Led Zeppelin top 20 ballots

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed

Post them here.

Straight Outta Bill Compton (Spottie_Ottie_Dope), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:28 (fourteen years ago)

In the Evening - 40
Stairway to Heaven - 36
Ten Years Gone - 33
Over the Hills and Far Away - 30
Your Time Is Gonna Come - 28
Fool in the Rain - 26
Whole Lotta Love - 25
When the Levee Breaks - 24
Kashmir - 23
Dazed and Confused - 22
Tangerine - 21
Babe I'm Gonna Leave You - 20
Ramble On - 19
The Ocean - 18
What Is and What Should Never Be - 17
Immigrant Song - 16
Communication Breakdown - 15
Trampled Under Foot - 14
Black Dog - 13
Thank You - 12

Johnny Fever, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:29 (fourteen years ago)

1. Over The Hills And Far Away 8
2. Tangerine 15
3. Fool In The Rain 21
4. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You 26
5. Achilles Last Stand 7
6. How Many More Times 35
7. No Quarter 9
8. Nobody's Fault But Mine 33
9. In My Time Of Dying 30
10. Dazed And Confused 13
11. Stairway To Heaven 10
12. The Rain Song 2
13. Good Times Bad Times 12
14. Black Dog 27
15. That's The Way 24
16. The Lemon Song 53
17. The Ocean 19
18. Trampled Under Foot 22
19. Since I've Been Loving You 39
20. When The Levee Breaks 1

Straight Outta Bill Compton (Spottie_Ottie_Dope), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:29 (fourteen years ago)

Right side is where they placed on ILM

Straight Outta Bill Compton (Spottie_Ottie_Dope), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:30 (fourteen years ago)

Yeah, I just copied mine right out of the email I sent with the voting points attached.

Johnny Fever, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:32 (fourteen years ago)

The two that didn't make the top 55 in bold, ILM placement on right:

1. In The Evening 28
2. What Is And What Should Never Be 23
3. Fool In The Rain 21
4. Immigrant Song 3
5. The Rain Song 2
6. Nobody's Fault But Mine 32
7. Tangerine 15
8. Bron Yr Aur Stomp
9. No Quarter 9
10. Trampled Under Foot 22
11. South Bound Suarez
12. Down By The Seaside 48
13. Over the Hills and Far Away 8
14. When The Levee Breaks 1
15. The Wanton Song 37
16. Stairway To Heaven 10
17. Achilles' Last Stand 7
18. Black Dog 27
19. Since I've Been Loving You 41
20. Gallows Pole 36

EZ Snappin, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:34 (fourteen years ago)

1 How Many More Times
2 When the Levee Breaks
3 In My Time of Dying
4 Rock n Roll
5 Black Dog
6 Immigrant Song
7 Sick Again
8 For Your Life
9 Out on the Tiles
10 Dancing Days
11.Bring It On Home
12 Traveling Riverside Blues
13 Gallows Poll
14 Ramble On
15 Good Times Bad Times
16 Nobody's Fault But Mine
17 Ten Years Gone
18 Kashmir
19 Trampled Under Foot
20 What Is and What Should Never Be

Naive Teen Idol, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:35 (fourteen years ago)

my ballot and final position

1) In The Light (28)
2) Immigrant Song (3)
3) The Song Remains The Same (11)
4) Achilles Last Stand (7)
5) Your Time Is Gonna Come (46)
6) That's The Way (24)
7) Battle of Evermore (18)
8) Ten Years Gone (4)
9) Thank You (54)
10) No Quarter (9)
11) When The Levee Breaks (1)
12) Tangerine (15)
13) Friends (40)
14) Hey Hey What Can I Do (45)
15) Carouselambra (44)
16) Going To California (17)
17) The Rain Song (2)
18) The Rover (32)
19) Nobody's Fault But Mine (33)
20) Down By The Seaside (49)

buzza, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:36 (fourteen years ago)

18 out of 20, which seems about right:

1. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
2. Achilles Last Stand
3. Immigrant Song
4. When The Levee Breaks
5. Over The Hills And Far Away
6. The Ocean
7. Kashmir
8. Stairway To Heaven
9. Tea For One
10. Tangerine

11. Out On The Tiles
12. Friends
13. Black Dog
14. Bron-Yr-Aur
15. The Battle Of Evermore
16. All My Love
17. Rock & Roll
18. Travelling Riverside Blues
19. No Quarter
20. Carouselambra

Ismael Klata, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:36 (fourteen years ago)

01 when the levee breaks (1)
02 immigrant song (3)
03 since i've been loving you (39)
04 nobody's fault but mine (33)
05 rock and roll (31)
06 the ocean (19)
07 custard pie (42)
08 kashmir (5)
09 gallows pole (36)
10 in the evening (29)
11 black dog (27)
12 dazed and confused (13)
13 trampled under foot (22)
14 babe i'm gonna leave you (26)
15 whole lotta love (34)
16 what is and what should never be (23)
17 the lemon song (53)
18 in the light (28)
19 in my time of dying (30)
20 hey hey what can i do (45)

mookieproof, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:37 (fourteen years ago)

Ten Years Gone
That's The Way
Friends
The Song Remains The Same
The Battle Of Evermore
In My Time Of Dying
What Is And What Should Never Be
No Quarter
The Wanton Song
Dazed And Confused
The Rover
Sick Again
Achilles' Last Stand
Thank You
The Rain Song
In The Light
Immigrant Song
Stairway To Heaven
Communication Breakdown
Down By The Seaside

Spectrist, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:39 (fourteen years ago)

1. The Song Remains the Same #11
2. The Rain Song #2
3. Ten Years Gone #4
4. Communication Breakdown #16
5. Over The Hills and Far Away #8
6. The Immigrant Song #3
7. Dazed and Confused #13
8. Kashmir #5
9. In My Time of Dying #30
10. Carouselambra #44
11. Four Sticks #25
12. Misty Mountain Hop #14
13. Dancing Days #20
14. That's the Way #24
15. Achilles Last Stand #7
16. Good Times Bad Times #12
17. In The Evening #29
18. In The Light #28
19. Heartbreaker #48
20. The Wanton Song #37

Wish I had switched "The Immigrant Song" and "Communication Breakdown", not that it needed my help.

grandavis, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:40 (fourteen years ago)

1 Ten Years Gone 4
2 In The Evening 29
3 The Rain Song 2
4 That's The Way 24
5 Out On The Tiles 41
6 Carouselambra 44
7 How Many More Times 35
8 Fool in The Rain 21
9 Communication Breakdown 16
10 Trampled Underfoot 22
11 Down By The Seaside 49
12 Bring It On Home 47
13 The Rover 32
14 Custard Pie 42
15 The Ocean 19
16 Heartbreaker 48
17 Houses of The Holy 38
18 Wearing and Tearing
19 Ramble On 6
20 The Wanton Song 37

righteousmaelstrom, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:41 (fourteen years ago)

Wearing and Tearing was my last cut.

Johnny Fever, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:42 (fourteen years ago)

1. In My Time of Dying
2. Achilles Last Stand
3. When the Levee Breaks
4. Nobody's Fault But Mine
5. The Rain Song
6. In The Light
7. No Quarter
8. Immigrant Song
9. Misty Mountain Hop
10. Dazed and Confused
11. The Wanton Song
12. Ramble On
13. Going to California
14. Communication Breakdown
15. Good Times Bad Times
16. For Your Life
17. Out On The Tiles
18. Four Sticks
19. What Is and What Should Never Be
20. Stairway to Heaven

Only "for your life" didn't place.

chewy, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:45 (fourteen years ago)

i must admit i did overrated achilles a little on purpose because i mistakenly thought not a lot of ppl liked it

1 Achilles' Last Stand
2 Communication Breakdown
3 Misty Mountain Hop
4 When The Levee Breaks
5 Immigrant Song
6 Over the Hills and Far Away
7 Stairway To Heaven
8 Ramble On
9 The Battle Of Evermore
10 Kashmir
11 Whole Lotta Love
12 Bron Yr Aur
13 Heartbreaker
14 The Song Remains the Same
15 Nobody's Fault But Mine
16 Night Flight
17 Gallows Pole
18 The Wanton Song
19 Your Time Is Gonna Come
20 In The Evening

little dog (upper mississippi sh@kedown), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:47 (fourteen years ago)

i think wearing and tearing was my last cut too

mookieproof, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:47 (fourteen years ago)

in truth i'd probably put it after stairway and push everything up or down accordingly

little dog (upper mississippi sh@kedown), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:47 (fourteen years ago)

(and i meant bron-yr-aur not bron-yr-aur stomp, i think the non stomp one is the prettiest couple minutes they ever did)

little dog (upper mississippi sh@kedown), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:48 (fourteen years ago)

I think Achilles might be my favorite now actually. idk anymore!

Straight Outta Bill Compton (Spottie_Ottie_Dope), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:49 (fourteen years ago)

"Wearing and Tearing" and "Tea for One" were my top 2. That's all I'm giving out!

L.P. Hovercraft (WmC), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:52 (fourteen years ago)

Aww, it's not like you can be wrong. It's yer favorites, you know.

grandavis, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:53 (fourteen years ago)

PU$$AAAAAAAY xp

Straight Outta Bill Compton (Spottie_Ottie_Dope), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:54 (fourteen years ago)

Love the intro to "Tea for One" so much.

grandavis, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:55 (fourteen years ago)

1. Over The Hills And Far Away
2. Fool In The Rain
3. The Rain Song
4. Ramble On
5. When The Levee Breaks
6. Achilles Last Stand
7. Dancing Days
8. What Is And What Should Never Be
9. Whole Lotta Love
10. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
11. Stairway To Heaven
12. Your Time Is Gonna Come
13. Communication Breakdown
14. The Song Remains The Same
15. Rock And Roll
16. Houses Of The Holy
17. Living Loving Maid (She's Just A Woman)
18. Black Dog
19. Nobody's Fault But Mine
20. Tangerine

some dude, Friday, 26 August 2011 18:56 (fourteen years ago)

my #1 was "white summer/black mountain side"
my #2 was "bron-yr-aur"
my #3 was "hats off to (roy) harper"

Puff Daddy, whoever the fuck you are. I am dissapoint. (Steve Shasta), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:57 (fourteen years ago)

that's all i remember.

Puff Daddy, whoever the fuck you are. I am dissapoint. (Steve Shasta), Friday, 26 August 2011 18:57 (fourteen years ago)

Top 20 Zeppelin Tunes:
1 Tangerine
2 Kashmir
3 Bring It On Home
4 In My Time Of Dying
5 Stairway To heaven
6 Ten Years Gone
7 Friends
8 Communication Breakdown
9 Black Dog
10 Dancing days
11 Fool In The rain
12 Four Sticks
13 South Bound Suarez
14 Houses Of the Holy
15 Gallows Pole
16 Achilles Last Stand
17 That's The way
18 Since I've been Loving You
19 Nobody's Fault But Mine
20 Royal Orleans

Vendo Caramelos A Veces Sin Dinero (Capitaine Jay Vee), Friday, 26 August 2011 19:08 (fourteen years ago)

Had I submitted a ballot, which I did not because I suck, it might have looked something like this. Well, the top ten would have at least:

1) Over the Hills and Far Away
2) Fool in the Rain
3) Communication Breakdown
4) Tangerine
5) The Rain Song
6) Hey Hey What Can I Do
7) Kashmir
8) The Crunge
9) Nobody's Fault But Mine
10) D'yer Mak'er

your mom the burrito (ENBB), Friday, 26 August 2011 19:15 (fourteen years ago)

some #1 and #2 as me! high five!

some dude, Friday, 26 August 2011 19:15 (fourteen years ago)

When the Levee Breaks
Kashmir
Dazed and Confused
Ramble O
The Battle of Evermore
Immigrant Song
Since I've Been Loving You
Rock & Roll
In the Light
Achilles' Last Stand
Going to California
In My Time of Dying
No Quarter
Thank You
The Rain Song
Nobody's Fault But Mine
Ten Years Gone
Over the Hills and Far Away
The Rover
Dancing Days

Brad C., Friday, 26 August 2011 19:15 (fourteen years ago)

Ramble On, obv

Brad C., Friday, 26 August 2011 19:16 (fourteen years ago)

Ha, Al - I noticed! :)

your mom the burrito (ENBB), Friday, 26 August 2011 19:17 (fourteen years ago)

1. Friends 40
2. Trampled Under Foot 22
3. The Ocean 19
4. Houses Of The Holy 38
5. Dancing Days 20
6. Kashmir 5
7. Carouselambra 44
8. Black Dog 27
9. When The Levee Breaks 1
10. Immigrant Song 3
11. Rock And Roll 31
12. The Rain Song 2
13. Gallows Pole 36
14. In The Light 28
15. Heartbreaker 48
16. Four Sticks 25
17. What Is And What Should Never Be 23
18. Ramble On 6
19. All My Love 59
20. No Quarter 9

Very little acoustic stuff, nothing off the first album. Regret voting for "All My Love".

Ban or Astro-Ban? (Ówen P.), Friday, 26 August 2011 19:34 (fourteen years ago)

1. Since I've Been Loving You
2. Dazed And Confused
3. The Rain Song
4. The Song Remains The Same
5. No Quarter
6. Communication Breakdown
7. Achilles' Last Stand
8. In My Time Of Dying
9. Celebration Day
10. Custard Pie
11. Kashmir
12. Out On The Tiles
13. The Crunge
14. Good Times Bad Times
15. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
16. Immigrant Song
17. How Many More Times
18. The Wanton Song
19. Gallows Pole
20. The Lemon Song

nate woolls, Friday, 26 August 2011 19:40 (fourteen years ago)

When The Levee Breaks
Ten Years Gone
Gallows Pole
No Quarter
Kashmir
Bron Yr Aur Stomp
Bring It On Home
The Ocean
How Many More Times
The Wanton Song
Good Times Bad Times
Black Dog
Tangerine
Immigrant Song
The Rain Song
The Battle Of Evermore
Travelling Riverside Blues
Going To California
The Rover
Night Flight

call all destroyer, Friday, 26 August 2011 19:51 (fourteen years ago)

Good Times Bad Times
Communication Breakdown
Over The Hills And Far Away
Ten Years Gone
Nobody's Fault But Mine
Houses Of The Holy
Trampled Under Foot
When The Levee Breaks
Stairway To Heaven
Fool In The Rain
D'yer Mak'er
Custard Pie
Immigrant Song
Black Dog
The Rain Song
Ramble On
Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
Bron-Yr-Aur
What Is And What Should Never Be
Celebration Day

Euler, Friday, 26 August 2011 20:23 (fourteen years ago)

1. Goin’ to California
2. That’s the Way
3. Rock ‘n’ Roll
4. Bron Ya Aur
5. No Quarter
6. When the Levee Breaks
7. Hey Hey What Can I Do
8. Fool in the Rain
9. The Rain Song
10. Thank You
11. Out On the Tiles
12. D’Yer Mak’er
13. In the Evening
14. Your Time is Gonna Come
15. Misty Mountain Hop
16. Ramble On
17. Kashmir
18. Tangerine
19. The Ocean
20. Boogie With Stu

satisfying punishment for that thing he said about lesbians (Shakey Mo Collier), Friday, 26 August 2011 20:39 (fourteen years ago)

I erased the email with my ballot. WmC, can you post if possible? Thanks!

a 'catch-all', almost humorous, 'Jeez' quality (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn), Friday, 26 August 2011 20:44 (fourteen years ago)

1. When The Levee Breaks
2. Communication Breakdown
3. Living Loving Maid
4. Misty Mountain Hop
5. Ramble On
6. Travelling Riverside Blues
7. What Is And What Should Never Be
8. Bring It On Home
9. Dancing Days
10. Going To California
11. Hey Hey What Can I Do
12. In The Light
13. Trampled Under Foot
14. Celebration Day 

15. Four Sticks

16. Gallows Pole

17. Good Times Bad Times 

18. The Lemon Song

19. Your Time Is Gonna Come
20. We're Gonna Groove

You guys are making me feel like I'm nuts for liking Livin' Lovin' Maid so much.

Darin, Friday, 26 August 2011 20:57 (fourteen years ago)

Didn't realize a separate thread was going to be started, so I'll re-post here:

1. “Good Times Bad Times” (40)
2. “Misty Mountain Hop” (36)
3. “Four Sticks” (33)
4. “Hey Hey What Can I Do” (30)
5. “Black Dog” (28)
6. “Your Time Is Gonna Come” (26)
7. “Over the Hills and Far Away” (25)
8. “Whole Lotta Love” (24)
9. “Black Mountain Side” (23)
10. “Nobody’s Fault but Mine” (22)
11. “That’s the Way” (21)
12. “Black Country Woman” (20)

Pretty conventional, so most of mine made the big list...was surprised "Black Mountain Side" didn't, but that's it.

clemenza, Friday, 26 August 2011 21:00 (fourteen years ago)

Tracks

1. When The Levee Breaks
2. The Song Remains The Same
3. The Rover
4. Stairway To Heaven
5. Over the Hills and Far Away
6. Ten Years Gone
7. Hey Hey What Can I Do
8. Misty Mountain Hop
9. Gallows Pole
10. Immigrant Song
11. Going To California
12. Rock And Roll
13. What Is And What Should Never Be
14. Tangerine
15. South Bound Suarez
16. The Ocean
17. Travelling Riverside Blues
18. Black Dog
19. Night Flight
20. Babe I’m Gonna Leave You

kornrulez6969, Friday, 26 August 2011 21:22 (fourteen years ago)

Glad someone else rated "The Song Remains the Same" so high. Also "The Rover"!

grandavis, Friday, 26 August 2011 21:24 (fourteen years ago)

Yes. The Rover is absolutely killer. And The Song Remains The Same is as good as anything they've done besides Levee.

kornrulez6969, Friday, 26 August 2011 21:30 (fourteen years ago)

1. Houses of the Holy
2. In My Time of Dying
3. In the Light
4. The Rain Song
5. Dancing Days
6. When the Levee Breaks
7. Bring It On Home
8. Ten Years Gone
9. Since I’ve Been Loving You
10. Custard Pie
11. Tea for One
12. Song Remains the Same
13. Fool in the Rain
14. Out on the Tiles
15. Sick Again
16. Stairway to Heaven
17. Going to California
18. Dazed and Confused
19. Kashmir
20. Achilles Last Stand

Iago Galdston, Friday, 26 August 2011 22:59 (fourteen years ago)

1 kashmir (5)
2 when the levee breaks (1)
3 in the evening (29)
4 the rover (32)
5 stairway to heaven (10)
6 no quarter (9)
7 nobody's fault but mine (33)
8 the ocean (19)
9 whole lotta love (6)
10 over the hills and far away (8)
11 communication breakdown (16)
12 what is and what should never be (23)
13 ramble on (6)
14 since I've been loving you (39)
15 immigrant song (3)
16 heartbreaker (48)
17 in my time of dying (30)
18 good times bad times (12)
19 custard pie (42)
20 four sticks (25)

all yoga attacks are fire based (rogermexico.), Friday, 26 August 2011 23:16 (fourteen years ago)

Alfred's ballot:

1. Trampled Underfoot
2. Fool in the Rain
3. The Rover
4. Out on the Tiles
5. That's The Way
6. In the Evening
7. Misty Mountain Hop
8. Houses of the Holy
9. When the Levee Breaks
10. Over the Hills and Far Away
11. Friends
12. The Ocean
13. Going to California
14. Black Country Woman
15. Celebration
16. D'Yer Mak'r
17. Ten Years Gone
18. The Rain Song
19. Immigrant Song
20. Tangerine

FAVORITE ALBUMS:

1. Houses of the Holy
2. IV
3. III
4. Physical Graffiti
5. In Through the Out Door

L.P. Hovercraft (WmC), Friday, 26 August 2011 23:41 (fourteen years ago)

WmC, can you post mine for the sheer challopsian lolz?

Puff Daddy, whoever the fuck you are. I am dissapoint. (Steve Shasta), Friday, 26 August 2011 23:50 (fourteen years ago)

Yup.

Song Rank
1) White Summer/Black Mountain Side
Bron-Yr-Aur
Hat's Off To (Roy) Harper
Bring It On Home
Four Sticks
The Lemon Song
Achilles Last Stand
In The Light
Kashmir
Ten Years Gone
The Rain Song
Going To California
Travelling Riverside Blues
Custard Pie
Ramble On
The Song Remains The Same
Over The Hills And Far Away
Your Time Is Gonna Come
That's The Way
20) Down By The Seaside

LP Rank
1) Physical Graffiti
2) Houses of the Holy
3) IV
4) II
5) Presence

Least Liked Tracks
1) D'yer Maker
2) Hot Dog
3) All My Love

L.P. Hovercraft (WmC), Friday, 26 August 2011 23:51 (fourteen years ago)

1. Fool in the Rain
2. When the Levee Breaks
3. Over The Hills And Far Away
4. Immigrant Song
5. The Ocean
6. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
7. The Crunge
8. Trampled Under Foot
9. Kashmir
10. Gallows Pole
11. Good Times Bad Times
12. The Song Remains the Same
13. How Many More Times
14. Dancing Days
15. No Quarter
16. Misty Mountain Hop
17. Friends
18. Black Dog
19. Rock and Roll
20. Tangerine

slapped together and sent off 5 mins before deadline, not really as carefully put together as i might've liked

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_i_qxQztHRI (Princess TamTam), Friday, 26 August 2011 23:59 (fourteen years ago)

With a significant caveat on the results thread:

1 Stairway to Heaven
2 Achilles’ Last Stand
3 Dancing Days
4 That’s the Way
5 The Song Remains the Same
6 Good Times Bad Times
7 The Rain Song
8 Dazed and Confused
9 The Wanton Song
10 The Lemon Song
11 How Many More Times?
12 Whole Lotta Love
13 Kashmir
14 Black Dog
15 The Rover
16 Custard Pie
17 Out on the Tiles
18 Over the Hills and Far Away
19 All of My Love
20 Immigrant Song

EveningStar (Sund4r), Saturday, 27 August 2011 00:20 (fourteen years ago)

1. "Tangerine"
2. "When The Levee Breaks"
3. "Sick Again"
4. "No Quarter"
5. "In The Evening"
6. "The Wanton Song"
7. "Custard Pie"
8. "How Many More Times"
9. "Boogie With Stu"
10. "Hot Dog"

11. "Nobody's Fault But Mine"
12. "The Song Remains The Same"
13. "Misty Mountain Hop"
14. "Bron-Y-aur Stomp"
15. "The Battle of Evermore"
16. "Celebration Day"
17. "Black Country Woman"
18. "Hats Off To (Roy) Harper"
19. "The Crunge"

20. "The Rover"

14 made it. For the most part I said shoo to the radio staples, and honestly I would take these over most of them anyway. Didn't do the albums or a hated list.

Mucho! Macho! Honcho!: Turn Off The Dark (C. Grisso/McCain), Saturday, 27 August 2011 00:53 (fourteen years ago)

props to you for being the only other voter for "Hats Off".

Puff Daddy, whoever the fuck you are. I am dissapoint. (Steve Shasta), Saturday, 27 August 2011 01:01 (fourteen years ago)

No, there were three -- Hats Off was my #6.

# Wearing And Tearing
# Tea For One
# Four Sticks
# In My Time Of Dying
# Since I've Been Loving You
# Hats Off To (Roy) Harper
# Sick Again
# Achilles' Last Stand
# Out On The Tiles
# The Wanton Song
# Bron-Yr-Aur
# Carouselambra
# Down by the Seaside
# I'm Gonna Crawl
# Misty Mountain Hop
# Candy Store Rock
# Ten Years Gone
# When The Levee Breaks
# Kashmir
# Black Dog

L.P. Hovercraft (WmC), Saturday, 27 August 2011 02:00 (fourteen years ago)

WmC, your ballot is awesome, contrarian in the best sense....

Iago Galdston, Saturday, 27 August 2011 02:13 (fourteen years ago)

Hahaha, thank you. I slashed pretty viciously, cut the first two albums out entirely, and added "Black Dog" back when I realized I had cut it down to 19. I actually thought "Tea for One" would be top-50, foolish me.

L.P. Hovercraft (WmC), Saturday, 27 August 2011 02:34 (fourteen years ago)

I stuck Livin' Lovin at #4 because I had Ramble On at #3 and they go hand in hand (imo)

that's cute, but it's WRONG (CaptainLorax), Saturday, 27 August 2011 03:44 (fourteen years ago)

I love seeing everyone's choices so I'm glad this separate thread exists. I've listened to so many of these today including a lot that I either hadn't heard or given much consideration to before. It was awesome.

your mom the burrito (ENBB), Saturday, 27 August 2011 03:50 (fourteen years ago)

Ya, I thought I would be done listening to LZ after the countdown finished, but all I wanted to listen to on the commute home was No Quarter and Achilles Last Stand over and over.

Straight Outta Bill Compton (Spottie_Ottie_Dope), Saturday, 27 August 2011 03:54 (fourteen years ago)

Yeah I totes listened to some of them at least five times.

your mom the burrito (ENBB), Saturday, 27 August 2011 03:55 (fourteen years ago)

1. The Rain Song (live)
2. The Song Remains The Same (live)
3. Ramble On
4. Living Loving Maid
5. The Battle Of Evermore
6. Immigrant Song
7. Down By The Seaside
8. Fool in the Rain
9. Going to California
10. In The Light
11. The Crunge
12. Misty Mountain Hop
13. Ten Years Gone
14. No Quarter (live?)
15. What is and What Should Never Be
16. Four Sticks
17. Black Dog
18. The Wanton Song
19. D'yer Maker
20. Over The Hills And Far Away

I didn't put much time into my ballot. There was some songs that I either forgot or discovered after I sent my ballot. I've been relatively clueless about post Physical Graffiti until now.

that's cute, but it's WRONG (CaptainLorax), Saturday, 27 August 2011 06:13 (fourteen years ago)

1 - The Ocean
2 - Over the Hills and Far Away
3 - The Battle of Evermore
4 - Ramble On
5 - Tangerine
6 - The Rain Song
7 - Going to California
8 - When the Levee Breaks
9 - That's The Way
10 - Good Times Bad Times
11 - Hey Hey What Can I Do
12 - The Song Remains the Same
13 - Heartbreaker
14 - Rock and Roll
15 - Kashmir
16 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - Misty Mountain Hop
18 - All of My Love
19 - Dazed and Confused
20 - Thank You

that's not my post, Saturday, 27 August 2011 06:32 (fourteen years ago)

1. That's The Way
2. Since I've Been Loving You
3. Tangerine
4. Ten Years Gone
5. Thank You
6. The Song Remains The Same
7. In The Light
8. The Rain Song
9. Friends
10. Going To California
11. Celebration Day
12. The Battle Of Evermore
13. Dazed And Confused
14. How Many More Times
15. What Is And What Should Never Be
16. The Rover
17. Trampled Under Foot
18. Travelling Riverside Blues
19. Your Time Is Gonna Come
20. Fool In The Rain

All of my picks charted, although I seriously contemplated "Hots On For Nowhere", "Poor Tom", even "Ozone Baby". Also strongly considered "Tea For One", but as David Spade would say, I liked it better the first time when it was called "Since I've Been Loving You".

Lee547 (Lee626), Saturday, 27 August 2011 06:42 (fourteen years ago)

1. Ten Years Gone
2. Achilles' Last Stand
3. Four Sticks
4. How Many More Times
5. Whole Lotta Love
6. Dazed And Confused
7. Communication Breakdown
8. We're Gonna Groove
9. Carouselambra
10. The Rain Song
11. Wearing And Tearing
12. Over the Hills and Far Away
13. What Is And What Should Never Be
14. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
15. The Song Remains The Same
16. Ramble On
17. Good Times Bad Times
18. Bron Yr Aur Stomp
19. That's The Way
20. Stairway To Heaven

This was probably the hardest ballot I've ever made here at ILM. "South Bound Suarez" and "For Your Life" were two very serious contenders.

Kent Burt, Saturday, 27 August 2011 13:19 (fourteen years ago)

I stuck Livin' Lovin at #4 because I had Ramble On at #3 and they go hand in hand (imo)

― that's cute, but it's WRONG (CaptainLorax), Friday, August 26, 2011 11:44 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark

strikes me as an odd thing to say since "Heartbreaker" and "Living Loving Maid" are the ones that are always played on the radio as a pair

some dude, Saturday, 27 August 2011 13:24 (fourteen years ago)

I was curious to note Physical Graffiti's results by year recording session -- no surprise that the main 1974 sessions did the best, for the most part.

10 yrs gone - 1974
Kashmir - 1974
Trampled - 1974
In the light - 1974
time of dying - 1974
Rover - 1974
Wanton - 1974
Houses of the Holy - 1972
Custard pie - 1974
Seaside - 1971
Sick again - 1974
Bron yr aur - 1970
Night flight - 1971
Black country woman - 1972
Boogie w/stu - 1971

L.P. Hovercraft (WmC), Saturday, 27 August 2011 13:36 (fourteen years ago)

wow. thanks for doing that. i never saw so clearly what a 1974 only release would look like, which is an absolute killer and different animal

Iago Galdston, Saturday, 27 August 2011 13:53 (fourteen years ago)

Oops, "The Rover" was 1972.

L.P. Hovercraft (WmC), Saturday, 27 August 2011 14:09 (fourteen years ago)

A 74-only PG would have been 53:31, a little too long for two sides of vinyl. Minus "Sick Again," it's 48:48 -- doable. They could probably have tightened up a couple of songs and gotten it a minute shorter.

Side 1:
Custard pie - 4:13
Trampled - 5:37
Kashmir - 8:32
10 yrs gone - 6:32

Side 2:
In the light - 8:46
Wanton - 4:07
time of dying - 11:04

Think that mighta been a Pazz & Jop contender.

L.P. Hovercraft (WmC), Saturday, 27 August 2011 14:12 (fourteen years ago)

yeah, too many long songs though...would have been way too lopsided and too much to digest.

Iago Galdston, Saturday, 27 August 2011 14:27 (fourteen years ago)

I thought I would be burned out by now, but bro-in-law and I stayed up late last night with HOTH, PG, and Presence.

Brad C., Saturday, 27 August 2011 14:33 (fourteen years ago)

i hope there were copious drugs involved...two months on the narcotics wagon but i can still vaguely recall :(

Iago Galdston, Saturday, 27 August 2011 15:21 (fourteen years ago)

1. Achilles Last Stand
2. When the Levee Breaks
3. Houses of the Holy
4. Rain Song
5. The Ocean
6. Fool in the Rain
7. Since I've Been Lovin' You
8. Over the Hills and Far Away
9. Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
10. Bron Yr Aur
11. Bron Y Aur Stomp
12. Rock And Roll
13. Ten Years Gone
14. Misty Mountain Hop
15. Black Dog
16. Heartbreaker
17. Ramble On
18. That's the Way
19. Whole Lotta Love
20. Immigrant Song

ablaeser, Sunday, 28 August 2011 03:59 (fourteen years ago)

When The Levee Breaks
Dancing Days
Travelling Riverside Blues
Dazed And Confused
How Many More Times
The Battle Of Evermore
Immigrant Song
Over the Hills and Far Away
Ramble On
Wearing And Tearing
Trampled Under Foot
The Ocean
Out On The Tiles
That's The Way
In The Evening
Houses Of The Holy
Communication Breakdown
Four Sticks
Your Time Is Gonna Come
Fool In The Rain

strident gumrakers (Drugs A. Money), Sunday, 28 August 2011 06:18 (fourteen years ago)

yikes just realized how 'Get the Led Out' my ballot really was

FROXB NEWS (Drugs A. Money), Sunday, 28 August 2011 06:35 (fourteen years ago)

that a self-proclaimed Get The Led Out ballot still doesn't include "Whole Lotta Love" speaks volumes about this poll

some dude, Sunday, 28 August 2011 17:43 (fourteen years ago)


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.