TS: Kellie Clarkson- "Breakaway" vs. Carrie Underwood- "Some Hearts"

Some Hearts, definitely. "Since U Been Gone" beats "Before He Cheats," though only barely, but most of the rest of Carrie's album whomps Kelly's. And Kelly's ballads tend to suck a lot, whereas Carrie has the likes of "Jesus Take the Wheel" and "Don't Forget to Remember Me."