We Become Panoramic - THE KATE BUSH RESULTS THREAD (ilm artist poll #24)

http://img853.imageshack.us/img853/2817/1334682634a859291167437.jpg

LOOK no one said I had to choose a favourite Kate Bush album, okay? No one said I HAD TO CHOOSE. No one said that.

― Bassment Jacks (Bimble...), Wednesday, October 11, 2006 5:03 AM (5 years ago)

Alternate titles subsequently thought better of:

IrgendPOLL in der tiefe
Suspended in Gallup
100% tracks by female artists

I was going to have a gallop through these to finish tomorrow, but forgot this was a bank holiday here. So I'm going to do albums and 50-41 today, and twenty each tomorrow and Wednesday.

But first: luncheon!

ALBUMS

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/e/ea/Kate_Bush_Lionheart.jpg

7. LIONHEART (1978)
3 points, one vote

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/9e/Kate_Bush_The_Sensual_World.jpg

6. The Sensual World (1989)
17 points, five votes

Suspended in Gallup

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b2/The_Kick_Inside_UK_cover.jpg

5. THE KICK INSIDE
23 points, five votes, two no.1s

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/1/14/Kate_Bush_Never_Forever.jpg

4. NEVER FOR EVER
32 points, eight votes

27 people voted for albums btw, it's fair to say that the big scorers are yet to come

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b4/Katebushaerial.jpg

3. AERIAL (2005)
71 points, seventeen votes, two no.1s

Come on The Dreaming. Kick that Hounds' arse.

i likes me some Aerial, but so far ahead of Never For Ever is kerazy

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/0/05/Kate_Bush_The_Dreaming_Cover.jpg

2. THE DREAMING (1982)
124 points, twenty-two votes, eleven no.1s

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/e/eb/Hounds_of_love.jpg

1. HOUNDS OF LOVE (1985)
135 points, twenty-three votes, twelve no.1s

Not troubling the scorers: The Whole Story, The Red Shoes, The Director's Cut, 50 Words For Snow

I'm going to get a spot of work done before starting tracks, but meantime: what should I do about youtube links? I want to link, but don't want to clog the thread up. I put youtu.be instead of youtube.com, is that right? Do I need to linkify it too?

Thanks for leading off with a Bimble quote. I'm glad he's with us in spirit.

Ismael, if you click the "share" button underneath any YouTube video, it will spit out a link that won't automatically bring the video into the thread.

Okay I've got one that ends _gdata_player, do I just paste that in and ilx does the rest?

Hmm, that I'm not sure; my techie skills are pretty sad. It seems the link they spit out with "share" is indeed just the regular link with the youtu.be substitution you mention above, now that I'm looking at it.

I'll play safe then rather than relying on cleverness. I'm doing this from my phone too, which adds another layer of things-to-go-wrong.

I expected the #1 and #2 spots to be a race between Hounds of Love and the Dreaming, but wasn't expecting Aerial to trounce Never for Ever so handily in the contest for #3!

TRACKS

http://img215.imageshack.us/img215/4981/0049aerial.jpg

49. Aerial
102 points, five votes
Aerial (2005)
youtube

"Aerial" over "Never For Ever"? Wow.

Is that an equal 49th?

Aerial is completely incredible though - that's the one I've been devouring most this past week. I ended up with it as my no.1, though in fairness I could've had any of the top three there.

i think what's important is

I FEEL I WANNA BE UP ON THE ROOF

Yes xp, 49 is a tie, I'm not being eccentric. 46 is a three-way tie, and iirc 39 is a tie too; but I think above that they're all unique.

It hurt me not to vote for this track. Listening to it now, I should've just figured out a way to do it.

http://img822.imageshack.us/img822/3220/0049loveandanger.jpg

49. Love And Anger
102 points,  five votes
The Sensual World (1989)
youtube

think i dropped this from my ballot at the last minute :/

too low! guessing we'll see very little of The Sensual World or The Red Shoes then, & pretty much all of HOL.

I found a Sky of Honey's tracks even more problematic than the Ninth Wave's, as they are even more of a piece. Wonder if they might not suffer a bit as they end up being randomly chosen as placeholders for the entire album side.

Re. the albums, I tried really hard to reacquaint myself w the first three records. There may come a time that I love them -- the ballads, the theatricality of it all. But short of a few songs on Never For Ever, even with the re-listening these last few weeks, this isn't that time.

I've never gotten past the video for "Love and Anger," which was my introduction to Kate Bush. On another thread, I wrote this about TSW:

I'm still trying to get a grip on the whole thing, but the record opens very strong. On the whole, it still sounds a bit...overstuffed -- the video for "Love and Anger" indicated as much, featuring very LUSH optics, sparkly confetti and Dave Gilmour, who himself looks overstuffed.

Re. the albums, I tried really hard to reacquaint myself w the first three records. There may come a time that I love them -- the ballads, the theatricality of it all. But short of a few songs on Never For Ever, even with the re-listening these last few weeks, this isn't that time.

― Naive Teen Idol, Monday, August 27, 2012 8:37 AM (1 minute ago)

a selection of tracks from the first four albums = by far my favorite kate bush material

http://img507.imageshack.us/img507/2025/0046laketahoe.jpg

46. Lake Tahoe
103 points, five votes
50 Words For Snow (2011)
youtube

http://img822.imageshack.us/img822/467/0046wakingthewitch.jpg

46. Waking The Witch
103 points, five votes
Hounds of Love (1985)
youtube

and there's my first to place. i must admit, my primary reason for voting vor this was "wake up man".

these song images are awesome, BTW.

love "waking the witch". witchy part always freaks me out.

Thanks. Some relate to the songs, some don't - I let my mind wander a bit while I'm doing them.

these song images are awesome, BTW.

well that was yesterday well spent

working fine here

The album covers were fine.

same

oh dear, Egypt all the way down there at no. 62. i think it was my no. 3.

1. Hounds Of Love
2. Wuthering Heights
3. Violin
4. Suspended in Gaffa
5. The Big Sky
6. Delius (Song of Summer)
7. Moving
8. Don't Push Your Foot on the Heartbrake
9. Get Out of My House
10. How to Be Invisible
11. This Woman's Work
12. Leave It Open
13. Deeper Understanding
14. Hammer Horror
15. Jig Of Life
16. Waking The Witch
17. James and the Gold Gun
18. The Red Shoes
19. The Infant Kiss
20. King of the Mountain

Alfred I thought you liked Red Shoes more than Sensual World???

My ballot:

SONGS:

Hello Earth
The Dreaming
Hounds of Love
Nocturne
Night of the Swallow
Mother Stands For Comfort
Leave It Open
And Dream Of Sheep
The Sensual World
Breathing
Running Up That Hill
The Fog
Get Out Of My House
Sunset
Suspended In Gaffa
Moments of Pleasure
Army Dreamers
This Woman's Work
Cloudbusting
Moving

ALBUMS:

Hounds of Love
The Dreaming
Aerial

albums
the dreaming
never for ever
the sensual world

tracks
the sensual world
sat in your lap
running up that hill
get out of my house
violin
suspended in gaffa
the fog
cloudbusting
hounds of love
this woman’s work
breathing
love & anger
the kick inside
deeper understanding
king of the mountain
nocturn
hammer horror
feel it
big sky
don’t give up

Songs
1 Hello Earth
2 Night of the Swallow
3 Hounds of Love
4 The Kick Inside
5 The Sensual World
6 Suspended in Gaffa
7 Rocket's Tail
8 Aerial
9 Jig of Life
10 December Will Be Magic Again
11 Delius (Song of Summer)
12 Experiment IV
13 The Dreaming
14 Hammer Horror
15 Never Be Mine
16 Running Up That Hill
17 Nocturn
18 The Morning Fog
19 Somewhere in Between
20 Be Kind to My Mistakes

Albums
1 Hounds of Love
2 Aerial
3 The Dreaming

Only surprise for me was that the track the Kick Inside didn't place higher than that, and shouldn't December Will Be Magic Again have 43 points and not 22? Me and one other person voted for it in slots 10 and 11 respectively.

i love aerial but i am kinda surprised by just how well it did here, i do wonder how much of that is maybe for a large segment of ilx it was the first kate bush lp they experienced first hand so to speak.

Aerial is classic, proven by science!

I just can't believe I was all secretly "I wish she'd do another Ninth Wave type thing, except better" and she did.

Er...there was some love for In Search of Peter Pan, IK. It was at 12 in my poll:

1 This Woman's Work
2 Night of the Swallow
3 Running Up That Hill
4. Cloudbusting
5 Deeper Understanding
6 Lake Tahoe
7 The Sensual World
8 Under The Ivy
9 Jig of Life
10 Snowflake
11 The Infant Kiss
12 In Search of Peter Pan
13 Moving
14 Symphony in Blue
15 December WIll Be Magic Again
16 Wuthering Heights
17 Experiment IV
18 All We Ever Look For
19 Get Out of My House
20 Nocturn

Albums:

1 Hounds of Love
2 Never For Ever
3 Lionheart

Stuff that came very close to making my ballot:

The Saxophone Song
In Search of Peter Pan
Delius (Song of Summer)
Egypt
Pull Out The Pin
All The Love
Jig of Life
Experiment IV
Never Be Mine
Lily
A Coral Room
Somewhere In Between
Aerial
Snowflake
Lake Tahoe

was not able to submit a ballot because of weird irl issues this past weekend but here was my prelim untangled ballot
The Man with the Child in His Eyes
Wuthering Heights
Babooshka
Delius (Song of Summer)
Blow Away (For Bill)
All We Ever Look For
Egypt
The Wedding List
Violin
Army Dreamers
breathing
Sat in Your Lap
There Goes a Tenner
pull out the pin
Suspended in Gaffa
leave it open
The Dreaming
hounds of love
cloudbusting
the sensual world

Unranked

A couple of corrections in the minor slots:

December Will Be Magic Again - four votes and 81 points
In Search Of Peter Pan - two votes and 34 points

Don't keep 'em coming

1. This Woman's Work
2. Them Heavy People
3. The Man with the Child in His Eyes
4. Deeper Understanding
5. The Sensual World
6. And Dream of Sheep
7. Joanni
8. Suspended in Gaffa
9. Army Dreamers
10. How to Be Invisible
11. Rocket Man
12. Pull Out the Pin
13. In the Warm Room
14. Breathing
15. Mrs Bartolozzi
16. Mother Stands for Comfort
17. There Goes a Tenner
18. Wuthering Heights
19. Somewhere in Between
20. Babooshka

i don't love Hounds of Love as much as a lot of you i guess

I didn't vote (I only knew "Hounds of Love" and a handful of other songs here and there) but had a lot of fun following the results and finally getting around to hearing more of Kate Bush's music. Great poll, thanks Ismael!

Bold didn't place, including my #1 sadly.

1. Why Should I Love You?
2. Wuthering Heights
3. Running Up That Hill
4. This Woman's Work
5. Cloudbursting
6. Moments of Pleasure
7. Watching You Without Me
8. An Architect's Dream
9. Army Dreamers
10. And Dream of Sheep
11. The Dreaming
12. There Goes a Tenner
13. The Big Sky
14. Hounds of Love
15. Bertie
16. Rocket Man
17. Man With The Child In His Eyes
18. Misty
19. Breathing
20. Them Heavy People

Albums

1, Hounds of Love
2. The Dreaming
3. Aerial

i love aerial but i am kinda surprised by just how well it did here, i do wonder how much of that is maybe for a large segment of ilx it was the first kate bush lp they experienced first hand so to speak.

Process of elimination for me. HOL is her only perfect album for me. I even regret sticking TSW on my list.

1. Feel It
2. The Man with the Child in His Eyes
3. L'Amour Looks Something like You
4. Cloudbusting
5. Running Up That Hill
6. Snowflake
7. Night Scented Stock
8. A Coral Room
9. Oh to Be in Love
10. Wuthering Heights
11. In the Warm Room
12. Nocturn
13. Army Dreamers
14. Lake Tahoe
15. Night of the Swallow
16. Mother Stands for Comfort
17. The Dreaming
18. The Kick Inside
19. Misty
20. Wow

ALBUMS

1. The Kick Inside
2. Hounds of Love
3. Aerial

Hmph. Totally would've preferred Cloudbusting or Hounds as #1. I'm always glad to hear Running, but it's never been one of my Kate faves. Anyway, here's mine. Think everything placed except the two Red Shoes tracks.

Jig of Life
The Dreaming
The Man With the Child in His Eyes
Wuthering Heights ('86 version)
Nocturn
Leave It Open
Cloudbusting
Breathing
Hello Earth
The Sensual World
Hounds of Love
Night of the Swallow
Waking the Witch
Sat in Your Lap
Snowflake
Lily
Get Out of My House
Pull Out the Pin
Top of the City
Experiment IV

ALBUMS
The Dreaming
Hounds of Love
Aerial

And great poll, IK. Thanks. The pictures were gorgeous.

this poll has made me realise how much attention i should have paid to All The Love, amazing bit of work.

LET'S EXCHANGE THE EXPERIENCE

Nocturn
Running Up That Hill
Cloudbusting
Hounds of Love
Suspended in Gaffa
The Morning Fog
One Last Look Around The House Before We Go
Love and Anger
Rubberband Girl
Big Sky
This Woman's Work
Breathing
Experiment IV
A Coral Room
Jig of Life
The Fog
Heads We're Dancing
The Man with the Child in his Eyes
Symphony in Blue
Big Stripey Lie

albums
Hounds of Love
Aerial
The Dreaming

if this poll happened a week ago i would've been mondo annoyed at running's placement. it always left me cold. but i happened to hear it on the radio while driving last night and i was like 'damn this owns doesnt it' so i guess it finally clicked. still think wuthering not being #1 is mild challops (i might've voted for gaffa tho)

Very belated thanks to IK for running this and for the beautiful rollout.

My ballot:
Tracks
01 The Sensual World
02 The Dreaming
03 Rocket's Tail
04 The Man with the Child in His Eyes
05 Sat in Your Lap
06 King of the Mountain
07 Army Dreamers
08 Leave It Open
09 The Infant Kiss
10 The Red Shoes
11 Get Out of My House
12 All the Love
13 Moments of Pleasure
14 Delius (Song of Summer)
15 Suspended in Gaffa
16 Nocturn
17 Deeper Understanding
18 Houdini
19 Them Heavy People (On Stage EP version)
20 Ken

Albums
01 The Dreaming
02 Aerial
03 The Sensual World

Many thanks to Ismael forSam great poll. A bit late to followup, but...



*5. Wuthering Heights
617 points, twenty-two votes, three no.1s
The Kick Inside (1978) (two votes for The Whole Story (1986))
debut performance*

On the original, the way she phrases "It's me/Cathy, I've come home" leaves her running out of breath by the time she reaches "I'm" (it's already an odd phrasing, putting the "I'm" in the line with "home" instead of "So cold" but the clipped way she sings it makes it even odder). But on the remake, her superior breath control allows her to extend the "ee's" of "me" and "Cathy" so that she can go straight into a hugely powerful "Co-o-o-ollld." That in turn allows her to use the line "Let me in-a-your window" as the climax of the chorus instead of the kind of tag it serves as in the original.

Not altogether unlike Sinatra ca. the Capitol recordings, the skill of her singing by this time was at its absolute peak. And on this, it allows her to fundamentally transform not just the feel of one of her best-known songs into something even more powerful and natural -- but the melody itself. It's amazing.

Yeah, but a) the original sounds like a crazy person singing alien music whereas in '86 it just sounds like Kate Bush, b) there's a MIDIVerb or something on the '86 version that makes it sound as if she's singing in a bathroom instead of on a wild and windy moor, c) one needs to hear how untamed her voice was on those early singles to really appreciate the subsequent "soft focus" approach to her singing on "Lionheart" moving into the high drama of "Never For Ever".

I'm 100% in favour of remixing and revising and think more people should do it. Even when it creates crap, which it does, like 90% of the time, having a polished-up crap version only sharpens the ingenuity of the original

(Not calling '86 "Kick Inside" vocal takes crap, mind)

I love her. My revised list of her best.

Great list, A+

Yep, excellent list, Alfred.

alfred you don't own the Kick Inside or Lionheart???

I own TKI but not Lionheart, don't relish playing the former except as exceptional demos

Lionheart is worth picking up for a few choice songs (Kashka, coffee homeground, the title track).

The Kick Inside is awesome.

Her catalog is awesome.

I like the love you showed for Aerial, but I don't think I will ever understand the gushing that the Dreaming receives. It's a weird dynamic; most casual fans don't rate it at all, but of the more serious fans that do rate it, the overwhelming majority seem to overrate the ever-loving hell out of it. It's a pretty good album, but considering the next two records she released after it, it's very mediocre in comparison.

A Sky of Honey is the greatest thing ever

Trying to imagine a world in which The Dreaming sounds mediocre compared to The Sensual World.

It's not a terribly sensual one, to be honest.

Given how much of a favourite it is of Kate's, having been picked for the live shows, it's surprising how badly Lily did.

didn't rank '50 Words for Snow'?

Trying to imagine a world in which The Dreaming sounds mediocre compared to The Sensual World.

― Tim F, Tuesday, September 11, 2018 12:43 AM (seven hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I'm with you. Or any record of hers after HoL for that matter.

A Sky of Honey is the greatest thing ever

― ufo, Monday, September 10, 2018 8:56 PM (yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

i won't hear any sensual world slander, idk how anyone can not get immediately enveloped in it, the way its textures sprout up & spread out like a landscape in the fog

to use the ready-made image lol

I like the love you showed for Aerial, but I don't think I will ever understand the gushing that the Dreaming receives. It's a weird dynamic; most casual fans don't rate it at all, but of the more serious fans that do rate it, the overwhelming majority seem to overrate the ever-loving hell out of it. It's a pretty good album, but considering the next two records she released after it, it's very mediocre in comparison.

― Totally different head. Totally. (Austin), Monday, September 10, 2018 11:12 PM (yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

this, except for Hounds of Love

tbh same

A Sky of Honey is the greatest thing ever

― ufo, Monday, September 10, 2018 8:56 PM (yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

― princess of hell (BradNelson), Tuesday, September 11, 2018 1:39 PM (three hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

otm

I think The Sensual World is great but The Dreaming is monumental.