based on baseball almanac there have been 59 team names associated with the current roster of active mlb organizations. since we can only do 50 options i've instituted a few rules to get down to 50:
-1891 cutoff date (sorry fans of the gothams, alleghenys, brown stockings, red caps, red stockings, trolley dodgers, white stockings... if you want to vote for one of these vote for their current team and let us know in the comments)
-rays/devil rays have been combined into one entry (but note that reds/redlegs were not)
-indians have been left off, obviously, but you can vote for the guards
feel free to take into account the associated aesthetic and branding, which can be challenging for the 1890s/early 1900s teams. rank a top 5 or 10 or all 59 if you want. the important thing is to have fun. let's play ball!
Poll Results
| Option | Votes |
| beaneaters (boston) | 3 |
| orphans (chicago) | 2 |
| giants (san francisco, new york) | 1 |
| bridegrooms (brooklyn) | 1 |
| expos (montreal) | 1 |
| bees (boston) | 1 |
| brewers (milwaukee) | 1 |
| pilots (seattle) | 0 |
| pirates (pittsburgh) | 0 |
| rangers (texas) | 0 |
| yankees (new york) | 0 |
| phillies (philadelphia) | 0 |
| perfectos (st louis) | 0 |
| padres (san diego) | 0 |
| orioles (baltimore) | 0 |
| red sox (boston) | 0 |
| redlegs (cincinnati) | 0 |
| white sox (chicago) | 0 |
| twins (minnesota) | 0 |
| tigers (detroit) | 0 |
| superbas (brooklyn) | 0 |
| senators (washington) | 0 |
| rustlers (boston) | 0 |
| royals (kansas city) | 0 |
| rockies (colorado) | 0 |
| robins (brooklyn) | 0 |
| reds (cincinnati) | 0 |
| nationals (washington) | 0 |
| naps (cleveland) | 0 |
| colt .45s (houston) | 0 |
| cardinals (st louis) | 0 |
| browns (st louis) | 0 |
| braves (atlanta, milwaukee, boston) | 0 |
| blues (cleveland) | 0 |
| blue jays (toronto) | 0 |
| athletics (sacramento, oakland, kansas city, philadelphia) | 0 |
| astros (houston) | 0 |
| angels (los angeles, anaheim, california) | 0 |
| colts (chicago) | 0 |
| cubs (chicago) | 0 |
| mets (new york) | 0 |
| marlins (miami, florida) | 0 |
| mariners (seattle) | 0 |
| highlanders (new york) | 0 |
| guardians (cleveland) | 0 |
| doves (boston) | 0 |
| dodgers (los angeles, brooklyn) | 0 |
| diamondbacks (arizona) | 0 |
| devil rays / rays (tampa bay) | 0 |
| americans (boston) | 0 |
― 龜, Friday, 18 April 2025 15:55 (six months ago)