Post a controversial music opinion

I think To Ramona has potential - Sinead Lohan's version isn't bad.

When I play it, which I sometimes do, I cut out a lot of the more stilted backward phrasing and lose one or more verses.

Totally agree that His Bobness often lacks an inner editor, and the people surrounding him are not empowered to tell him when he's making a mistake.

does this version grab ya? It sorta has that California country sound

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPxNc34tUpI

Better.

lil Wayne’s best work was done when he was a minor

I don't think I agree but I could definitely see the rationale for that one.

you know, the block WAS hot

"dragon" (lou reed + metallica) = one of the best songs either has recorded

That is insanity

in a better world it would not be a controversial opinion

I'll agree that it features probably one of the best Kirk's solos.

I do love saying LULU is my favorite Metallica album to hardcore stans and hear them lose their minds.

better roots rock bands than The Band: ZZ Top, The Stoneman Family, Thin Lizzy, Lynyrd Skynyrd, Cowboy, Homer & Jethro, Little Feat, any episode of Hee Haw, Disney's Country Bear Jamboree.

I find all International Anthem releases other than Jamie Branch's to be tedious and not as groundbreaking as widely advertised. (Who remembers Thirsty Ears' Blue Series?)

it says "controversial," not "banworthy"

xp

One aspect of Lulu that I don't think people think about is that it was the first time in a while and the last time ever you got to hear Metallica play as an actual band with good production, not protooled within an inch of their lives

I find all International Anthem releases other than Jamie Branch's to be tedious and not as groundbreaking as widely advertised. (Who remembers Thirsty Ears' Blue Series?)

I’d 100% agree LULU is their best material in the past 25/30+ years.

Also more true for Metallica than for Lou Reed. There’s still gems in Raven and Ecstasy

I mean...if you don't like Metallica, that's fine? But to run around yakking about how great Metallica can be when they sound nothing like themselves is just weird.

I'm with Scott on the Band. They might have been OK had they made two albums and faded away, but they made, like, seven.

I like a lot of International Anthem's early releases — Irreversible Entanglements, Junius Paul, Damon Locks, Makaya McCraven — but their recent indie-crossover stuff has been fucking dire.

The Thirsty Ear Blue Series deserves a second look, though. A lot of it was great.

when they sound nothing like themselves

not correct in the least

I love Metallica! Master of Puppets is one of my fav albums ever

the riffs on lulu are metallica as fuck

minus the 15 minute ambient ebbing that concludes it "junior dad" reminds me a great deal of "hero of the day," etc.

Superunknown has more or less the same snare drum sound as St Anger but one is a classic while the other is St Anger.

I'm with Scott on the Band. They might have been OK had they made two albums and faded away, but they made, like, seven.

But none of those albums after their first two made much impact beyond a critical one, and they were too anonymous -- too interested in music -- to be as grossly ubiquitous as CSN. Basically, the public knows them for "The Weight," and probably Aretha's.

Stagefright is great though, and as much as I'm skeptical of remixes of old albums, Robbie's new version was really great

the first band album is basically hauntology

XXXp to unperson, forgot about the Junius Paul and Irreversible Entanglements releases, which I'll rep for. I've tried to get into Makaya McCraven and Damon Locks to no avail.

Here is my genuinely-held controversial music opinion: Sunn O)))? Those guys need a drummer!

The best thing about Master of Puppets is that it generated the utterly perfect spoonerism Pastor of Muppets. Never before or since has there been a better pair of phrases - one intended seriously and the other just plain silly, with a sly pop-culture reference.

For wordplay dorks like me it really was a sterfect porm.

"Hairway to Steven" is another pretty good one, imo

^

The ones I remember are Night in the Ruts and Cunning Stunts

jesus christ i JUST GOT night in the ruts right now lmao

this is like when it took me 10 years to get Buck Cherry

omg I never got Night in the Ruts before

LOL XP

wtf i'm so brain dead i swear

Here is my genuinely-held controversial music opinion: Sunn O)))? Those guys need a drummer!

― the phantom flim-flammer (Matt #2), Thursday, 10 August 2023 19:39 (one hour ago) link

Khanate sort of scratches this itch for me

xp idk Matt I've been aware of that record since circa 1979 and never got the joke either

it totally scans as literally a "night in the ruts" to me because it's the LP following legendary 70s excess

Yer Self is Steam took me years to realize

Here is my genuinely-held controversial music opinion: Sunn O)))? Those guys need a drummer!

They kinda did this once; the live album Sunn O))) Presents...Pentemple has NZ black metal dude Sin Nanna (of Striborg) on drums. It's...okay.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kfiVrJ7dTlQ

I actually never got the pun in "Porcupine Tree" until recently

I still don't?

It's not very good so that's why nobody notices it.

Oh, wait, I got it - not so much a "pun" but "pine tree".

Yer Self is Steam took me years to realize

― Elvis Telecom

wait what, plz clarify for the brain dead among us

"your self esteem", no?

The rear cover of “night in the ruts” does give a hint of the spoonerism

night in the ruts has shaken my entire worldview, my life has been a lie

I learned early because I was reading Steven Tyler's annotations in the liner notes for....something, where he was going album by album, and he got to Night in the Ruts and he said something like "reverse two letters and you'll learn what Aerosmith is really about"

I mean, Night in the Ruts is downright poetic compared to the ever so subtle title/cover art combo for Pump