POX Eagles

I Can't Tell You Why (best Carole King knockoff evah)

Such a great song...

yeah, incredible song and production

Not really a fan, but I can stand these ten:

My Man
Best of My Love
Journey of the Sorcerer
Take It to the Limit
Hotel California
New Kid in Town
Life in the Fast Lane
Pretty Maids All in a Row
Try and Love Again
I Can't Tell You Why

I like four that you mention, and would add:

On the Border
The Disco Strangler
Those Shoes

Don Henley's a great singer I almost never want to hear sing.

Glenn and Don also recommend:
A Good Day In Hell - The Official ILM Track-By-Track EAGLES Listening Thread

Well, yeah

https://y.yarn.co/7d3610ec-5864-46e6-b5f0-2bb70c9c325e_thumb.jpg

Best Thread Ever

“one of these nights” has maybe my favorite don vocal performance

Yeah, it's not a bad Bee Gees pastiche and the opening sounds like it would make a great sample.

it’s more his smokey tone in verses than the chorus for me

I was actually surprised when I found out Don Henley was in the Eagles. Like I knew him as this '80s adult contemporary guy behind "Boys of Summer, "End of the Innocence," "Heart of the Matter," "All She Wants to Do Is Dance," etc. and it was weird to find out that he had this decade-long existence as a "country-rock" guy almost as old as Woodstock. But yeah, I like Henley as a vocalist - I'm much more partial to those '80s hits though.