Let's poll... RYM's Top 50 Albums of All Time

Is this the men-only list or something

Geez, it's still so godawful boring. I guess I'd have to go MBV by default?

Nico is at #6, what more do you want?!?!? Sheesh.

xp

oh you don't wanna know what i really think.

voting disintegration, but fuck this list.

hey it's kind of like this year! "voting biden, but fuck this system."

It's simultaneously better and worse than its RS counterpart.

It is just as boring, just in a slightly different way!

Torn between Low and The Queen is Dead (not even my favourite Smiths album ffs); ended up voting for Ziggy because I remember the first evening I played it - I went and immediately listened to it all over again.

xxxp let's not forget the hurdy-gurdy lady in Arcade Fire!

There are loads of good albums here, just sort of tiring and sad to read them all stuck together like this

Yeah, this is like exhibit A in the argument that a band's most popular album is rarely a band's best album.

let's not forget the hurdy-gurdy lady in Arcade Fire!

And Kim Gordon and Bilinda Butcher and Kim Deal! And that woman who sings on 'The Great Gig in the Sky'!

Top 50 Gold CDs the Dude at the Stereo Store Throws On to Demo the Dynamic Range of This Year's Models

this is a more conservative list than Q magazine would produce

most of these were locked in 10+ years ago when the site was heavy on prog/metal nerds and its taken the likes of kendrick lamar to displace them. wonder what it'd look like if you only counted active accounts

voted for kanye

just kidding

This has a higher proportion of albums I listen to than the other lists. I'm glad there's a list like this.

Literal lol at that top 4

This is fucking awful but the contemporary RYM yearly charts are really not bad, cider press otm

That GYBE album at 13 is maybe the weirdest entry?

I gave up on making a “so literally all music made by a solo female artist is inferior to album X” post as there were too many options

rym yearly charts are like

20s - good
30s - good
40s - good
50s - good, bit conservative
60s - good, if predictable
70s - fairly good, but even more predictable
80s - weird
90s - more predictable than good
00s - just predictable
10s - a few cliques fighting to get their stuff on top, to nobody's benefit.

the weird thing about gybe at #13 is that that isn't their best album

Very few albums I count on to bring me joy in the next years
Weirdest has to be Neutral Milk Hotel or maybe In Rainbows
It was between King Crimson, Wu-Tang, Talking Heads, Pixies, Sonic Youth, The Smiths. Went with Wu-tang.
I expect a Bowie (boring) win

but one of those cliques is weird art-pop, and another is weird art-metal, and I'm in those cliques

Yeah, that's a fair assessment.

3xp

the weird thing about gybe at #13 is that that isn't their best album

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nzf907rY38Y&list=PLcBPFG0zN-JggvpaN4dJ05h52SF_0g_Sr&index=10&t=0s

Agree with that but GYBE themselves appearing on a list like this is one of the least surprising things I can imagine.xp

The albums I'd consider voting for:

14. Kendrick Lamar, 'good kid, m.A.A.d. city'
15. The Beatles, 'Abbey Road'
16. Miles Davis, 'Kind of Blue'
17. Talking Heads, 'Remain in Light'
19. Madvillain, 'Madvillainy'
26. John Coltrane, 'A Love Supreme'
46. Sigur Rós, 'Ágætis byrjun'
47. DJ Shadow, 'Endtroducing.....'

I loved Ágætis byrjun when it came out, but haven't listened to it in at least 15 years now, and doubt I will again.

51-100 has a lot more interesting records. Homogenic, Hounds of Love, Tago Mago, Close to the Edge, SAW 85-92, Hot Rats, Long Season (!!!!), Future Days, Music Has the Right to Children

Yeah tbc I don’t think Godspeed are an outlier here, it’s exactly what Cam said plus it’s very high on the list. Is anything an outlier? Endtroducing maybe the only one I was at all surprised to see

voted In the Court because that's the only one here that makes my own personal list. Remain in Light was on there too but I probably tossed it for some shitty vaporwave album

I loved Ágætis byrjun when it came out, but haven't listened to it in at least 15 years now, and doubt I will again.

same, though I did listen to it once recently and remember thinking "lol are you fucking kidding me" a lot
feel like that entire album is an attempt to recreate "Leb Wohl" on Neu! 75

80s RYM Charts are really very odd, a few of the expected canon albums, then loads of thrash metal, classical recordings and post-punk from around the world. Which I suppose is good? Not sure.

I am surprised by the lack of LCD Soundsystem, do RYM hate them like they love Death Grips?

Surprised Charlie Mingus made the list with the word "lady" in the title

51-100 has a lot more interesting records. Homogenic, Hounds of Love, Tago Mago, Close to the Edge, SAW 85-92, Hot Rats, Long Season (!!!!), Future Days, Music Has the Right to Children

Agreed. I'll poll that one next.

first 3 LCD Soundsystem albums are bolded (though I'm sure the 'bonus disc' factors into the first one), SoS is in the Top 250

I just knew Radiohead would be number one before I clicked but I didn't expect quite so much Radiohead.

*votes Radiohead, probably*

51-100 has a lot more interesting records. Homogenic, Hounds of Love, Tago Mago, Close to the Edge, SAW 85-92, Hot Rats, Long Season (!!!!), Future Days, Music Has the Right to Children

― frogbs

I do really like the Fishmans obsession on RYM. Long Season will be in the top 10 one day.

Full disclosure: I already voted for OK Computer.

for every album on this list, there's a related or adjacent one I prefer more

went for Black Saint and The Sinner Lady cos I'm sick of most of the others

wasn't RYM literally Geir Hongro: The Site

lol, RYM is typically not into hypermelodic Europop.

I see no five albums of Genesis in the top 10 so.

don't remember Geir being into Euro pop tbh

Think I'll vote for Joni Mitchell or Aretha Franklin...oh, wait...

Geir would hate most of these.

yeah 51-100 has several of my favorite records on it whereas 1-50 doesn't really have any

I do really like the Fishmans obsession on RYM. Long Season will be in the top 10 one day.

its one of the most endearing parts of that site. amusingly I've been seeing something similar happen with Kyuusai no Gihou, it had like 15 ratings when I 5-starred it and now it's bold with over 800

They're inderectly responsible for a whole lot of generic "cresndocore" post-rock but Lift Your Skinny Fists holds up for me, beautiful album

more xs and ps

but, more significantly: _The Queen Is Dead_

voting for the album that features the most ODB verses

every album on this list that I like, I like a little less because of it appearing on this list

lol is it because it's RYM or because seeing them all huddled so close together is too normative for comfort?

Four Beatles albums sounds ok but four Radiohead albums? That is ridiculous. And there isn't even their by far best album - Amnesiac - there!

It's my second fave but its omission is indeed unforgivable.

This list looks like it was made by the Radiohead forum I used to post on in 2000/2001 (GYBE, Sigur Ros, Boards of Canada etc.)

Whatever happened to Melissa btw? She was the ultimate RH stan back in ILM's early days, fighting the good fight.

It's sort of what I like about it? There's no real pretence of objectivity. It just looks like someone's favourite albums from their collection. If you really like Radiohead, Pink Floyd, and King Crimson, there's a good chance you'll like the whole list. Not everything has to be Pitchfork.xp

This list looks like it was made by the Radiohead forum I used to post on in 2000/2001 (GYBE, Sigur Ros, Boards of Canada etc.)

yeah the "music guys" I used to hang out with in college (circa 2006 or so) would've made pretty much this exact same list back then, mins Kanye and Kendrick. so many of these albums I heard for the first time through the same people. at the time the RYM list was pretty much all 60s and 70s classic rock + Radiohead.

in high school a lot of my classmates were big into classic rock stuff like Floyd, Zep, and the Beatles...music our parents and teachers liked. I guess for the current generation of teenagers that would be Radiohead? maybe why they got 3 albums in the top 10

There's maybe like 3-4 albums on this list I don't really care for so clearly it's doing a good job of catering to my demographic.

It's still astonishingly boring, though.

Let's also poll and moan about ... Acclaimed Music's Top 50 Albums of All Time

It's almost as if their star-rating methodology has nothing to do with designing a fun listicle that can logically compare to ones compiled by journalists.

Master Of Puppets and Red are the ones I listen to most lately.

Is there an updated Rolling Stone albums canon that I missed?

The 2003 list was revised in 2012 and a brand new one is apparently imminent.

We'll be polling it as soon as it drops, of course.

Before it drops as ILM is that hip

:)

pro tip just poll this one again

remember NME used to produce a list but deliberately out in a troll entry like Andrew WK to annoy readers/clickbait

um Andrew WK has 3 albums better than the majority of this list

Ride The Lightning and Master Of Puppets are about equally good and I'm happy the results reflect this.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

From this list, I've heard 44 albums and enjoy some tracks from each of them except Neutral Milk Hotel. I'm voting for Animals over Red.

if amnesiac had been released first and then kid a eight months later, would their reputations be different?

Wu-Tang

xpost I never really liked Amnesiac, one of the few Radioheads that never grabbed me

I surprised myself and went with the first Doors album. Don't @ me.

No nuclear war option no vote.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

Not the result I was expecting, but I approve.

Ha, I was one of the two votes for Daydream Nation.

I listened to the first Doors album last night, still rules

Wasn't expecting Kid A and Unknown Pleasures to get 0 votes.

baaahahaha, awesome results!

who voted for dark side of the moon???? let's be friends.

Me, I think? I could easily have gone with several others (Kind of Blue or Loveless maybe), but DSOTM is speaking to me these days, I dunno.

I did vote Wu-Tang in the Rolling Stone revamp poll.

cool, now let's figure out who voted animals and start a pink floyd power trio cover band.

also, i'm down to do a mashup cover of "money" and "c.r.e.a.m." if you are.

ok so who voted for neutral milk hotel i'm not mad i just wanna know

clearly ned

ok so who voted for neutral milk hotel i'm not mad i just wanna know

― Deflatormouse, Thursday, October 15, 2020 5:24 AM (three hours ago) bookmarkflaglink

https://i.imgur.com/3M8Db5t.gif

4 votes for Master of Puppets ?

On reflection, Mingus is the correct answer. I know there's a significant cadre of Cure people on here but the number of votes for Disintegration still surprises me.

also, i'm down to do a mashup cover of "money" and "c.r.e.a.m." if you are.

Man, every good idea's been taken.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYCk6Zq6wds

WEAK!! WE CAN DO BETTER.

That's the spirit!

At least In the 36 Chambers Over the Sea is still available.