ILB writing workshop

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
It's only natural, isn't it? We have a book club; we've argued the merits of writing workshops. So I propose we start an experimental, utopian, barter-based fiction AND nonfiction writing workshop.

In my mind it would go something like this: instead of holding each other to our own pet theories about how stories work, we would pledge to judge each story by its own rules -- unless the piece obviously doesn't know its own rules, in which case we could feel free to suggest. Sort of a Crewesian, empiricist formula, I think, might free the proceedings of the authoritarian theory-flogging some of us have encountered in real workshops.

Another idea was that to keep people from wasting time on things the author already knows, each submission should get a "finishedness rating" on a scale of 1 to 10, 1 being "just a sketch of an idea, really" and 10 being "This has been rejected by more than one publisher and I'm bashing my head on the wall here, can anybody tell me what I'm doing wrong before I shoot myself?"

By "barter-based" I mean that in order to post a story for workshopping, you first must take a story already on the thread (I'll waive that rule for the first ten comers, for obvious reasons)and give your two cents' worth. Here's how we stay honest: no one need feel obliged to give your piece any more attention than you gave to the one you took on. People are obviously encouraged to gang-discuss stories, but so that the thread doesn't become bogged down with untouched submissions please use your sense of fair play in deciding whether a post in a really fascinating discussion counts as a trade.

Procedure:

Post the finishedness rating, then the opening of the story, then your real, current E-mail if it isn't there when you post normally, then maybe a short note (but plot synopses, probably no, unless it's nonfiction).Then any takers may E-mail you for the full draft; if there's a URL for it post that, lucky you. (Now that I think about it this thread will probably need to have lots of babies if it goes anywhere.)

Like so:

Finishedness: 9 (rejected by a couple publishers with some criticism that made me wish I had time to go over it a few times, but I'm too discouraged and have other projects)

LUCK

One morning Mr. Pearson threw his screaming wife in the Jaguar and tore away from the townhouse, crumpling a neighbor's garden gate and his own chassis as he swerved to avoid a jaywalking dowager; they barely made the hospital in time. But that afternoon the Jag staggered regally back to the garage, bearing man, wife, and a healthy baby boy, already named Charlie.

The Pearsons -- lovely people -- brought their bundle home, gave it a good long look, and were, per their habit, gently honest with each other.

“What a plain-looking baby!” said the missus, a retired supporting actress.

“Seen worse,” said the Mr., a Nobel-winning AIDS researcher with a frightening beak. “He looked a bit duller than the other babies in the ward, though.”

“Quite a bit duller,” said the mother. “And he has your nose, darling – do you still want a paternity test?”

(my e-mail below is correct)

Ann Sterzinger (Ann Sterzinger), Monday, 15 March 2004 21:05 (twenty-two years ago)

Another rule: If you steal an idea, either you discuss it with the originator or the Ghost of Oscar Wilde comes to your house and turns you into a "lonely high-court judge." (Thank you, Morrissey!)

And -- Aw heck, I'll put up a nonfiction example too (first ten other comers are still freebies, I'll quit now unless nobody bites):

finishedness: -1 (these few graphs aren't even coherent yet, and the "first draft" is now mostly quotes typed in from listening to the album in question while drunk on red wine)

After dying in such infamy that his two sons had to live under false surnames, what gifts and lessons did Oscar Wilde leave for later writers?

Woo. You’d need the cranium of Jeeves -- the fish-guzzling valet created by 20th-century comic novelist P.G. Wodehouse -- to tackle that. Or perhaps you could skate by on the youthful, aristocratic ignorance of peril so wittily parlayed into social criticism by the antiheroes of Saki -- a dandified short-story master and more obvious disciple to Wilde. TK ANOTHER EXAMPLE. You could even rely on the everyone’s-an-18-year-old-to-me hubris of the professorly types brought to life by Kingsley Amis, David Lodge, Julian Barnes, and other academic novelists, shlumpier in appearance but similar in attitude to Wilde’s condescending-father figures, the [from D.G.] and Erskines. Such profly combination of hubris and real expertise has been called upon enough times, in fiction and real life, in books and right in front of my sleeping corpse in a classroom, to scare off a thousand mercenaries of my variety. Though the humorless teacup tragedies that university litfic presses can’t seem to get down the gullets of the Stateside public make you “[Wilde quote for wonder?]”, one then looks at Anglophones overseas and says to oneself, “more than you can ever comprehend, mousebrain.”

So, being human, I’ll pick a – hopefully – smaller field: what the bard of Reading Gaol did for bedroom pop. Yeah, maybe it only looks safer because there aren’t as many bodies strewn on it, but any grave’s better than a mass trench. And I’ve picked a screamingly obvious steed to ride in on: Craig Simmons, keyboardist for Electrosquad, forsake the bittersweet Australian synthpop outfit for an indie-inflected solo project called Space March last year and named one of the songs on its eponymous debut “Dorian Grey.”

But, as Jeeves’s young master Wooster might say, whoah there, Simmons. You’re already bearing me toward the hospital, and the enemy doesn’t even know where the battle is yet.

Ann Sterzinger (Ann Sterzinger), Monday, 15 March 2004 21:18 (twenty-two years ago)

Ann, you aren't helping me kick this fictional crush any.

Jerry the Nipper (Jerrynipper), Monday, 15 March 2004 23:34 (twenty-two years ago)

Does the fact that I look like Golem help?

Ann Sterzinger (Ann Sterzinger), Monday, 15 March 2004 23:37 (twenty-two years ago)

IT MAKES IT EVEN WORSER.

Jerry the Nipper (Jerrynipper), Monday, 15 March 2004 23:39 (twenty-two years ago)

Well, if it helps any, I really do exist but the nonfictional Ann is much boringer and whiny and small and petty and evil.

Ann Sterzinger (Ann Sterzinger), Monday, 15 March 2004 23:43 (twenty-two years ago)

Nobody wants to do this?

Snif.

Oh well.

Ann Sterzinger (Ann Sterzinger), Friday, 19 March 2004 02:57 (twenty-two years ago)

Actually I do want to do this, just been kind of busy lately/forgetting to check this thread.

My email is correct after you de-spam-proof it.

Finishedness: 4

And then the angels carry him away

The end of the world was a stony beach where he roved naked, beyond the pull of the tide. Footing was uneven, so his knees kept knocking against one another. Every time he shot out an arm to balance himself the medical bracelet slid along the parallel scars on his wrist, as a reminder, but instead he listened for the waves, susurrus caresses, along the shore, softer than her hair. Like angels singing to him. All the time left in the world, he said to the angels. Engulfed into the swelling waters – the cold at first crushed a heavy ache into his bones, but then like the prick of a needle, it gave away to numbness – he said goodbye having set her free, but in turn bound himself to the sea.

The bus bumped across the road with the window rattling against his head, a sound of harsh coughing glass like cackling. It gave him a headache. Everyone stared out of the corners of their eyes at his wrists, so at the next stop, he left and walked the remaining way to the beach.

When his eyelids snapped open like a porcelain doll’s, she was by his side, half seated, half sprawled onto the bed, a hand resting on his chest. The fluorescent light above him cut high shadows across his face, carving out his cheeks while his eyes sank into black pools. He was so pale his head was just a shadow on the pillow. Fresh bandages bound each wrist, and against the white hospital sheets, he looked like an amputee. She barely recognized him.

O.Leee.B. (Leee), Friday, 19 March 2004 04:30 (twenty-two years ago)


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.