Murakami vs Mishima

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed

Murakami vs Mishima

Poll Results

OptionVotes
Mishima11
Murakami 8


xyzzzz__, Friday, 8 August 2008 22:32 (seventeen years ago)

Er, we'll find out the result next year bcz I can't type at this time of night. Shouldn't stop anyone from talking tho'

xyzzzz__, Friday, 8 August 2008 22:33 (seventeen years ago)

They both have done great bits of writing, but they both also annoy me frequently. But there must be somethign like despite that, as I keep being tempted back. I do think Murakami is wildly over-rated, though.

James Morrison, Saturday, 9 August 2008 03:02 (seventeen years ago)

Could the thread author tell me why he has grouped these two authors in a poll together beause it doesn't really make any sense, the don't have much in common besides being japanese

bell_labs, Saturday, 9 August 2008 03:58 (seventeen years ago)

Its not much more than 'being Japanese'. I know they're different, and that I would have set up Mishima against someone like Kawabata if I wanted similarity.

Thread is based on a throwaway comment I read on a puff piece on Murakami I happened to glance a couple of weeks ago where he said he hated Mishima. That kind of set me thinking that these two seem to be the more prominent authors to come out of post-war Japan and yet they couldn't be more different in terms of interests (ok I haven't Murakami's bk on the Tokyo gas attacks where there could be some overlap?)

Plus this place does need more polls.

xyzzzz__, Saturday, 9 August 2008 14:01 (seventeen years ago)

I perhaps enjoy Murakami more but Mishima is waaaaay the better writer.

Noodle Vague, Saturday, 9 August 2008 22:12 (seventeen years ago)

I've read very little of Mishima's writing, but liked it and have always meant to dig deeper. I've read TONS of Murakami, on the other hand, but find him increasingly tedious (assume we're talking Haruki and not Ryu).

It's hard to evaluate writing in translation, though. There are two primary translators of Murakami's short fiction that I'm familiar with (can't remember their names, don't wanna dig), and I've noticed that I much prefer the stories tranlated by Translator X to those by Translator Y. Wonder how much of clunky flatness that I find so offputting in the novels is due to the author and how much to the translators. (Given that clunky flatness seems to be a big part of Murakami's style, I mean.)

HM's long essay on running in the New Yorker a few weeks back was one of the more boring things ever published in that magazine.

contenderizer, Sunday, 10 August 2008 00:20 (seventeen years ago)

^There have been three major Murakami English translators--Alfred Birnbaum, Jay Rubin and Philip Gabriel. I'm not sure what it is -- they all seem to do "clunky flatness" at points--but I've liked all the Gabriel-translated ones the least. I'm totally unfamiliar with Japanese, so maybe it's just the selection (I remember reading a "translators roundtable" w/ Rubin and Gabriel where one of them wrote that they almost never have to compete for stories because they usually like different ones), but I'm curious if anyone else feels this way.

C0L1N B..., Sunday, 10 August 2008 00:29 (seventeen years ago)

I've never read the second volume of Underground, which was translated by Gabriel (the first volume is Birnbaum), which is probably a good way to compare them.

C0L1N B..., Sunday, 10 August 2008 00:31 (seventeen years ago)

The sarin-gas-attack book (Underground) was one of his I enjoyed the most, but partly just because the subject matter was so intrinsically interesting.

James Morrison, Sunday, 10 August 2008 08:28 (seventeen years ago)

Murakami's thing gets tiring, yeah -- I'll admit some of the events can be hold interest, and those pop cult refs keep you awake sometimes, but after a book and a half I struggle with those. If there is anything Beatles-like about it I go all negative.

Mishima, on the other hand...the themes he obsesses over and over again: the mourning at the loss of Japan's 'glorious' imperial past, the influence of the West, which he seems to hate yet he throws in an obsession with bodybuilding (surely something quite Western as oposed to learning Kendo, I know absolutely zilch about it)...now obv there is lots more, but right now I've read six books by him and could easily another sixty. But still there is a sense it could all become unreadable in a year so its a good thing this is set for 2009...:-)

xyzzzz__, Sunday, 10 August 2008 21:47 (seventeen years ago)

I know what you mean--I share almost NO beliefs with Mishima, but he's compelling.

James Morrison, Sunday, 10 August 2008 23:59 (seventeen years ago)

HM's long essay on running in the New Yorker a few weeks back was one of the more boring things ever published in that magazine.

was it excerpted from his new book? because i liked that a lot, although i could see how a chapter would be boring. or maybe i like it because it's boring.

i'll have to check who translated what again, but i'm pretty sure i like philip gabriel's work the best!

Jordan, Monday, 11 August 2008 14:45 (seventeen years ago)

gabriel and birnbaum, apparently.

i've never read any mishima, what's good?

Jordan, Monday, 11 August 2008 14:47 (seventeen years ago)

I've only read Confessions of a Mask, which I enjoyed well enough.

Casuistry, Monday, 11 August 2008 19:11 (seventeen years ago)

same here, it's the only mishima i've read and although i liked it i felt he was telling me a lot and not really showing me a lot (a problem i also recently had with stefan zwig). i've read a 4 murakami's and that's enough. it's unlikely i'll read anything else my him.

jed_, Tuesday, 12 August 2008 01:20 (seventeen years ago)

i started the sailor who fell etc., stopped after about 20 pages. would like to return to it, i didn't hate it, but decided i wasn't in the mood for a book like that at the time (i had also just finished reading woman in the dunes). never read any murakami.

impudent harlot, Tuesday, 12 August 2008 16:15 (seventeen years ago)

Is Woman in the Dunes anything like Mishima? From the film of it I wouldn't have thought so...

Yeah I agree he is telling me something quite basic. However its all in his expression of it.

I started on Confessions..., moved onto the The Sea of fertility (the tetralogy of novels he wrote later in his life). I'm about to start on a short story collection.

Just found a couple of Junichiro Tanizaki bks and Kawabata's Master of Go so I hope its all exciting stuff to absorb...

xyzzzz__, Thursday, 14 August 2008 20:59 (seventeen years ago)

kobo abe is nothing like mishima. abe is bonkers. surreal, insane, you name it. kafka x 10. i thought woman in the dunes was just unbelievably great. it haunted me for months after reading it.

scott seward, Thursday, 14 August 2008 23:19 (seventeen years ago)

mishima was literally bonkers insane but i know what you mean.

jed_, Saturday, 16 August 2008 16:28 (seventeen years ago)

mishima's BOOKS aren't all that bonkers though. or what i've read anyway. with abe you get plots like this:

"The unnamed narrator is a low-level employee at an office-supply firm who, in jest, proposes a new product called a Kangaroo Notebook. His assignment to produce a rough sketch of the notebook is interrupted, however, when he discovers, while eating breakfast, that radish sprouts are growing where his leg hair used to be. At a dermatology clinic, he meets a disturbingly seductive nurse, after which he is then strapped to a bed in an operating room and tranquilized. From this point, the narrator's experiences grow increasingly hallucinatory as he is released into the world with nothing more than a blanket and a hospital bed, which turns out to be a remarkable machine with its own agenda. Buffeted about, seemingly deprived of free will, the narrator lands in a corner of hell, where he takes a sulfur-spring cure and meets child-demons who perform for tourists and the villainous specter of his own mother. More than once, he is rescued by the nurse from the clinic, who, it turns out, collects blood for her own mysterious purposes and has a strange American boyfriend named Master Hammer Killer, who conducts research into sudden deaths."

"The principal character, nicknamed Mole, has converted a huge underground quarry into an "ark" capable of surviving the coming nuclear holocaust and is now in search of his "crew." He falls victim, however, to the wiles of his first crew members, a con man-cum-insect dealer and his two shills, one of them a pretty young woman. In the surreal drama that ensues, the ark is invaded by a gang of youths and a sinister group of elderly people called the Broom Brigade, led by Mole's odious father, while Mole gets his leg trapped in the ark's central piece of equipment, a giant toilet powerful enough to flush almost anything, including chopped-up humans, out to sea."

scott seward, Saturday, 16 August 2008 17:16 (seventeen years ago)

one month passes...

The appeal of Mishima (who I've always liked a lot) seems to me to be a bit like D H Lawrence. Both were pretty much quacks, but were so obsessed and committed to portraying their visions that their books are compelling, whether you're attracted to their "philosophies" or not. Murakami has his visions, etc., but the laid back thing suggests he fantasises about himself in the mould of a Raymond Chandler dude. So I guess in that sense, M + M are similar in that they have a strong vein of unapologetic vanity, but Mishima's pushes beyond Murakami's worldly vanity so that it becomes something grander, if that makes any sense. I'm tired.

David Joyner, Thursday, 18 September 2008 11:35 (seventeen years ago)

five months pass...

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

System, Saturday, 7 March 2009 00:01 (sixteen years ago)

Voting for the one I've read (Mishima).

Alex in SF, Saturday, 7 March 2009 00:09 (sixteen years ago)

I'm not voting because I've only read one Murakami book and so am not really qualified. Best thing about Murakami to me was that I had actually cooked pasta while listening to the overture from La Gazza Ladra about a month before reading Wind-up so I was basically really relating with the protagonist from the get go.

Really want to read Mishima though.

Blackout Crew are the Beatles of donk (jim), Saturday, 7 March 2009 01:14 (sixteen years ago)

Favourite Japanese writer on the basis of very little reading would be Oe tho.

Blackout Crew are the Beatles of donk (jim), Saturday, 7 March 2009 01:17 (sixteen years ago)

Can you recommend a book by Oe, btw?

I haven't voted so far! :-) Mishima it will be.

By Total coincidence I was just reading about the new production of Mishima's play Madame De Sade starring Judi Dench!

xyzzzz__, Saturday, 7 March 2009 10:20 (sixteen years ago)

The Oe I read first and that I liked the most was the four, very short, novellas "Prize Stock", "Teach Us to Outgrow Our Madness", "The Day He Himself Shall Wipe My Tears Away" and "Aghwee the Sky Monster" collected in this book:

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/71XQ9JNMBQL._SS500_.gif

The longest and best of those to me was "The Day He Himself Shall Wipe My Tears Away" which is the longest story, and maybe, the most nutty. Really cool unreliable narrator stuff going on in it.

Blackout Crew are the Beatles of donk (jim), Saturday, 7 March 2009 15:23 (sixteen years ago)

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

System, Sunday, 8 March 2009 00:01 (sixteen years ago)

Thanks for the recommendation jim.

xyzzzz__, Sunday, 8 March 2009 19:41 (sixteen years ago)

Scott, or anyone else, what Kobo Abe should I read? I have only read "Woman In The Dunes." I haven't read much Mishima either, but I feel i've at least sort of oriented myself towards his work.

ian, Tuesday, 10 March 2009 03:12 (sixteen years ago)

Another Oe I'd suggest is one of his earlier novels (may even be his first), Nip the Buds, Shoot the Kids. Adored this book, such that I now buy any Oe I see. The novel has what I still think of as quite a Japanese habit, and which I detect in Mishima but not so much in Murakami, which is an oddly distant, very "still" way of describing objects or aspects of physiognomy that seems to simultaneously treat them as strange, delicate, beautiful, while also importing something sinister... Does anyone else get this or am I on my own?

David Joyner, Tuesday, 10 March 2009 05:05 (sixteen years ago)

Abe to track down -- Face of Another

But read Mishima, Ian (glad he won my one and only poll, wasn't expecting it tbh)!

xyzzzz__, Tuesday, 10 March 2009 23:21 (sixteen years ago)

If people need Mishima recs:

- The Sea of Fertility tetralogy is a must-- Runaway Horses and Decay of the Angel are probably the best in that group.
- The Sailor Who Fell From Grace With The Sea-- gorgeous gorgeous prose.
- The Sound of Waves-- again, an A+
- Forbidden Colors-- hard to find, but an excellent look into gay Japanese life in the Shinjuku district in the 1950's. Really quite a brilliant book, way ahead of its time and rarely talked about in the canon of non-Western queer/gay lit.

I've read pretty much everything he ever wrote (during a deep depression, oddly), so if you want details, let me know. The only one I really don't like, possibly because of the translation and possibly because of the over-labored sense of detail, is Temple of the Golden Pavilion.

the table is the table, Wednesday, 11 March 2009 00:24 (sixteen years ago)

read this, ian:

http://www.randomhouse.com/catalog/covers_450/9780307389633.jpg

scott seward, Wednesday, 11 March 2009 15:20 (sixteen years ago)

or this:

http://www.randomhouse.com/catalog/covers_450/9780375726514.jpg

scott seward, Wednesday, 11 March 2009 15:22 (sixteen years ago)

Mishima thread

Mishima might have won the poll but I saw someone reading Murakami on the train today :-(

xyzzzz__, Wednesday, 11 March 2009 21:37 (sixteen years ago)

My roommate was flipping through my copy of the biography of her most famous compatriot, and getting angrier and angrier. It was affecting her English for the worse.

"Why he do that! Just, do somewhere, in private! Why he do that, that just ..."

[a struggle to express the ultimate transgression]

"... just ... make everyone ... FEEL BAD!"

alimosina, Saturday, 14 March 2009 04:42 (sixteen years ago)


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.