What's the best Zelda game then?

oo, here Taking Sides: Zelda, Ocarina of Time or Zelda, Majora's Mask?

But it's hard to beat what Zelda the first was at the time. For its context, and in its time and place, it was the best and it doesn't seem fair to ask it to stand up to the later Zelda games.

Ocarina was fun, but I do not worship it as others seem to.

Ocarina's dungeons were better as well, Edge review said something like ocarina's dungeons are more holisitic and you need to think abt how an action in one room would affect the whole dungeon whereas windwakes dungeons were more abt just single-room puzzles. I read that review before i actually played windwaker so it probably clouded/informed my opinion but it seems to be partly true.

I bought minish cap a couple of weeks ago but advance wars DS has kept me away from it.

Majora's Mask was very interesting and I didn't get very far in it before I needed to put it down. But I will try it again later. Wind Waker had some nice bits to it but it felt very paint-by-numbers, theme-wise.

Original Zelda is still completely great, especially since it was one of the few games I finished as a kid.

Link's Awakening drives me batty because I always wind up just goofing around with the map warp trick.

Was it included on that GC comp of eight trillion Zelda games?

Wind Waker was so much about being chugged along to your inevitable and easy-to-accomplish destiny that it couldn't possibly have felt upsetting.

??? The eventual fate of 95% of Hyrule isn't incredibly depressing?

http://www.dailygame.net/Articles/media/screens/zeldaww/zeldaww3.jpg

OMG

Sigh.

Anyway, I just finished Minish Cap, which was pretty awesome, although about half as long as I expected it to be. (It was silly of me to expect that.)

Windwaker is gorgeous, not just because the cel shading looks great but the music! The new tunes are lilting, sweet, seaworthy lovliness.

the water temple level = best use of "3D" I've encountered in a game.

It did do a number on my fingers on the DS, bah.

i love the way this game looks.

MY, WAS THAT REVENGE SWEET.

What I've played of Ocarina struck me as pedestrian and mundane, but Wind Waker is damn lovely because it's so twee and classic-looking. I think I mentioned elsewhere that the dialogue for WW was among the best that I've encountered in a video game. The final ending had me choking up!

TOTALLY. I always lose 80% of my health fighting those bastards, even with the bonus giant spin attack! And so then fighting vaati with fuckall health is hopeless :(

I am, I must add, pretty shite at eye-hand co-ord tho.

I'll try that tactic you suggest Tom, sounds like it might help.

If my hand doesnt fall of first that is - Ive been getting shooting pains in my right hand recently heh meep.

It's not a game you can come back to after a month, or even a week, because it takes about a day to remember what the fuck you're supposed to be doing. It is an amazing game though.

I accidentally wiped my Ocarina save, as well, just before I got to the end.

People can go on about Wind Waker being easy and simple compared to past Zelda's all they wish, but I can honestly say I probably haven't had such a pleasant experience just playing through a game hardly ever. I think it was one of the first times I played a game where everything seemed to fit, in a lot of ways. It was so totally immersive in a "oh, this is how games should look!" because it just seems so much more successful to create a world like that rather than one of giant people getting in tiny cars and driving around mini cities.

I hated the last boss of Minish Cap, it took me a while to beat him, and really infuriated me. I lent the game to a friend of mine once, and they got stuck on the last boss and asked me to try. Which was daunting, because after beating the game I'd been like "HA! I don't have beat you EVER AGAIN! YOU COCK!". I was drunk at the time, and couldn't remember what I was supposed to do, lost practically all my health on the first section, but still ended up beating him. It was my proudest gaming moment, and I in no way drunkenly re-enacted it whilst pretending to Link later on in the night.

In no way did that happen.

DS Zelda looks so pretty. I need to remember to stop leaving my DS at people's houses.

i also gave up wind waker earlier this year, due to i) annoying bugs like not recognising that i have the right kind of arrow to get to a particular island ii) annoyance at the whole pirate girl is zelda, is a girl, therefore is useless at everything bit. what with her saving yr ass several times before she turns out to be zelda. (which also = oh, didn't see that coming.)

How is Zelda/pirate useless at everything again?

Mind you I didn't see the identity of Zelda coming, they did quite a nice fake with the little rich girl there.

LEGEND OF ZELDA: THE PHANTOM HOURGLASS

...

forthcoming on DS, with wind waker-style visuals (!!!)

Proceed to have Link beat the crap out of Zelda: "send ME all around Hyrule slaying monsters because you're always getting kidnapped and locked in dungeons! I'll show YOU who the beeyatch is!" *smack kick bash slash etc etc*

Oh, we did laugh.

x posts bcz i don't check this board v often oops.

Zelda 2 is massively underrated.

― Alex in Novosibirsk (ex machina), Tuesday, November 1, 2005 3:20 PM (2 years ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

^^^ this dude knows what's up

replayed the first three zeldas this weekend and link to the past is apparently ingrained in my muscle memory now!? total cliche to bemoan remembering where all the keys in the misery mire are but then not remember w/e relevant to yr actual life but, still, true. kind of robbed the game of any feeling of real accomplishment like a doing a crossword puzzle with the answer key in front of you.

zelda 2 rpg elements are clever w/o being too much of a concession to what is a challenging action game. pretty genious level design too.

I loved having to search the map for hidden p-bags etc -- broke the tedium of level grinding

I'm playing through Zelda on the wii. Excellent game so far and I'm a little more than halfway through.
The epicness of flute boy on the classic SNES zelda game has yet to be recreated. I was like damn, the poor kid turned to stone and is doomed to forever be stone. They don't make those kind of subplots anymore. I will always say SNES version is the best Zelda release but the Wii version is definitely worth checking out. It trumps the gamecube and n64 links imo. Well, it barely beats Ocarina of Time and I never played Majora's Mask, but the boss battles are much more fun now.

So I got a DS lately, included phantom hourglass and i thought i'd opt for Minish Cap which i never played.

PH isn't great, has some nice ideas but the stylus to control the movement isn't doing it for me - especially if i want to move top left and so my hand obscures the screen!

MC on the other hand is a thing of beauty, my fave zelda has always been link to the past. how did i miss this one.

Minish Cap is indeed awesome, and it broke my heart. I bought it at a Shanghai bootleg street market for like 3 dollars. I got pretty deep into the game, maybe 10 hours or so, and then it erased my saved game. I'm the kind of person who needs a 4-5 year cooling off period with a game after something like that happens, so I'm on schedule to purchase a legit copy of Minish Cap and play it again around 2010-11.

Agreed with Phantom Hourglass. It was pleasant enough, but not close to Link of the Past style gameplay.

link to the past rules - o.g. zelda is super mystical ultimately

minish cap is so great

I think phantom hourglass would have been equally great, were dpad control allowed :(:(:(:(:(:(:(:(

Zelda is the only reason, I bought a DS. I wish I could buy a wii so I could play Zelda on it, but I don't have a television.

I actually really liked Phantom Hourglass - by the end, I was disappointed there wasn't more. Stylus input was weird, but I got used to it pretty quickly, and I liked the natural mapping/course sailing. That dungeon you had to keep revisiting was a wonderful idea, I hope they expand on it in the sequel.

http://27.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_ljm7b9RKgG1qaw7zqo1_500.gif

some kind of chocolate bar?

infinitely more excited for Link's Awakening on 3DS than Skyward Sword

Well yeah, 6% excited is technically infinitely more than 0% excited, so me too I guess.

Well yeah, 6% excited is technically infinitely more than 0% excited, so me too I guess.

no it's 6% more, not infinitely! :/ MATHPEDANTED

guys

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hs9Lly3HDgk

Lost my copy of minish cap ;_;

And Phantom Hourglass ended up being kind of crap - those ENDLESS UNBEATABLE DUNGEONS omg.

The evening breeze
Caressed the trees
Kennerly

nerd bonerz

when I'm president I'm going to make a law that goes as follows: all games shipped will be the legend of zelda: ocarina of time. what this means in practice: you and your game development company can work on your game for as long as you want, spend as much money as you want on it, draw those polygons and texture maps real fucking good. but when you send it to the game factory that presses the DVDs, the factory will instead press the legend of zelda: ocarina of time onto your DVD and that will ship to the store. vote for me 2016.

I'm voting for you in 2012, the world needs this powerful message NOW

I wd play this game
http://i.imgur.com/fG2zu.jpg

is skyward sword worthwhile? have been told that it has some of the best dungeons of any zelda game, but have also been told it doesn't match up to the other 3d ones in general

fwiw my favorite zelda games are link's awakening and majora's mask so i'm not necessarily looking for the same things out of a zelda game that all the LTTP&ocarina4ever people are

let's get it on:
ILX Plays: The Legend of Zelda for NES

Everyone familiar with Link to the Past should really give this a shot. It's loads of fun!

vt.alttp.run/randomizer

Basically, they've developed a way to generate roms (seeds) that randomly redistribute all of the progression items, and you have to figure out where to go based on what you have to work with. Having a complete knowledge of all chest and non-chest significant item locations is key to beating the seed. They also randomize the crystals and pendants, changing the order of the dungeons leading up to Ganon's tower. It's exciting to open mundane chests in Kakariko village with the possibility that you'll find the mirror or the hammer etc. There's a tournament right now in the community around these randomizers where people race the same seed and both have to figure out their route as they go. Gets pretty intense.

That's a url, by the way. Paste in your browser. Let me know if it doesn't make sense. I'm not a huge fan of the UI layout.

yeah randomizer hacks are all the rage right now for speedrun races, theres one for super metroid too

Sure is. I find the ALTTP one to be the most exciting, personally.

Damn I was sure this would excite someone. Assuming everyone's seen the post by now.

it sounds cool but honestly i kind of suck at zeldas in the first place, and then by "Having a complete knowledge of all chest and non-chest significant item locations is key to beating the seed" i knew it wasn't for me.

Well OK true that makes it sound daunting. It's also misleading, because it's no different than any other Zelda game that requires you to explore thoroughly. Also if you get hopelessly stuck you can check the spoiler readout if you want, which is handy.

I replayed ATTP about a decade ago, got about 2/3rds of the way through and had no idea what to do or where to go (old school lack of hand-holding) and dropped it. I probably wouldn't fare well with this

I watched a speed run with this hack, it was really exciting tbh

Well if anyone gave it a shot and needed a hand I'd be happy to help. Been a bit obsessed myself. Every seed is a fresh experience.