Harmony Stella guitars, played by BB King, Mr. Cobain and 10 year olds.

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
I got a regular 39" Stella acoustic for my lady's stepdad for xmas. It has a really cool sunburst from deep black to warm orange just in the center. The thing was $129.00 and I checked online and found out that retail price is $132.95, so I guess I did good. But, then I started reading how notoriously cheap they are, the Harmony name ruined by being distributed through Sears and JC Penney. This confirmed my fear that this was a toy guitar meant for kids.

Then, I found out that Kurt Cobain definitely used it to record Polly and Something In The Way and possibly 2 or 3 others. His was an old one he paid $29.00 for at a pawn shop. Then I read that BB King's first guitar was a Stella.

The thing feels kinda dinky and cheap, but it cost more than my piece of dung Gremlin, which feels solid as hell, but I discovered was a "jumbo" folk guitar. That explains why chords ring out warm, but single string picking is nearly impossible and difficult to hear. The Stella, on the other hand, has a great delta blues sound. Sharp and tinny, plays really easy. The deep end sounds a little menacing, similar to a surf or spy guitar. But this is an acoustic.

From what I can gather, these things either "stay in tune and sound great" and are "built to last a lifetime" or "sound so bad it's good and don't stay in tune for shit" or "so bad the factory probably wouldn't answer the phone if they knew you were calling about this guitar". These are direct quotes from reviewers online. I also found out that they either have horrible floating bridges or great floating bridges and are played mostly by school kids whose parents don't want to waste a lot of money on a beater guitar or by famous musicians who love the brilliant tone of superior guitars.

Can anyone clarify this for me before I wrap this package up? The guy's an old blues man. I'm sure he doesn't want a dinky kid's guitar. You'd think he'd already have an acoustic but he doesn't.

Nude Spock, Monday, 17 December 2001 01:00 (twenty-four years ago)

The "Harmony" brand has been applied to thousands of different guitars manufactured by tens of factories. But if this one sounds good and stays in tune, it is good. If you're really genuinely nervous, put it in the hands of an experienced guitarist before you wrap it up. Nobody's going to be able to judge it properly without having their hands on it.

On-line reviews of guitars are generally worthless.

Colin Meeder, Monday, 17 December 2001 01:00 (twenty-four years ago)

I don't know if Harmony has suffered the same fate as Silvertone... Silvertone used to be regarded as a great guitar, even though it was a kid's guitar from Sears. Antique Silvertones are worth big bucks these days. Unfortunately, the name was sold to some Asian outfit that made inferior guitars - so the newer Silvertones are crap.

You may want to post your question here. A lot of the people hangin' out here own these guitars & can tell you what they think....

Dave225, Monday, 17 December 2001 01:00 (twenty-four years ago)

Thanks, Dave. The color of your link suggests I visited there last night! I haven't clicked it, but I'm guessing it's the harmony-central guitar reviews (which isn't related to Harmony guitars as far as I can tell.)

I know one thing, it seems to stay in tune (but the strings are new, so how can you tell?). It has a really cool tinny sound, as opposed to a warm folk guitar sound. It's really LOUD. It's easy and fun to play, single string soloing sounds very good and detailed, not to mention loud again. It seems to be made in the USA, but it doesn't say where it was made anywhere. Apparantly, the asian models say something on the neck (I forgot what it was, but mine didn't have the phrase on the neck).

Thanks for the input, guys. I guess I'll keep it. I had so much fun playing it last night, I almost want one for myself.

Harmony Rockets and Harmony Meteors look pretty cool. I'm going to go play one (this guy's shop seems to specialize in Sears guitars) and if it's good, I'm going to get it. It's the coolest looking jazz guitar this side of a $2000 Gibson L5 or whatever.

Nude Spock, Monday, 17 December 2001 01:00 (twenty-four years ago)

there wouldn't be no blues if it wasn't for guitars from sears (ok, this is an exaggeration, but the mass availability of cheap acoustics — esp.mail-order — from the 1890s, are a major reason why the instrument is so central to american music).

mark s, Tuesday, 18 December 2001 01:00 (twenty-four years ago)


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.