The Nigel Godrich Poll

Several marvellous albums, but it has to be "OK Computer", which also needs all the votes it can get in the fight against the evil "Kid A", which I am afraid will win this poll unless the lurkers agree with me.

Well, I voted for Kid A, because it's the best album here.

I'm gonna vote for Eraser just to be contrary, and 'cause it's my favourite radiohead-type project since OK Computer.

charlotte gainsbourg vs silver sun.
difficult choice...

Chaos is, by far, my favorite macca solo album, the rest (especially radiohead and beck) I don't care too much about, so...

I went with Mutations 'cuz it's my favorite on here. Only Beck that isn't entirely insufferable, for which I'll credit Godrich. Of course the other two insufferable Becks he produced kinda cut into that theory. Oh well, my reasoning sucks!

With typical lack of historical perspective, I voted for In Rainbows.

He's like the George Martin of the 90s/00s: brilliant work with one band, nothing but shit work with all the others. So, Kid A.

yea those travis records are dreadful, aren't they?

not that that's due to godrich

Radiohead's production work is really not that exemplary.

i voted for the eraser because it seems like he was pretty hands-on, but i really wonder how deep he gets as far as contributing to the actual arrangement and programming on it (and the radiohead stuff).

Radiohead's production work is really not that exemplary.

rong

the bends, showcasing that i don't spend much time on ILM, really. sorry!

anyway, i voted kid a.

his work on the mccartney album is excellent. I think what shows there is not so much just his skill at sound crafting, but help in arranging and overall aesthetic influence. that said, kid a still wins

Not a single great album on the list, at least out of the ones I've heard, so I voted for "The Man Who", which at least has a few singles that I like.

yea those travis records are dreadful, aren't they?

No, they are all excellent. But still not up there with "OK Computer" obv.

silver sun

Jason Falkner's Can You Still Feel?, which, as has unfortunately been the case with lots of Geir polls, not a choice here.

So, OK Computer, I guess, not that it needs another vote.

shoulda chose mutations

Jason Falkner's Can You Still Feel?, which, as has unfortunately been the case with lots of Geir polls, not a choice here.

He is just credited as engineer on that one.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

i went with Kid A though i could of also gone with Mutations and The Man Who.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

I can dig this (although a bit shocked at the Radiohead rout), although the correct answer is Talking Walkie.

/runs and hides

Talkie, rather, tho when I get around to that Stevie Wonder/Air mashup, that'll come in handy

i voted for mutations

davey, i voted for talkie walkie so you didn't vote!

It's true, I didn't see this poll until too late for some reason.

wtf, why didn't i see this poll?