it's time for a HAVE MOICY! poll (Michael Hurley, The Unholy Modal Rounders, Jeffrey Frederick & The Clamtones)

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed

After spending my 20s as an incorrigible music snob focused on punk/noise/industrial/experimental artists, I eventually got a clue and started branching out. Finally purchasing a mixer and beginning to do live DJ sets was one influence, briefly dating a super cool woman with wide-ranging tastes who worked at a record store was another, making some new friends with more diverse record collections was yet another. There could be twenty albums just as a sub-entry here – Otis Redding’s Love Man, the amazing New Orleans funk/soul compilation Saturday Night Fish Fry, the Anthology Of American Folk Music reissue, Rounder Records’ Ska Bonanza, thrift store P-funk albums, etc. etc. etc. As I started to DJ more events and get gigs at bars, I kept expanding my collection in every direction. It hasn’t stopped yet, and my life and DJ sets are the better for it.

Back in the Icky’s days (an anarchist teahouse in Eugene, 1994-95) my friend Sunshine would tell me about this hobo musician Michael Hurley (“he releases all his stuff on tape” – which was kind of true at the time). It took me a few years, but eventually in late 1999 I was at a Seattle record show and picked up the Weatherhole CD for a couple of bucks. Pretty soon after that I got the Rounder reissues of Snockgrass and Long Journey, but a lot of the other stuff was out of print and quite hard to find at the time. Even with this incomplete picture of his work, I was enthralled. I even saw Hurley live at least once (2002, Sam Bond’s) before hearing the older records. When I belatedly got into filesharing in 2003, I finally got to hear records like Armchair Boogie, Hi Fi Snock Uptown, and Have Moicy - the album pictured here.

https://i.discogs.com/RbDc0pxrTsYjrVzFImIgSfjFOSC-YveOvkwUgdQJLM0/rs:fit/g:sm/q:90/h:600/w:600/czM6Ly9kaXNjb2dz/LWRhdGFiYXNlLWlt/YWdlcy9SLTEzMzgw/NzItMTIxMDg2NjE3/Ny5qcGVn.jpeg

I’m not sure how much has been written long-form about this record, but it deserves its own 33 1/3 book. Robert Christgau called it “the greatest folk album of the rock era” and I think it’s worth printing his unpublished review here:

"You wear my beret and I'll use your bidet, cherie/I'll be clean you'll be free," goes Peter Stampfel's frenetic bluegrass gloss on Con Conrad's and Herb Magidson's 1935 "Midnight in Paris," setting theme and mood for this cute, fatalistic musical head comik about the pleasures, sorrows, and mundane irritations of bohemian life, country hippie division. Cut in two days in 1975 for around $1500, the album assembled a loose confederation of folkie misfits who were having trouble trusting each other as they passed 30. Breaking it down, you could call Greenwich Village stalwart Stampfel dionysian, Oregon pickup songwriter Jeffrey Frederick sardonic, and Vermont-based lazybones Michael Hurley downhome. Only that's dionysian as in throwing a party, sardonic as in plumb mean, and downhome as in blowing bubbles underwater, as in where's the salt, as in who'll do the dishes, as in "We fill up our guts/Then they turn it into shit/Then we get rid of it." And it doesn't come close to suggesting the mesh this bunch of Sixties casualties fall into. The emotion and execution are so consistent that you enjoy the acoustic arrangements--a relaxed development of the Holy Modal Rounders' irreverent traditionalism plus crucial (although not loud) input from Hurley's pet drummer, Frog--without registering their easy variety. Except when Stampfel exercises his tonsils, you never think about who's singing, either--don't even notice when cocomposer Paul Presti takes the lead on "Jealous Daddy's Death Song": "And if any of you punks try to misbehave/I'll haunt your asses to an early grave/I'm telling you telling you telling you boys/Don't you monkey with my widow when I'm gone." I bet none of them does.”

As mentioned above, this album was a serendipitous collision between three different musical forces. The Holy (in this case Unholy, missing co-founder Steve Weber who had stayed in NYC) Modal Rounders and Hurley himself have roots as far back as the Greenwich Village/Folkways Records scene of 1964-65. I don’t think Frederick was active in the 60s but his songs here are some of my favorites (given that every song on this is a stone cold classic). It is a perfectly out-of-focus snapshot of a bygone time, as per this fan review:
“The greatest front porch sittin', dog barkin', screen door squeakin', hammock swingin', mason jar swiggin', skillet lickin' album of all time.”

Here’s Hurley’s own take on it, from an extensive interview on the Perfect Sound Forever website (https://www.furious.com/perfect/michaelhurley.html):
“You probably just don't have the software to know how good I feel about the Have Moicy release. So many people have told me that they love it, it changed their life, it turned them on to old-time asskickin' hillbilly, it lead them to a superior love life, it brought them much wealth and still remains a favorite after 20 years or 10. Everytime I listen to it, it sounds more together; it sounds like a bunch of loonies too.”

As someone who spent years as a kid in and around the 70’s commune scene (and who has lived in hippie-throwback Eugene Oregon for almost 30 years), so many things about this record ring true and warm my cold punk heart. The “outlaw hippie” culture celebrated here does still live on in nooks and crannies of this troubled country, god bless those crusty old folks. Hurley lives near Astoria, Oregon, so we are lucky enough to catch him live on occasion – he even played at our house in 2009 for our wedding/housewarming. If you ever get a chance to see him live, you should go.
While his entire discography is worthy of your attention, the alchemical combination of hippie lunatics on Have Moicy is unique, and once the record works its way into your brain you too will catch yourself singing “big sack of oysters, their molecules will soon become mine”, or “when I see the dishes over there, they fill me with despair” or “I know you can’t wait until I’m dead/to drag her off to your waterbed” or any of the other great lines that abound.

individual track notes added here by yours truly.

“Midnight In Paris” - the culmination of every deadbeat beatnik boyfriend’s dream, to live for free in yr girlfriends city apartment.
“Robbin’ Banks” - self-explanatory ode to "being illegal”.
“Slurf Song” - a timeless song about the joys of food (and also the dishes).
“Jackknife/The Red Newt” - “Jackknife" is a song about wanting to kill a motherfucker, “The Red Newt” is a song about not giving a fuck whether some motherfucker kills you or not.
“Griselda” is a love song about teenage trysts in the woods.
“What Made My Hamburger Disappear” is typical sly Jeffrey Frederick songwriting, it seems amusing at first but is actually written from the POV of a guy having a heart attack.
“Sweet Lucy” is a song about being busted and going to jail with yr girlfriend.
“Country Bump” is the failed dance craze hit of the record, designed to be played at the Hoodoo Bash that we get to later in the album.
“Fooey Fooey” is a song of heartbreak and dissolution.
“Jealous Daddy’s Death Song” is a self-explanatory song about haunting people’s asses to an early grave.
“Driving Wheel” - Michael Hurley loves his cars, as this classic explains in detail.
“Weep Weep Weep” - a song about self-pity and artistic drama.
“Hoodoo Bash” - A literal and detailed description of a serious fucking party, back in the 70s when they were not fucking around. The kids still hear the stories.

Poll Results

OptionVotes
“Slurf Song” 11
“Griselda” 5
“Robbin’ Banks” 3
“Driving Wheel” 2
“Hoodoo Bash” 1
“Jealous Daddy’s Death Song” 1
“Sweet Lucy” 1
“Jackknife/The Red Newt” 1
“Country Bump” 0
“Fooey Fooey” 0
“What Made My Hamburger Disappear” 0
“Weep Weep Weep” 0
“Midnight In Paris” 0


sleeve, Sunday, 23 February 2025 02:52 (nine months ago)

the above was written for FB as part of that "post yr ten fave albums" thing, I recently bought another copy of this for some dear friends and sent them that writing plus the song-by-song breakdown which I just wrote tonight. this really is one of the best albums ever.

sleeve, Sunday, 23 February 2025 03:01 (nine months ago)

excellent write-up! just revisited this over the summer, will have to play it again though. songwriting really strong on this one, pretty much every time the next track starts to play i think, "no, no, this is the best track"

budo jeru, Sunday, 23 February 2025 05:27 (nine months ago)

these days I am torn between "Hoodoo Bash" and "The Red Newt" but yeah they are all great

sleeve, Sunday, 23 February 2025 05:33 (nine months ago)

Never been polled before? Surprised. Definitely "Slurf Song," with a contender for the greatest lyric ever: "The dishes over there/They fill me with despair."

clemenza, Sunday, 23 February 2025 05:34 (nine months ago)

Really good post, sleeve. This is one of those albums where I really wouldn't cut a single song. Torn right now between "Sweet Lucy," "Robbin' Banks," and "Slurf Song" but may vote for "Fooey Fooey" because I think it's (sneakily?) the most beautiful song here and it will no doubt be underrepresented in the poll. What a magnificent record.

Paul Ponzi, Sunday, 23 February 2025 11:56 (nine months ago)

Tough call!!! Gotta be Robbin Banks or Driving Wheel for me…

ian, Sunday, 23 February 2025 21:01 (nine months ago)

Truly stunning collection of songs.

ian, Sunday, 23 February 2025 21:02 (nine months ago)

Truly stunning collection of songs.

ian, Sunday, 23 February 2025 21:02 (nine months ago)

re-listened and had to go with "Slurf Song"

budo jeru, Sunday, 23 February 2025 23:32 (nine months ago)

this better get more than ten votes, dammit

sleeve, Sunday, 23 February 2025 23:44 (nine months ago)

Jackknife / Red Newt fer me

kornrulez6969, Monday, 24 February 2025 02:02 (nine months ago)

I've known about this record for years due to Christgau and also its presence on the "Top 100 Alternative Albums" in the 1995 Spin Alternative Guide. I've heard Hurley's Raccoon albums (which were OK) and the Rounders' Indian War Whoop (which I mostly hated).
Listened for the first time today, found it charming without being too cute too often and thought it really benefited from rotating singers/songwriters. Will listen more before I vote.

Halfway there but for you, Monday, 24 February 2025 02:56 (nine months ago)

very happy I can turn at least one ilxor on to this work of genius <3

sleeve, Monday, 24 February 2025 03:35 (nine months ago)

for anyone who likes the Frederick songs here, the Jeffrey Frederick/Clamtones album "Spiders In The Moonlight" is still around for non-collector prices and wholeheartedly recommended. Along with Hurley's "Long Journey" it forms a sort of Oregon trilogy. The Clamtones absolutely ruled the Portland bar scene of the mid-70s and I wish Dave Reisch's memoir of their 9000-mile 1976 Bicentennial US border tour (!!!) was still available online.

sleeve, Monday, 24 February 2025 03:39 (nine months ago)

In 1976 the bands took off on a 9,000-mile Bicentennial tour of the perimeter of the United States. During this tour, Frederick was arrested in Texas for performing in a dress, and the band was escorted out of Alabama by the state police, for singing the irreligious gospel tune, "Let Me Down" ("Take these nails right out of my hands/And I swear you will get to the promised land/All your sins are forgiven/now let me down...").[3] During the tour, Frederick recorded Have Moicy! ("best album of the year," Village Voice, "the top folk album of the rock era," Rolling Stone Magazine) with Jill, Michael Hurley, Peter Stampfel, Paul Presti, Dave Reisch, Robin Remaily, Wax Iwaskiewicz and Robert Nickson. His contribution to this groundbreaking record is widely recognized. For example, rock critic Robert Christgau has described Frederick as "the secret hero of my beloved Have Moicy."

Frederick's only full-length solo studio album, Spiders in the Moonlight, was recorded in 1977 after the completion of the tour. Shortly thereafter, Frederick and Jill went back to Boston for a "short break", and Steve Weber and Robin Remaily went their own ways. Frederick came back to Portland alone and formed a new band, Les Clams. The lineup was Jeff, Dave Reisch, Roger North, Bruce Sweetman or Lex Browning (depending on who was around) and Michael Shade.

sleeve, Monday, 24 February 2025 17:53 (nine months ago)

A lot of good ones but it’s Robbin Banks for me, no second thought needed

Slim is an Alien, Monday, 24 February 2025 20:29 (nine months ago)

"Spiders In The Moonlight" is still around for non-collector prices

yes although i'd pay some money for an LP reissue with the superior Michael Hurley art

budo jeru, Tuesday, 25 February 2025 19:56 (nine months ago)

An album so great I may not be able to vote. Kind of leaning toward "Slurf Song."

I think we're all Bezos on this bus (WmC), Tuesday, 25 February 2025 20:42 (nine months ago)

I haven't listened to it in a few years as I've dug more into Hurley, but given my love for cooking, food, and doing dishes, it can't be anything but Slurf Song.

"Cooking up tortillas is so much fun when you have a bowl of beans" is some of the best advice in a song ever.

il lavoro mi rovina la giornata (PBKR), Wednesday, 26 February 2025 12:31 (nine months ago)

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

System, Friday, 7 March 2025 00:01 (eight months ago)

Was listening to Loudon Wainwright's "Dead Skunk" in the car last week. Think that would fit comfortably onto this album. (I know some people hate that song...I've always loved it.)

clemenza, Friday, 7 March 2025 00:11 (eight months ago)

I love Dead Skunk too, and you're absolutely right.

Gotta vote for Driving Wheel, which captures with surreal levity the experience of desperately flailing about when you've hit absolute rock bottom.

Have Moicy! is classic, but Hurley's Long Journey is the ONE for me. We should poll that sometime

J. Sam, Friday, 7 March 2025 01:16 (eight months ago)

Joanna Newsom covered Slurf Song last year for her kids' matinee shows w/suitable lyrical tweaks :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6uVcBRHuxA

J. Sam, Friday, 7 March 2025 01:22 (eight months ago)

^ That's my buddy (and sleeve's) on the banjo. He's in our D&D group.

ian, Friday, 7 March 2025 01:37 (eight months ago)

:O

sleeve, Friday, 7 March 2025 02:02 (eight months ago)

This album is the epitome of laid-back. Been a while since I listened, thanks for the excuse!

Antonia and Peter are two of my favorite songwriters, and I voted Griselda, but I wasn't sure I would, there's so much competition: Robbin' Banks, Slurf Song, Sweet Lucy. And a lot of my favorite lines aren't Antonia or Peter's.

If you get scared and run,
you bastard, I'll break your arm

Whoa, whoa! catastrophe!
Candle lit the pillow on fire,
almost roasted me,
almost roasted me

Big ol' Fluke weigh three hundred pound
Fell on Harry when Harry fell down

Such great performances and perfectly-maintained vibe on this one, even if, yeah, Long Journey is even more the thing, and Spiders in the Moonlight just as good, and my Peter Stampfel top ten might not even have Moicy in it.

TheNuNuNu, Friday, 7 March 2025 02:13 (eight months ago)

they're bringing Thunderbird wine
and a POUND of HASH

sleeve, Friday, 7 March 2025 02:18 (eight months ago)

what did ian vote for? 🤔

Mrs. Ippei (Steve Shasta), Friday, 7 March 2025 05:00 (eight months ago)

Lord I love poaching chickens.

ian, Friday, 7 March 2025 16:30 (eight months ago)

Lord I love poaching chickens.

ian, Friday, 7 March 2025 16:31 (eight months ago)

<3

Mrs. Ippei (Steve Shasta), Friday, 7 March 2025 17:07 (eight months ago)

I listened to this four times and I don't think I'll ever love it as much as Christgau and everyone here, but it's interesting to hear music that diverged so much both from the mainstream and from whatever "alternative" movements were starting at the time, while still being very much of its era.

"Griselda" has an interesting tension between an absurd presentation and a melodramatic topic which somehow results in it being moving rather than a parody. The other Stampfel songs in particular remind me of being a kid in the 70s, and over-enthusiastic older people trying to compel you to sing along or otherwise participate in some supposedly enjoyable activity. I think of it as "enforced fun" and it makes me feel queasy even now.

Halfway there but for you, Friday, 7 March 2025 17:36 (eight months ago)

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

System, Saturday, 8 March 2025 00:01 (eight months ago)

It's telling of the album's balance that the top three has a Hurley, an Antonia/Peter, *and* a Jeff Fredericks tune.

Halfway, that's an unfortunate and frightening association... Peter's been in my own Triumvirate of Favorite Singers since I first fell for Moicy in 2019.

TheNuNuNu, Saturday, 8 March 2025 05:10 (eight months ago)

Paul, did you forget to vote or did something win out over Foeey in the end?

TheNuNuNu, Saturday, 8 March 2025 05:11 (eight months ago)

All three units toured Moicy in their way. Jeff's Clamtones have this Clamtones B.C. document where, alongside Jeff songs from Moicy and Spiders, they play Griselda and a bunch of Hurleys. Peter and Paul Presti's Unholy Modal Rounders play the Antonia/Peter/Paul songs and a bunch of contemporaneous unrecorded all-time great Antonia/Peter songs (Fucking Sailors in Chinatown, Places where You Never See the Snow, Cajun Polka) *and* a bunch of Hurleys (Unholier than Thou, released just last year). On Moicy, Hurley didn't play on any of the songs he didn't write, and on tour he didn't play anybody's songs but his own. Still did awesome shows, if Growlin' Bobo is any indication (1980 but he plays Slurf Song (with the verses they had to cut to fit Moicy on vinyl!) and Driving Wheel).

TheNuNuNu, Saturday, 8 March 2025 05:23 (eight months ago)

Paul, did you forget to vote or did something win out over Foeey in the end?

― TheNuNuNu, Saturday, March 8, 2025 12:11 AM (six hours ago) bookmarkflaglink

Much as I love "Fooey Fooey," I re-listened to the album and could not pull the trigger, not with "Slurf Song" in contention. Now that the latter won so decisively, though, leaving "Fooey" without a single vote, I'm regretting it slightly. "Fooey" is just one of those deep cuts that I think really benefits from being heard in isolation, because I think its relative subtlety gets overlooked when evaluated against all the other great, scene-stealing tunes on this perfect album.

Incidentally, I also feel this way about "Something Changed" on Pulp's Different Class. Probably not in the top 5 album songs on that album, right? But drop it on a mixtape or hear it out of context and you will think, "this is the best song ever written."

Underrated songs amidst an abundance of riches: might be a good thread idea!

Paul Ponzi, Saturday, 8 March 2025 12:17 (eight months ago)

happy to be the sole vote for "Hoodoo Bash", sad that "Hamburger" didn't get a vote

sleeve, Saturday, 8 March 2025 20:16 (eight months ago)

and yes xxp, the Clamtones B.C. record is fantastic, and all the live boots of Rounders/Clamtones shows from that 76-77 era are incredible too. great Rounders versions of "STP" for example.

sleeve, Saturday, 8 March 2025 20:17 (eight months ago)

I made a CDr for some friends of this album, with (mostly, two earlier Hurley tracks) contemporaneous bonus tracks as follows:

15 Hurley - Water Train
16 Clamtones - Lazy Bones
17 Rounders - STP (live)
18 Hurley - Portland Water
19 Clamtones - Stolen Guitar
20 Rounders - Low Down Dog
21 Hurley - In The Garden
22 Clamtones - Oh Me Oh My
23 Rounders - The Whole World Oughta Go On A Vacation
24 Hurley - Open Up

sleeve, Saturday, 8 March 2025 20:20 (eight months ago)

Love all those choices, sleeve. Water Train is top ten Hurley in my book.

TheNuNuNu, Sunday, 9 March 2025 04:13 (eight months ago)

same <3

sleeve, Sunday, 9 March 2025 06:03 (eight months ago)


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.