Martha, My Dear: ILM's All-Time Video-Poll Results Thread

The Passion of Joan of Arc?

That wasn't questioning you, sorry, it was an answer to the previous. But I don't know if it's an intentional homage.

I was about to guess that one, but honestly the connection had never occurred to me before now

Googled the two together and found this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30ivsoYJ3qs

https://phildellio.tripod.com/video-11.jpg

11. “Sledgehammer,” Peter Gabriel (1986)
111 points/11 votes
Director: Stephen R. Johnson

iirc this topped vh1s all time poll in the early 2000s
happy to be corrected if wrong

Another one I never got. I was working in a record store at the time, and our assistant manager was a fanatical fan--played So or Invisible Touch or Mike & the Mechanics seemingly every time he was on cash (or would walk around the store air-drumming to them). Nice guy, but that didn't help.

The 11th song got 111 points from 11 voters.

11th video, I mean.

I should have voted but anything but Top 3 for Sledgehammer is a travesty

otm

a TRAIN goes through his EARS u guys

There's only two videos I'd even hear a CASE for being better than Sledgehammer and they're probably on their way

There's basically 8 videos left that I'm gonna see and be like "come on, you guys"

https://phildellio.tripod.com/video-10.jpg

10. “Come Into My World,” Kylie Minogue (2002)
113 points/8 votes
Director: Michel Gondry

come on, you guys

Oops--have to download the last 10 screenshots.

https://phildellio.tripod.com/video-10.jpg

10. “Come Into My World,” Kylie Minogue (2002)
113 points/8 votes
Director: Michel Gondry

i was expecting a lot of comments about “drop” lol

best music video ever

i didn’t vote for any stop motion animation videos, who can say why

Didn't know the video, didn't know the song. She got lots of votes for other videos, too--didn't know any of them. I'm a little behind here--she's "The Loco-motion" to me.

Sledgehammer was my #8 but two of the ones above it were pretty silly choices.

Sledgehammer video is cool, but this isn't the technical achievement awards or whatever.

(i.e., #11 placement is totally fine)

https://phildellio.tripod.com/video-09.jpg

9. “Once in a Lifetime,” Talking Heads (1981)
114 points/12 votes
Director: Toni Basil & David Byrne

Nice eyesore...image 09, not image 9.

11 seems reasonable for sledgehammer.

“drop” is definitely the video i am most ashamed about leaving off, would’ve been a top 3 contender for me if i didn’t skim over it on the noms sheet.

the pharcyde didn’t learn to rap their lines backwards just to wind up outside the top ten smh

If Reet Petite places *I* will be like "come on, you guys."

Anyway, this one's objectively great, but not much of a fan in general.

I didn't know Toni Basil co-directed it, though, that was interesting.

So far we've seen three MTV Video of the Year Award winners: "Money for Nothing" (1986), "Sledgehammer" (1987), and "Nothing Compares 2U" (1990).

I assume Van Halen's "Right Now" (1992) and Aerosmith's "Cryin'" (1994) are coming up.

xp I didn't either, although I know about her choreography career and everything.

If there's a moderator around, maybe you could remove those two posts with the ugly broken links...thanks in advance.

xxp Which videos won in '88, '91, & '93?

(xxxpost) Rest easy.

"Teen Spirit" came out late in the year, otherwise I'd assume that won in '91.

come on, you guys

Well what jumped out at me was that The Cars' "You Might Think" won in 1984 (the debut awards) over "Rockit" and "Thriller"

Well what jumped out at me was that The Cars' "You Might Think" won in 1984 (the debut awards) over "Rockit" and "Thriller"

― Josefa, Friday, March 18, 2022 10:56 AM (twenty-one seconds ago) bookmarkflaglink

.... D:

There is a time-tested strategy for trying to get the results you want...

I didn't want to get in too deep because this is a subject I'm really passionate about

Didn't vote in this but gratified to see "Don't Come Around Here No More" and "Rockit," the two videos that really made young-teen me sit up and realize this was a THING, ranked high. Should be higher of course.

Best Video of the Year win was Neil Young's "This Note's for You" in '89, which they only gave to him because they were criticized for banning the video.

Can't think off-hand what else was around, but god, what a terrible choice.

The Chris Isaak video, for one, plus lots of great hip-hop videos, I'm sure.

https://phildellio.tripod.com/video-06.jpg

6. “Let Forever Be,” Chemical Brothers (1999)
127 points/8 votes/two #1 votes
Director: Michel Gondry

xp "Wicked Game" was one of the 1991 nominees

come on, you guys

American MTV didn't even give the Kate Bush videos with movie stars in them much play.

Interesting. In my possibly distorted memory, I feel like she was constantly on Canadian TV when I was a kid, between MuchMusic and other video programmes like Video Hits? I was definitely v familiar with "Cloudbusting", also "Babooshka" and "Army Dreamers".

We need a Stephen R. Johnson DVD so everyone's brains don't get warped by "we put this on at a party and smoked weed" in 2004

Let Forever Be is incredible, the mixing and mirroring of video and practical effects is sublime - is it a technique that's ever been used anywhere else? My #3.