballots where people were either into twilight singers stuff as well as everything else, or only really the pre-reunion whigs albums.

the shoegaze soul sound of it is incredible

and i don't think it falls off after the first 7 tracks or anything, "follow you down" is one of his prettiest ballads and i love "feathers" and "number nine"

"feathers" -> "fat city" -> "number nine" is a really strong ending, love it when lanegan's voice rises like a phantom through the floor of that last track

lanegan really does sound incredible on "number nine"

posting these two together because they're a tie on points at least

https://i.imgur.com/pgxtiNn.jpg
5. The Afghan Whigs - In Spades
58 points, 8 voters

album cover (NSFW)
4. The Afghan Whigs - Congregation
58 points, 9 voters

another thing i just remembered is when i got really into twilight i was also listening to joseph arthur's our shadows will remain a lot and i had no idea they knew each other

in retrospect, maybe i should've noticed something, as those records are doing similar things at certain points!

ugh in spades is so fuckin good, i'm psyched it made it this high

I really need to check out joseph arthur's stuff

i can't keep up with his material at all, but i will tell you our shadows will remain is still a really good record

oh i'm not familiar with him at all except that he's done some guest vocals on twilight singers stuff?

will have to check it out

congregation has some good stuff on it but the production's pretty bad & they don't sound quite fully formed yet, it seems kinda like a 'you had to be there' thing compared to the later material for me, as someone younger who only got into them in the last decade (my entry point was stumbling across their primavera reunion performance being streamed and going 'wow this is the best rock music ever')

"kiss the floor" almost made my tracks ballot for the drum part alone, but i get the most out of the singles on congregation

and an unsurprising huge jump in points

https://i.imgur.com/tnhWqHZ.jpg
3. The Afghan Whigs - 1965
130 points, 13 voters, 2 #1 votes

ugh the best album

those two no. 1 votes... i like their style

i don't think i'd really realised how great it is before this poll. the first side is their purest pop moment & then the second just goes wild

https://i.imgur.com/PTBzHSx.jpg
2. The Afghan Whigs - Gentlemen
178 points, 15 voters, 7 #1 votes

https://i.imgur.com/Af89hS0.jpg
1. The Afghan Whigs - Black Love
194 points, 16 voters, 6 #1 votes

the correct result!

yess

full results:

1. The Afghan Whigs - Black Love - 194 points, 16 votes, 6 #1 votes
2. The Afghan Whigs - Gentlemen - 178 points, 15 votes, 7 #1 votes
3. The Afghan Whigs - 1965 - 130 points, 13 votes, 2 #1 votes
4. The Afghan Whigs - Congregation - 58 points, 9 votes
5. The Afghan Whigs - In Spades - 58 points, 8 votes
6. The Twilight Singers - Blackberry Belle - 56 points, 7 votes, 1 #1 vote
7. The Twilight Singers - Twilight - 44 points, 6 votes
8. The Twilight Singers - Powder Burns - 32 points, 5 vote
9. The Afghan Whigs - Do to the Beast - 28 points, 6 votes
10. The Gutter Twins - Saturnalia - 18 points, 4 votes
11. The Afghan Whigs - Up In It - 16 points, 2 votes
12. The Twilight Singers - She Loves You - 12 points, 2 votes
13. The Afghan Whigs - Uptown Avondale - 10 points, 3 votes
14. Greg Dulli - Random Desire - 6 points, 3 votes
15. The Afghan Whigs - 66 Single - 6 points, 1 vote
16. The Twilight Singers - Dynamite Steps - 4 points, 1 vote
17. Greg Dulli - Amber Headlights - 2 points, 1 vote

back half of black love is just completely relentless

black love is really pretty much perfect

Results are pretty good, yes. My top six was your top six, if not exactly in order, but close.

this was my ballot:
Black Love
1965
Blackberry Belle
Gentlemen
In Spades
Do to the Beast
Random Desire

going to count down the tracks from 50 to 41 soon, i don't have images for those but will for the top 40

my albums ballot:

Black Love
1965
Twilight
Gentlemen
In Spades
Blackberry Belle
Do to the Beast

50. The Twilight Singers - I Wish I Was
56 points, 3 votes
from Powder Burns

50. The Afghan Whigs - If I Were Going
56 points, 3 votes
from Gentlemen

interesting start lol. "i wish i was" is gorgeous

yeah it's a great closer

"kiss the floor" almost made my tracks ballot for the drum part alone, but i get the most out of the singles on congregation

― mellon collie and the infinite bradness (BradNelson), Tuesday, June 15, 2021 8:13 AM (one hour ago) bookmarkflaglink

i voted for it, hope it makes it!

my albs ranked top to bottom:

Black Love
1965
Gentlemen
In Spades
Powder Burns
Do The Beast
twilight as played by the twilight singers

voted for i wish i was. dulli by way of blue nile.

that explosion about halfway through is stunning. i really like dullis vocals on it too