carrie brownstein vs. corin tucker

Sophie's Choice, I'm abstaining.

I slightly prefer Carrie's playing to Corin's, but Corin's voice towers over Carrie's, and it pretty much defines S-K for me.

Also, Corin never did a horribly racist sketch on Portlandia.

it's never too late

what about janet?

waited for that

Write in for Janet.

I slightly prefer Carrie's playing to Corin's, but Corin's voice towers over Carrie's, and it pretty much defines S-K for me.

Also, Corin never did a horribly racist sketch on Portlandia.

― Montgomery Burns' Jazz (Tarfumes The Escape Goat), Wednesday, December 31, 2014 12:49 PM (4 hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Idk about the horribly racist sketch, but the first sentence is otm for me, especially if you extend "voice" to mean lyrical content, even if her politics can be slightly tongue-tied or different from mine.

(also, i've always found her super-cute, in a coy sort of way)

Carrie I've always found comparatively uncompelling in her reticence and maybe even masking through stuff like Portland - I find her persona to be a bit blank in the way I'd expect her comparatively charismatic scientologist comedy (?) partner to be - but i became more intrigued through the thoughtfulness of her blog, etc. writing (the whole phish thing helped) and increasing command in her other post-S-K coming-out/into-her-own activities (Wild Flag! Wild Flag!). it's not just an introverted thing with her, though - she still seems a bit uncommitted. maybe that's just Northwestern diplomacy?

feels weird to admit this as a long-time SK fan but i kinda prefer carrie's voice.

Like trying to decide which channel is best on the Velvet's "Murder Mystery."

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

Oh wow, Team Corin In Full Effect!