Best Christmas song to re-enter the Billboard US Hot 100 in 2019

Sleigh Ride for me. Love the ringaling harmonies

"Happy Holidays / The Holiday Season" aside--because I can't recall it offhand, even though I'm sure I've heard it at least ten times already in the last few weeks--I can honestly say that I won't/don't turn any of these off, but this totally comes down to a choice between Mariah, Wham or The Ronettes, for me. I expect the former to win, but I'll vote for it anyway.

The Christmas Song (Merry Christmas To You) - Nat King Cole

poll surprisingly difficult

Fuck, overlooked Nat.

Still ok with my choice tho

I don't actually dislike any of these!

yeah, tough poll

This particular Andy Williams cut surprised me too. Thought "It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year" was the go to Williams wobs song

They're both on there!

xp ha, only just noticed that's re-charted too and is in the poll, nm

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z2El5ttjM9I

lol

Different 90s comedy series, but every time I see Andy Williams mentioned, I just hear “packed...every night.”

i didn't think he was gonna do moon river, but then bam! second encore!

Every time my brother and I are in the car with my folks, one of us points at a random sign and yells "ANDY WILLIAMS??!!".

And my mother gets annoyed, thinking we are making fun of Andy, forgetting we have had this back and forth 35 times before.

In Miami we are inundated by José Feliciano like acid rain.

Lol...his song would probably be my least favorite on the list. Not cos of the song as much as...his voice is nauseating to me.

I know he's a technically gifted singer but that voice don't mix with me

helluva guitarist tho

deano

"Happy Holidays / The Holiday Season" aside--because I can't recall it offhand

It's the holiday season
So whoop-de-do and hickory dock
And don't forget to hang up your sock
'Cause just exactly at twelve o'clock
He'll be coming down the chimney, down

I hate this song and I've been hearing it more and more in the last few years.

Relevant ILP-M content:

Kids say the darndest things

xpost

yeah, that one sucks.

Has "Happy Holidays" always been part one of a medley like that? 'Cause I'm feeling like I haven't ever heard that second part.

I like all the songs in this poll, but "Feliz Navidad" has worn out its welcome. I think I like Brenda Lee the best.

Andy Williams is just owning the holiday on those two tracks. Gonna go with "It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year."

Jingle Bell Rock, then Sleigh Ride.

Tired: Feliz Navidad
Wired: Feliciano's National Anthem
https://www.wbur.org/onlyagame/2019/04/12/jose-feliciano-susan-tigers-world-series

Wham.

Nat King Cole over almost anything not by Slade or Vince Guaraldi.

every time I see Andy Williams mentioned, I just hear “packed...every night.”

Larry Sanders!

https://thumbs.gfycat.com/BeautifulShrillBoto-size_restricted.gif

“Do They Know It’s Christmas” is better than any of these.

If you want to se what Last Christmas looks like in 4K now's your chance; if you flip the wee cog bottom right it actually does play in computer-frazzling 2160k. I wish Madonna would do the same for hers.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwNV7TAWN3M

Whamageddon is the worst social media phenomenon.

Besides the song is great

there'll be more, you know, before the chart year (or actual year) run out

it's between "last christmas" and "the christmas song" for me

in 2018's christmas season, 24 christmas songs re-entered the hot 100. of those, 22 had to reach the top 50 to even be eligible to appear, so for one week literally over 40% of the upper half of the singles chart consisted of old christmas tunes. this included all of the ones in this poll (except "happy holidays") plus

bing crosby "white christmas"
chuck berry "run rudolph run"
darlene love "christmas (baby please come home)"
elvis presley "blue christmas"
frank sinatra "jingle bells"
john & yoko/the plastic ono band with the harlem community choir "happy xmas (war is over)"
kelly clarkson "underneat the tree"
paul mccartney "wonderful christmastime"
perry como "(there's no place like) home for the holidays"
perry como & the fontane sisters "it's beginning to look a lot like christmas"

all of these, or others, could also re-enter this year.

it should be noted that an outsize determinant of which old chestnuts make their chart (re)appearance is amazon, specifically those in the company who formulate its christmas playlists. a massive number of people, including those who otherwise seldom feel compelled to stream music, apparently ask their alexa surveillance bots to "play christmas music!"

i'm actually a little salty that no version of "this christmas" has re-entered yet. fingers crossed i guess

Feliz Navidad. it's not played all that much in the UK and I always enjoy it when it comes on

I hate Andy Williams/Most Wonderful Time of the Year so much

I think Nat's my favorite of the list

kinda bummed that Frank's Christmas Waltz didn't get a bump, I'd vote for that

I would have an easier time if we were supposed to vote for the one we hate the most, because that's obviously Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer.

Mariah’s Christmas tune finally hits #1:

https://pitchfork.com/news/mariah-carey-all-i-want-for-christmas-is-you-reaches-no-125-years-after-it-came-out/

125 years

and Brenda Lee "coming on strong" at #3

Correct me if I'm wrong but if Brenda Lee goes to #1 she would be simultaneously one of the youngest solo artists to do that (she was 13 when she recorded that song) and the oldest solo artist ever to score a #1 hit in terms of current age (75).

(*Stevie Wonder recorded "Fingertips" at age 12).

nat king cole in the streets jose feliciano in the sheets

i wonder if they're going to stop allowing old songs to re-enter at all (the way they used to before whitney houston died and they decided to let her songs re-enter) given the enormous growth of christmas-related streaming in recent years. like, "all i want for christmas is you" will probably be at or near #1 every year for the foreseeable future now, with "rockin' around the christmas tree" reliably close behind

like, it is unquestionably accurate that these songs are big at this time of year, but historically the hot 100 has been meant to rank the most popular current hits, not songs that emerge from hibernation for a few weeks every single year. seasonal/holiday titles were almost entirely forbidden from charting on the hot 100 for many years of its history

Yesterday my kids sang Feliz Navidad to me so I'm picking that one

This is a relatively new phenomenon, isn't it, the inundation of old xmas tunes in the hot 100? I mean, I know it's happened a number of times before but usually just one or two at a time.

yeah. the phenom of adult contemporary stations flipping to all-christmas is a big part of it, naturally, but that's been well established for many years now (that tradition started taking off post-9/11)

the bigger part of the picture is the meteoric growth in streaming stats for christmas titles: last year, the year that christmas hits really exploded onto the hot 100, 31 of the 50 positions on the streaming songs chart were occupied by christmas tunes.

where's all the streaming coming from? right now, if you look at the spotify, apple music, or youtube charts, you'll see a few christmas tunes, but not quite near the #1 slots yet, as they are on billboard's overall streaming chart. the answer is smart speakers, particularly amazon's. two of the songs that reached the hot 100 last holiday season -- katy perry's "cozy little christmas" and lauren daigle's "the christmas song" -- were amazon exclusives and still managed to reach nos. 53 and 55 respectively on the hot 100. (both placed on the streaming songs chart but were missing from radio songs and digital song sales, the other two main components to the hot 100.) billboard wrote a little about the massive growth in use of amazon devices to stream over the holidays last year.

(apparently a lot of billboard's articles are paywalled now? yikes. guess i'll just read through the html source lol)

Okay, the time frame of this phenomenon makes sense because I'm pretty familiar with the general trend of charting singles through the end of the 20th Century and then not so much from that point on. There were a few like 'The Chipmunk Song' that popped up a number of times over the years but by and large the xmas singles that charted back in the day were recent releases.

FELIZ NAVIDAD duh
it is the best

2017 and earlier i used to like "Wonderful Christmastime" "Last Christmas" and "All I Want For Christmas is You" and now 2019 i hate them thanks to countless cover versions heard in malls and department stores etc

Chris Molanphy's latest piece is urgent and key here

https://slate.com/culture/2019/12/mariah-carey-christmas-number-1-billboard-hot-100.html

the smart speakers thing makes a lot of sense -- as a kid growing up, throughout the month of December we'd always have Christmas music playing throughout the house (Mantovani, the Nutcracker soundtrack, Mannheim Steamroller, Barbra Streisand, a few others I don't remember), and that was just what December was; then my sister and I got old enough that my parents stopped, I asked why, and was shown how much of a royal pain in the ass it was to get all of the speakers set up to play all of the CDs and fix the inevitable issues

So it turns out “The Holiday Season” is pretty cute. I have put it on my Christmas mix for 2019, which I will link to tomorrow probably.

surprised myself by voting for burl (tho there are many contenders). bing would take it if he'd made the cut yet, and the drifters' cover would tower over all options imo. but agreed that actually overall this is a pretty good lineup of songs - the public, given the chance, would clearly curate a better and less maddening lineup than most mall and radio playlists or cassette/CD christmas comps. all killer, no filler.

the molanphy article is great, certainly one of the best i've read from him for a while. i was surprised he didn't mention smart speakers kicking christmas streaming into the stratosphere in the past couple of years specifically, but otherwise it's a very thorough and insightful rundown

This blows my mind:

in the entire history of the Hot 100, there’s been only one prior Christmas song at No. 1—and it’s by three imaginary singing rodents. That prior No. 1 Christmas single was “The Chipmunk Song (Christmas Don’t Be Late)”

This various artists compilation was a showcase for the stable of acts on Spector’s Philles Records label, from the Ronettes to the Crystals, and for Spector’s legendary Wall of Sound production style. The album was basically a flop,

The fact that it was released the day Kennedy was assassinated likely contributed to its floppiness.

here's a very informative billboard feature on the growth of the holiday music biz from the bing crosby days up thru today's nu streaming-era resurgence:

Although it’s hard to get exact figures for the holiday music business, the most popular recordings in the genre generate far more revenue than they did a decade ago. “Last Christmas” by Wham! sold 81,000 tracks in the United States in 2008 -- and sold and streamed the equivalent of 706,000 last year, according to Nielsen Music. Older recordings are getting more popular, too: Andy Williams’ “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year,” the third-most-popular holiday recording of 2018, sold 52,000 tracks in 2008 and streamed and sold the equivalent of 839,000 last year. Overall, holiday music accounted for 0.89% of on-demand streams in 2015 and 1.11% last year -- and during that time, the overall revenue from on-demand streaming rose from $1.57 billion in 2015 to $5.5 billion in 2018, according to the RIAA.

another article within the same series reports an amazon music rep's claim that requests for holiday music to alexa smart speakers have numbered 10,000 per minute since december 1st. (as yet another article on amazon's increasing involvement in the christmas tunes biz points out, while some requests are for specific recordings or artists, many are simply generic calls for 'holiday music' or similar.) moreover, many old chestnuts are being repackaged into what are essentially playlists, but presented to digital service providers as digital-only albums so as to appear on new release lists, complete with generic titles like best christmas songs 2019 evidently selected with similarly generic search queries and voice requests in mind.

on this week's hot 100, four of the chart's top ten are christmas tunes, with "all i want for christmas is you" repeating its turn at the top and "rockin' around the christmas tree" at a new personal best just under it. given that peak seasonal streaming will occur on christmas eve and day, next week's chart is sure to have even more holiday hits toward the top, with carey's almost certainly assured a third week at the crest. given that 24 christmas songs were on the hot 100 at the season's height last year, i'm gonna go ahead and predict at least 30 this year, with a new record amount within the top 10 (it was four at last year's holiday peak). since most of these will have to be in the top 50 to even be eligible to enter, about 60% of prime real estate on the chart will be occupied by these old evergreens instead of the newly-breaking hits that the chart was originally formulated to track.

in an interview last year, billboard's senior director of charts gary trust seemed to indicate a fairly unwavering commitment to current policy with respect to christmas music's eligibility for the hot 100. ("For most of the year, the chart is still going to be driven by absolutely current music. This is the time of the year when consumption habits fluctuate very wildly, and the charts should reflect that.") but part of me wonders whether voices in the industry will privately pressure billboard to change the rules to ensure that holiday music does not monopolize the charts every december -- it's not exactly a good look for current hits-in-waiting to be plummeting down the charts, or even prematurely banished to recurrency, when their actual week-on-week activity is the sort that would on a non-holiday week be reflected by a small upward movement.

guess we'll see! in the meantime, perhaps we'll be seeing this year's amazon exclusives (john legend's "happy xmas" and ellie goulding's "river") managing to effortlessly find themselves on the chart like last year's did.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

"all i want for christmas is you" and "last christmas" are both poorly written songs imo

didn't expect this winner

Mariah (25), Brenda (41) and Bobby (50) all re-entered the countdown this week, so tis the season. With "Jingle Bell Rock," I do wonder: does Mean Girls fandom have anything to do with its contemporary popularity (relative, that is--I realize that film is nearly 20 years old now), or has this song always been bigger than, say, any given version of "Silent Night" or "Frosty the Snowman" or anything like that?

I just learned via Andrew Hickey that “Feliz Navidad” was produced by the same guy who produced Surrealistic Pillow for the Jefferson Airplane.