Saucerful of Secrets vs. Movement

Message Bookmarked

Bookmark Removed

taking off from the "Pink Floyd vs. Joy Division" thread -- the "transitional" record for each of these bands after each had lost their charismatic yet troubled front-men and before either had settled into the musical sounds and lyrical themes that would dominate the respective roger waters (pink floyd) or bernard sumner (new order) eras.

Poll Results

Option	Votes
Saucerful of Secrets	15
Movement	9

― Ein kluges Äpfelchen (Eisbaer), Tuesday, 20 January 2009 10:42 (seventeen years ago)

and before some wise guy pipes up, yes i am aware that syd barrett is on a few of the songs on saucerful of secrets. it's still a fair competition since new order had some joy division-era songs on movement.

― Ein kluges Äpfelchen (Eisbaer), Tuesday, 20 January 2009 10:43 (seventeen years ago)

http://static.rateyourmusic.com/album_images/s977.jpg http://static.rateyourmusic.com/album_images/2532.jpg

― Ein kluges Äpfelchen (Eisbaer), Tuesday, 20 January 2009 10:45 (seventeen years ago)

SoS for me

― Vicious Cop Kills Gentle Fool (Tom D.), Tuesday, 20 January 2009 10:47 (seventeen years ago)

there's lots of new order that I think of as leagues better than most pink floyd but movement isn't so hot imo. saucerful on the other hand is nice. I'll take power corruption and lies over meddle or the more soundtrack tho

― J0hn D., Tuesday, 20 January 2009 10:47 (seventeen years ago)

What would all those Krautrock bands have sounded like if Floyd hadn't recorded SoS?

― Vicious Cop Kills Gentle Fool (Tom D.), Tuesday, 20 January 2009 10:54 (seventeen years ago)

the Dave Clark 5

― J0hn D., Tuesday, 20 January 2009 10:58 (seventeen years ago)

movement isn't great, whereas i really like some of the tracks on saucerful of secrets, particularly 'set the controls...' and 'remember a day'.

― Charlie Howard, Tuesday, 20 January 2009 11:02 (seventeen years ago)

Crazy, "Movement isn't great"? I though that ILX had recognised that it was under rated. Movement wins against almost any album.

― I am using your worlds, Tuesday, 20 January 2009 11:05 (seventeen years ago)

me and ILX are at odds over new order. it's a well documented saga :)

― Charlie Howard, Tuesday, 20 January 2009 11:06 (seventeen years ago)

"Saucerful Of Secrets" is ace. "Movement" also a good album, but still not in the same league.

― Geir Hongro, Tuesday, 20 January 2009 12:23 (seventeen years ago)

new order had some joy division-era songs on movement.

I don't think so.

― Zelda Zonk, Tuesday, 20 January 2009 12:30 (seventeen years ago)

No, I didn't think so either.

God, I dunno.

I did have Movement, but didn't get any of it (not being a JD fan), although I did 'get' the single(s)...

Saucer, I like the Syd tracks, but I cannae remember any of the rest of it.

Still, Youtube did(does?) provide access to the least likely video ever, the one for "Jug band blues"...

― Mark G, Tuesday, 20 January 2009 12:31 (seventeen years ago)

― Mark G, Tuesday, 20 January 2009 12:32 (seventeen years ago)

new order had some joy division-era songs on movement.

I don't think so.

― Zelda Zonk, Tuesday, January 20, 2009 7:30 AM (48 seconds ago) Bookmark

my bad -- you're right. i forgot that "ceremony" and "in a lonely place" aren't on movement.

― Ein kluges Äpfelchen (Eisbaer), Tuesday, 20 January 2009 12:34 (seventeen years ago)

SOS, though I don't love either.

― Calling All Creeps! (contenderizer), Tuesday, 20 January 2009 16:18 (seventeen years ago)

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

― System, Thursday, 22 January 2009 00:01 (seventeen years ago)

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

― System, Friday, 23 January 2009 00:05 (seventeen years ago)

Jugband Blues is the best song ever written.

― Pantheism F. Mohair (res), Friday, 23 January 2009 02:35 (seventeen years ago)

one year passes...

What would all those Krautrock bands have sounded like if Floyd hadn't recorded SoS?

― Vicious Cop Kills Gentle Fool (Tom D.), Tuesday, January 20, 2009 5:54 AM (1 year ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

I was listening to Saucerful today, and kind of thinking the same thing...SoS/Umagumma/Atom Heart Mother is kind of their proto-Krautrock period isn't it?

― only! assholes! write on doors! (Drugs A. Money), Tuesday, 2 November 2010 02:00 (fifteen years ago)

You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.